7 ms·
I'm not quite clear on why people are choosing spotify over google play music - to me the google option is superior in UI and offerings (including ad-free youtu
by komali2 9y ago
I'm not quite clear on why people are choosing spotify over google play music - to me the google option is superior in UI and offerings (including ad-free youtube).
Am I missing something? Is it just one runs better on iPhones or is more hip (like why people choose snapchat over instagram or something)?
- bllguo 9y agoI use GPM, but that's because of the bundling with Youtube Red. I would prefer Spotify for a desktop app, nicer looking UI IMO, and so Google doesn't know my music prefs. But for now, ad-free YT is too nice to give up.
- d1zzy 9y agoWhat operating system? I found Google Play Music Desktop Player to be pretty awesome (although it's just a browser underneath but it has much better integration with the rest of the system through themes, media keys) also native last.fm, lyrics, etc. https://www.googleplaymusicdesktopplayer.com/ https://www.googleplaymusicdesktopplayer.com/
- whymsicalburito 9y agoIt's the music discovery aspect of Spotify that is their game changer. They are constantly adding new ways to find new music.
- pm90 9y agoGoogle Play has good options for music discovery too... I stick to them mostly for their "Radio" option which is very good at selecting music similar to a song I'm listening to. That being said... I've been underwhelmed by the app's UI and performance and have given frequent feedback but haven't got any response and there has been no changes. Typical of Google... Its been so bad that I'm considering switching to Spotify soon. Its really annoying when you're trying to select some romantic music for dinner with your partner and the app keeps refusing to work.
- whymsicalburito 9y agoYea the radio features are pretty cool! Another thing I really enjoy about spotify is their app's ability to pause a song on my laptop at work and press play on my phone when I get in my car and the song picks up right where I left it. And the remote control functionality during parties is great. They're also experimenting with some "auto-DJ" features which don't do too bad of a job for an algorithm :)
- thomasfortes 9y agoSpotify is a music company, they care about it in a way that I don't think Google or Apple cares, this reflects on the dedication to the core of their product.
- Nullabillity 9y agoFor me it's: - Better discovery - Much cheaper (150kr/mo for 6 subscriptions, vs 100kr/mo for one with GPM) - A desktop client (even if it's a crappy electron one) - YTRed isn't available here anyway
- calcifer 9y agoNitpick, but Spotify isn't an Electron app, it uses CEF [1]. [1] https://bitbucket.org/chromiumembedded/cef https://bitbucket.org/chromiumembedded/cef
- unethical_ban 9y agoSpotify was first for on-demand streaming in the modern era, even before Google or Apple Music. Its radio/recommendations are better than Pandora, and I haven't tried others. I think Spotify's UI is fantastic, and its multi-device awareness is functional and intuitive. To your point, Google does have ad-free Youtube, but the ads don't bother me enough/I don't watch enough Youtube for it to impact me like it does with music. Finally, I like diversity sometimes; giving not-Google money is a plus, all other things being equal.
- kgwgk 9y ago> Spotify was first for on-demand streaming in the modern era I guess that’s true if you define the “modern era” as “starting with Spotify”.
- POTUS 9y agoHelp me out, I genuinely can't think of a music streaming service that came before Spotify. I vividly remember being blown away by their product when it came to market. I remember because I had never seen anything like it and literally didn't believe it could be done at that time. I was waiting for a train and could just search for any song and play it right away from my phone, no downloading, no waiting, just instant music. I was very sceptical beforehand but was instantly sold. Did I miss another service that did something even remotely similar before Spotify did it?
- komali2 9y agoPandora radio started in 2000 : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandora_Radio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandora_Radio Myspace was a popular way to share music, if limited. Youtube, again though this doesn't fully fit the definition. Anybody know about soundcloud? I know I was using that before I heard of spotify but I'm not sure if it came out beforehand.
- unethical_ban 9y agoPandora wasn't on demand until very recently. It was "station only". Myspace def. was limited and didn't have full catalogs of all music in any scope approaching Spotify. Youtube is video that has music, and can't be conveniently used on mobile or used for music discovery explicitly. Soundcloud is actually the closest to what I meant, but it obviously isn't used for record-label music distribution en masse.
- giarc 9y agoI was a longtime user of Google Play (Songza before that) on iPhone. I loved the playlist but the app was incredibly buggy. I was using the free version so I had ads. Often the ad wouldn't play and then freeze all playback, or the ad would play and then the music wouldn't start again. This made me very hesitant to pay a monthly subscription. I've switched to Amazon Music (free with my Prime membership) and although the app works well, the curated lists aren't as great. My point is that maybe other people have started with the free Google Play (Music?) app and had the same experience and looked for options elsewhere.
