12 ms·
There appears to be no LPDDR4 support in these processors, which seems like a major omission: https://ark.intel.com/products/134903/Intel-Core-i9-8950HK-Proces
by zdw 9y ago
There appears to be no LPDDR4 support in these processors, which seems like a major omission:
https://ark.intel.com/products/134903/Intel-Core-i9-8950HK-Processor-12M-Cache-up-to-4_60-GHz?q=i9-8950HK https://ark.intel.com/products/134903/Intel-Core-i9-8950HK-P...
Which means they'll be stuck using LPDDR3-2133 memory with the same bandwidth as previous generations in any power conscious design.
For example, Apple's MacBook Pro line continues to use LPDDR3-2133: https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs/ https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs/
I wish AMD would add LPDDR4 support to their mobile chips, if only to light another fire under Intel to have feature parity like they did with core count.
- neverminder 9y agoI don't understand how long will this bullshit continue. At the moment your average phone can technically support more than 16GB of RAM (LPDDR4), but not Intel's laptop CPUs. Is there some kind of massive obstacle that we don't know about?
- mbell 9y agoIntel is just behind, Cannonlake which supports LPDDR4 is now ~18 months late. LPDDR4 also uses a different physical signaling scheme than LPDDR3 so it's not a minor change to adapt current processors, if it is even possible without a packaging change.
- nerpderp83 9y agoTechnical management failure in how to mitigate late or stalled deps, fallback should have been to add ddr4 modems to existing chips.
- Declanomous 9y agoThat seem plausible to me, but aren't memory pretty tightly integrated into the design in a modern processor? How would you be able to take advantage of the additional RAM? Second question, do modems exist that could handle the bandwidth of existing designs? It seems like something that would be extraordinarily expensive, and there wouldn't be much of a benefit considering Intel doesn't have competition on this front.
- wtallis 9y agoDRAM controllers used to be on the motherboard, not the CPU. That changed for AMD in 2003 and Intel in 2008, but it is not at all interwoven with the CPU core itself. Processors within the same product line with varying core counts use the exact same DRAM controller blocks. This is really obvious on the Intel server chips where the CPU cores are linked by a ring or mesh bus and the DRAM controllers are just another stop at the far edges of those interconnects. Intel can update their DRAM controller independently of the CPU core microarchitecture, just like they can update the integrated GPU microarchitecture independently of the CPU core microarchitecture. The only reason why they might not be releasing a CPU with LPDDR4 yet is if they never expected to need an LPDDR4 controller before their 10nm process was ready, and never started designing a 14nm LPDDR4-capable controller. If so, that's a clear miscalculation on their part and a sign that the processor architects are probably insufficiently skeptical of what the fab guys are telling them.
- Declanomous 9y agoThat makes a lot of sense. Thanks for the explanation
- yuhong 9y agoProbably not trivial though, and I would not be surprised if many of these has already taped out and sampled. In general a modern DDR3/DDR4 memory controller is not a trivial thing to do.
- brandonmenc 9y agoWith super fast SSDs, does anyone really need 32GB of RAM? I don't even shut down my multiple JetBrains IDEs and gazillion browser tabs or bloated Slack when I take a break and pin the CPU with Ableton Live and a bunch of soft synths on my MBP. Nothing skips a beat. Is anyone seriously running into issues with only 16GB of RAM?
- _sigma 9y agoScientific dataset processing with R and python frequently pushes up against 16GB. Having more room with 32 or 64 would be fantastic.
- dagss 9y agoSome people store data in RAM not software.
- Jesus_Jones 9y agoYes, for devs with vms for compiling and testing like my team does, 16gb is not enough. Thus we are moving off macbooks. You can argue that you shouldn't do that on a laptop, you should have a desktop that you always connect to, but that's not how we prefer to do it. If there was no laptop with more than say 8 gig we'd probably have gone that way. 16gb is almost enough.
- walshemj 9y agowhy did you prefer laptops to a bigger and cheaper in a bang for buck way desktop machine?
