3 ms·
> Clients that you operate—including your browser, your smartphone, and any IoT device in your home—sends a DNS query for each domain name to a so-called “recur
by nailer 9y ago
> Clients that you operate—including your browser, your smartphone, and any IoT device in your home—sends a DNS query for each domain name to a so-called “recursive DNS resolver”.On a typical home network, the default recursive DNS resolver may be operated by your Internet service provider (ISP) (e.g., Comcast, Verizon).
Nobody says 'recursive DNS resolver' - it's just a DNS resolver. See `man resolv.conf`.
DNS is inherently recursive. Saying 'recursive DNS resolver' is like saying 'ATM machine' or similar.
- isostatic 9y ago>Nobody says 'recursive DNS resolver' >Saying 'recursive DNS resolver' is like saying 'ATM machine' or similar Yes, because I never use my PIN Number Nobody is a very small set, and a very powerful word -- use it carefully, like Never, Always and Everyone
- xori 9y agoNobody should* say...
- nailer 9y ago> Yes, because I never use my PIN Number I get the point you're making, but that doesn't change anything: Unix people (and devops people) don't say 'recursive DNS resolver'. I've met 0 people who do this in the last 20+ years. I'm using the term 'nobody' very deliberately. I guess technical people are more specific - or like to keep things shorter - than the general public.
- hoytech 9y agoIt means as distinct from a "stub" resolver. resolv.conf configures a stub (non-recursive) resolver.
- NoGravitas 9y agoI believe that they are making the distinction between a recursive DNS resolver and an authoritative DNS resolver.
- gregmac 9y agoResolver vs Authoritative is the distinction. A resolver is recursive (it has to query other servers to get the answer); an authoritative DNS server is not (it has the answer).
- hoytech 9y agoI've never heard of anybody refer to an authoritative server as a "resolver" before. Even the article considers them separate: > any third party who can observe communication between a client and a recursive resolver, a recursive resolver, or an authoritative server The "recursive" adjective is pretty clearly to distinguish between stub and recursive resolvers.
- JdeBP 9y agoActually, it is a recursive DNS resolver, and that designation is not redundant. See RFC 1034 and RFC 1035. This terminology is difficult to get right, very few people actually do, and you are also demonstrating how it can be got wrong. A resolver is not what people in the overwhelming majority of cases think it to be, and they then reason to erroneous conclusions from this false concept. This is why I explain DNS using the terminology of HTTP: content DNS servers, proxy DNS servers, and client libraries. * http://jdebp.eu./FGA/dns-server-roles.html http://jdebp.eu./FGA/dns-server-roles.html