- alex504 9y agoI've recently tried out every major service: Google, Spotify, Apple Music, Tidal, and Amazon Prime. They are all insanely buggy. I was a Spotify user for about 6 years before this and it was buggy, and is getting buggier as far as I can tell.
- giarc 9y agoI've only been using the Amazon Music for a few weeks now but I haven't encountered many bugs. It just doesn't seem overly feature rich. Although the one very annoying thing I have encountered is that my Alexa device doesn't seem to have a list of all of the possible Playlists. For a time, there was one called "Top Prime Hits". I could play it on my phone, but when I asked Alexa "Play Top Prime Hits" it couldn't find it. I now have to pair my phone, play it on my phone and set output to my Alexa. Seems to defeat the purpose of voice with Alexa.
- alannala 9y agoAlso, I think there might be something in diversifying the companies you use online. It's a bit scary how much of ones life is wrapped up in about 5 companies these days... Google know enough already!
- jklinger410 9y agoAs someone who just made this choice, let me add some insight. - My friends use Spotify - Larger library - Well made playlists - Social feed In the end, they are very similar products. I feel that Spotify has a huge head start on Google here, and it shows. The more mature product is Spotify. I think Google can't really compete in terms of curation and popularity. Really, the edge cases of "music that is not on Spotify" ends up being so small that Google's upload your own music feature doesn't tip it in their favor. At least in my eyes.
- Thaxll 9y agoLarger library? They all use the same base library afaik.
- deelowe 9y agoI thought this as well. I used both for a while and never found instances where spotify had a lead.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- esMazer 9y agoSpotify "Over 35M" [1] Google Music 40M [2] Apple Music 45M [3] [1]https://press.spotify.com/us/about/ https://press.spotify.com/us/about/ [2]https://play.google.com/music/listen#/sulp https://play.google.com/music/listen#/sulp [3]https://www.apple.com/apple-music/ https://www.apple.com/apple-music/
- komali2 9y agoAre there any specific artists that you've been able to find on Spotify but not on GPM? I haven't run into this problem yet (except one time when Mick Gordon maybe forgot to renew or something his Wolfestein soundtrack? It was fixed within a week though)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- salvar 9y agoYeah, it's just because it's more hip. After all, you know best which UI is superior for all people.
- komali2 9y agoI didn't claim to "know which UI is superior for all people." If you look closely, you might see that I had included "to me." I did this on purpose to make sure nobody thought I was speaking for them. I am annoyed that you did so anyway. My comment was an opportunity for people to disagree with me - what about the GPM UI do you find inferior to the Spotify one?
- salvar 9y agoThe fact that you suggested ignorance as one of the possible reasons for millions of people preferring Spotify over Google Music speaks quite a bit towards your view of how important your feelings are. If I ask you "Hey, why would you ever prefer the shoes you like over mine? To me, it's an obvious choice. Is it just because you don't know any better?", would you interpret that as an honest question?
- whatok 9y agoI use Google Music on an iPhone and iPad with a Chromecast Audio at home and could not be happier with the setup.
- skinnymuch 9y agoAcross all platforms Spotify is consistently pretty good. I didn’t feel the same way with Google Music. The UI and performance would be problematic sometimes. The no YouTube ads is nice. Some people on HN like areas especially might care about diversifying who they give their money and/or attention to. Spotify has an advantage there too.
- ebiester 9y agoI use both, and am in a gradual transition to GPM. However, I keep Spotify around because: * My TV has spotify and not play music. I could get a Chromecast but why? * Spotify exclusives are still a thing. * The daily mixes are still better than anything Google has for recommendations. It's surprising google is as bad as it is for music recommendation. * Google keeps things close to their chest for popularity. I like knowing if an artist's top song is 100 times more popular than their next, for example, or how many people follow a playlist. Spotify lets me know who runs a playlist, whereas that's hidden for GPM. (Spotify has moved closer to their own playlists, which saddens me a little. I always hoped there would be room for curation from personalities. I miss DJs.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- satysin 9y agoI use Spotify because it works on my TV and PS4 whereas GPM does not. I would happily use GPM but I don't want to buy new hardware to do so.
- tomduncalf 9y ago- Spotify’s UI is much cleaner IMO - Better iOS app - Native (well, Electron) MacOS app - Playlist folders - niche feature but a big one for me - Amazingly good music discovery on Spotify (not properly compared with Google but they get it so right a lot of the time even for niche genres) I do wish Google Play could address some of these (most of all playlist folders! big one for me and how I organise music) as I do love the ability to store your own music along with cloud music that GPM gives, and it would be enough for me to switch with just a couple of changes.
- lmm 9y agoGoogle's service was late to the party and feels like an afterthought. And Google has a pretty big history of shuttering products that don't get big, so I wouldn't want to trust to keeping my music there. (Spotify could of course fail, but is unlikely to stop offering a music service short of them going bankrupt).
