2 ms·
It's worth noting that privacy against ISPs, at least today, is hugely more important than privacy against DNS resolvers, and not just because first-world ISPs
by _bxg1 9y ago
It's worth noting that privacy against ISPs, at least today, is hugely more important than privacy against DNS resolvers, and not just because first-world ISPs have a reputation of being less trustworthy than companies like Cloudflare (Google is more debatable).
You always have a choice of DNS resolver; you often don't have a choice of ISP. Especially outside of the first world, where the ISPs might be in the pocket of the government, like in the example from Turkey mentioned in Cloudflare's blog post, or in China. The ISP is the physical pipes, and if you can't get through the physical pipes, you're dead in the water. You can always change DNS resolvers.
This is still an interesting idea that's worth looking at. They just shouldn't minimize the significance of what Cloudflare is doing.
- jiveturkey 9y ago> You can always change DNS resolvers. But you can't. First, it's technically hard for many or even most users. Some important platforms (mobile) may make this exceptionally hard even for savvy users. Even if it's built in to the browser, the ISP can require you to use their proxy (some regimes already do this today) and then they can filter and/or alter DNS, even DNS-over-https.