4 ms·
Totally agree, and Canada is worse - we have very few major cities to choose from, and the two major ones (Vancouver and Toronto) are insanely expensive to live
by mistermann 9y ago
Totally agree, and Canada is worse - we have very few major cities to choose from, and the two major ones (Vancouver and Toronto) are insanely expensive to live in on an affordability basis, due to the terrible wages Canadians enjoy compared to the US.
And worse, our already large but planned to increase annually immigration levels, much of which are wives and children of the world's 1%, who also coincidentally choose to live in the two cities above, essentially guarantees that working class people (by that I mean anyone that actually works for a living) will be eventually pushed out, unless some sort of a public dorm system is introduced.
- j-c-hewitt 9y agoRight... and the conventional 'working class' as in service workers, some factory workers, and the like have to live stacked up in probably-illegal conditions while the white collar 'working class' lives in tiny apartments paying as much in rent for a 1 bedroom as a guy with a lavish multi-hundred-acre horse farm estate with 8 bedrooms pays for his mortgage in the country.
- mistermann 9y agoAnd the cream on top: the white collar worker living in a shoebox is paying 40% income taxes while the estate owner has no taxable income, despite buying a few new $100k+ cars per year. And the government "doesn't see" any of this happening.
- toasterlovin 9y agoTo be fair, the accumulated wealth of the rich person has already been taxed.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe accumulation of wealth (income) has been, the accumulated wealth (property) has not (except insofar as they wealth is held in asset classes subject to property taxes.) Whether income alone, property alone, or some (and if so, what) particular combination of those two should be taxed is a matter of some debate.
- toasterlovin 9y agoYou have to buy assets. The income used to buy them has already been taxed. Then, whenever those assets generate further income, that additional income gets taxed. You can quibble about what the tax rates should be, but I was responding to somebody who made it sound like wealthy people pay no taxes, which is an utter misrepresentation of the situation.
- NervousTechno 9y ago> I was responding to somebody who made it sound like wealthy people pay no taxes, which is an utter misrepresentation of the situation. Who? Because that didn't happen.
- mistermann 9y ago> but I was responding to somebody who made it sound like wealthy people pay no taxes, which is an utter misrepresentation of the situation I wish you were right, however: https://globalnews.ca/news/3773729/richmond-incomes-downtown-eastside/ https://globalnews.ca/news/3773729/richmond-incomes-downtown... A huge percentage of recent sales are to overseas investors (untaxed money), most of the appreciation wealth is accumulated by people who bought > 10 years ago, so no tax as it is their primary residence. So even though it seems hard to believe, in fact the majority of the money in this system is untaxed. And if you're not familiar with the downtown eastside: https://www.straight.com/news/847631/photos-three-months-downtown-eastside-fentanyl-crisis-grows-bad-worse https://www.straight.com/news/847631/photos-three-months-dow...
- toasterlovin 9y agoI find it hard to complain too much about untaxed wealth in the form of primary residences. This is a vehicle that is available to vast swathes of the American & Canadian public. As such, it doesn’t really bolster the argument that wealthy people somehow pay less taxes, which is what I was responding to.
- mistermann 9y ago
- DamnYuppie 9y agoI believe taxation on capital gains from investments is much less then on salary. Also another fun game the wealthy can play is they can fund a company with large sums of capital. Then make themselves officers of the company. Then the cars, houses, flights, and clothing budgets are all expenses of the company. So they personally pay no taxes and the "company" can write them off as a lose for the year.
- mistermann 9y agoIf it was earned in Canada, which is increasingly not the case. How much, the government says it doesn't know. Funny that.
- madengr 9y agoMulti hundred acres horse farms cost a lot more than 1 bedroom apartments in SV.
- Density 9y agoOr more likely: a corporate town complete with a corporate store and dorms.