- cheshire137 9y agoI tried Google Play Music for a time, kept having trouble where songs would stop playing in the middle. Sometimes it would stop playing one song and skip to another track, other times it would just stop playing entirely. I don't want to hunt down the app and try to massage it into playing the song I want, it just needs to work, which Spotify gives me.
- r0m4n0 9y agoAmongst many of the other things listed by others here, a big item for me is integrations between all your logged in devices. One killer example: I can listen to a playlist through my ps4 while gaming (a unique feature in of itself), pull out my phone and pick another song in the playlist on my app. It tells me just below the play button where the music is currently streaming.
- whalesalad 9y agoSpotify has one mission: music. They do it really well. Google has a hundred hands in a hundred industries and only do a few of them very well. Google could shut their music service down for no reason at all. Spotify on the other hand has just gone all-in on ensuring they are a lasting institution. In the same light, Spotify is incentivized to crush the music app space. They need the best UI, the best discovery experiences, etc... whereas Google’s product is like the rich family that funds their son’s strange lifestyle business: It can live or die and the world keeps spinning. They do not need to innovate or be better... and they really aren’t. My wife used Spotify before we met. My sister uses it. My step mom uses it. All my buddies use it. I can count dozens of people around me that use it. It’s almost becoming a verb now: “Spotify it”. On the contrary, I only know one or two diehard google fanboys who use their music product. So I guess at the end of the day.. to answer your question, yes you’re missing something!
- nojvek 9y agoThat’s true for most things. While everyone thought Google Drive or One Drive or Some other drive company will kill Dropbox because making syncing storage isn’t rocket science, they were wrong. A nimble team of people focused on solving one core problem, whose entire livelihood depends on it working well, triumphs the giants. We can assume Microsoft and Google has enough middle management that they’ll fk it up along the way for sure. Too many agendas and failure doesn’t mean much. Therefore it’s in the best interest of giants to acquire companies that fit their mission and scale them with their marketing power. YouTube, Android, docs, are all good plays by google.
- rospaya 9y agoI hate that we've managed to fragment the tech markets again. Various websites I visit have exclusively Spotify or Apple Music playlists embeded, nothing modal that can be imported anywhere else. Those websites will be looked at one day the same way we see Java and Real Player plugins today.
- f4rker 9y agoBecause I have 100+ playlist I've spent years making. Some of which have emotional value (playlist are date stamped)
- alkonaut 9y ago> I'm not quite clear on why people are choosing spotify over google play music Simple answer: I'm a tech literate person (I read HN and a dozen other sites) and I hadn't even heard of "google play music" until now. So that's one reason. The other is likely that Spotify is pretty aggressive with marketing here (Sweden). E.g. get a phone contract and you get a year of spotify etc. But the most important reason is probably that after manty years on a product you get some lock-in. Now I wouldn't switch if the product was 10% better or if the price was 10% lower unless many of my friends switched and I could also port all playlists etc.
- lloeki 9y agoI like Google Play Music, a lot, but: - Google. Privacy. - trying to shove the Android/Material UI on iOS, such an impedance mismatch... I *hate* that. - no dedicated client on desktop (so, no offline mode) - the UI in the browser sucks (again, alien, and basically *negative* information density if it could be so) - uploading/downloading is a crapshoot[0] with official tools, and the API is unofficial so hacks[1] may be short-lived. So, again, I like GPM (and GPMAA) a lot, but only on Android. The only thing I miss in Spotify from GPMAA/Apple Music+iTunes Match is the digital locker for seamless syncing of music I own. FTR, despite having a native UI and digital locker, I moved from Apple Music to Spotify because discovery and reliability were terrible. [0]: official tools behave similarly to this: https://github.com/simon-weber/gmusicapi/issues/140 https://github.com/simon-weber/gmusicapi/issues/140 [1]: https://github.com/lloeki/ruby-skyjam https://github.com/lloeki/ruby-skyjam
- kerbalspacepro 9y agoAssuming that a Google Music PO reads this thread: --Spotify's ML features are way way way way way way better than Googles --Everybody else uses Spotify, which means I can share it The latter is obviously the thing Google won't win, so shouldn't try
- dheelus 9y agoGoogle Music has superior UI? SMH. In any case, I switched to GPMAA when it was launched and had the $7.99 a month rate locked in. Then, GPMAA started adding tracks to my playlist, etc. at random. No, Google, I don't want your suggestions to be auto-added to my collection. I simply want to listen to what I want to listen. I want to get away from Spotify but there are no better options. Amazon Music seemed promising for a bit but their catalog isn't as comprehensive and their app is just wonky. E.g.: the app won't sync / display song time when streaming over Bluetooth to my car audio. Deal breaker for me.