3 ms·
It really depends on your position and level of user engagement. Users of Reddit and Craigslist know very well what they want and what to expect. They can navig
by tootie 9y ago
It really depends on your position and level of user engagement. Users of Reddit and Craigslist know very well what they want and what to expect. They can navigate a wall of text really quickly because they've looked at it for countless hours. Strong design can be really critical to onboarding new users or leading down a path. Neither of which are priorities for Reddit or Craigslist.
- ddingus 9y agoIt's the leading down a path that is the problem. Onboarding for old-school Reddit and Craigslist isn't hard. You click on a few things. You're done. Once the idea of leading people down a path happens, then you've got a curated directed experience that conflicts with why you came there in the first place. That's what people have a problem with. The whole thing is presumptuous, as if they know better than you why you're there. They don't. Let's be honest about that.
- tootie 9y agoI mean like a workflow or a sales funnel for less engaged users. Not in a nefarious way.
- ddingus 9y agoIt's still presumptuous. Reddit doesn't need a sales funnel. It's owner Conde Nast does that's one problem. The users have a very different set of expectations set long before the new owner walked in. Prior to the big sale, which raised a lot of expectations, which may not actually be met very well at all given how users actually use Reddit,the site was self-sustaining based on gold and intra Reddit ads. The idea of billions of page views, based on largely organic online discussion, equaling massive dollars, isn't one proven valid. That's a problem too. The reason it's a problem, is curating a very compelling discussion site for advertisers runs in conflict with what makes for a very compelling discussion site.