- Jesus_Jones 9y agoBecause people wanted to take them around. At first, I think the dev system fit in 16 gig macbook pro without any trouble and it was a startup, so it was just natural to say that's all you need. Then the dev env started getting a little bit bigger. I showed up at the company and noticed you couldn't run the vm for a test and compile separately at the same time. Next I found out I couldn't have a bunch of tabs open while doing dev. So that was painful, and I got a desktop. The existing people who were used to how things worked said you shouldn't have a bunch of tabs open, don't do that and it works fine (oh and don't run any tests while compiling). Then as memory use kept up even the at most 4 tabs people found they kept running out of memory and they bought a few 32 gig laptops and suddenly things worked again. A few of us have desktops, most people are struggling with 16 gig notebooks and they started buying 32 gig notebooks for people that want them.
- pixl97 9y ago> Is there some kind of massive obstacle that we don't know about? Intel's profits?
- jhallenworld 9y agoMaybe Apple's. LPDDR4 is surely more expensive.
- bluedino 9y agoThe ARK page says the CPU can handle 64GB. LPDDR4 memory isn’t required when you’re going to be sucking as much power as this chip will
- yuhong 9y agoI bet that this is based on four SO-DIMM laptops, not 16Gbit DDR4.
- stock_toaster 9y agoPossibly another reason apple may be looking to do their own laptop cpus? six to 8 iphone's "glued together" would be somewhat appealing.
- opencl 9y agoIntel's laptop CPUs do support more than 16GB, just not more than 16GB of low power RAM. You can even get a Lenovo P51 with a mobile Xeon and 64GB ECC RAM.
- diffeomorphism 9y agoAll common Intel laptop CPUs (core ...) don't. The Xeons are the sole exception and only available in a few workstations.
- flukus 9y agoThe obstacle is lack of demand, the average user still has 4GB or less of RAM: https://hardware.metrics.mozilla.com/#goto-os-and-architecture https://hardware.metrics.mozilla.com/#goto-os-and-architectu... . People that need more than 16GB (as of today) are an incredibly niche market and can be better served by remoting into a desktop/server anyway.
- chasedehan 9y agoJust download more ram... https://downloadmoreram.com/ https://downloadmoreram.com/
- mciancia 9y agoIt will suck if we still won't see macbook pro with more than 16GB of ram because of that
- rsynnott 9y agoThey've already had a Kaby Lake MBP; there's a good chance they'll wait til CannonLake for the next one, which will.
- nickpeterson 9y agoThat or apple will just not update it for 20 months to build demand then use their own chips.
- nerpderp83 9y agoIn 20 months it better be 12 cores and 64gb. I already have a thinkpad with 32gb that I use for ML and minikube.
- nickpeterson 9y agoI have a suspicion that Apple can beat Intel on most of the metrics typical end users care about (single threaded speed, battery life), and pro users will just be forced to push the work to another rig. Who knows though, maybe they'll reintroduce the xserve? ;)
- merinowool 9y agoYeah, those new Intel chips are useless. I can't believe they wasted resources to build something like that. I really need a new laptop, but in 13 inch format I don't think I can get one with 32 or 64 GB of RAM. Only having 16 GB is a huge problem and make work difficult needlessly.
- gameswithgo 9y agoDoes it have more l2 or l3 cache to mitigate this? are there any benchmarks where this has a large effect? Is the I9 with 6 cores still faster than the I7 with 4 across the board? With more cores memory bandwidth does start to become more and more of an issue...
- sundvor 9y agoMeanwhile, if you're willing to go to DDR4, then e.g. the XPS15 is looking mighty nice: https://www.anandtech.com/show/12605/dells-8th-gen-alienware-laptops-and-monitors/4 https://www.anandtech.com/show/12605/dells-8th-gen-alienware... "internals of the XPS 15 model 9570 have been upgraded: [...]a fully-unlocked six-core Core i9-8950 HK." "Since the new processors support DDR4-2666 memory, Dell will equip its new XPS 15 with 8 – 32 GB of DDR4-2666. " It even scores 4 lanes PCIe Thunderbolt, finally. (I'm looking at upgrading my original X1 Carbon with a new one in the next couple of years myself so will probably wait for the LPDDR4).