3 ms·
>How much is "good design" codeword for dumbing the site down as much as possible and making it shiny enough for people who get distracted by car keys? You're
by krapp 9y ago
>How much is "good design" codeword for dumbing the site down as much as possible and making it shiny enough for people who get distracted by car keys?
You're confusing user interface design and graphic design, which are two different disciplines with different goals, neither of which is to be merely distracting.
>Japanese websites are proof by example that this is strictly a cultural phenomena.
You're assuming that Japanese don't consider that "good design." It is a cultural phenomenon, but your assertion that it's strictly a Western phenomenon is incorrect.
It's also particularly odd to invoke Japan as an example of a culture that doesn't care at all about design or aesthetics.
>Maybe I'm elitist, but if you can't understand reddit as it is maybe you're an idiot?
I don't think there was ever an overabundance of users who didn't understand Reddit, given the site's popularity. Like a lot of programmers, you're assuming an inverse correlation exists between the quality of a site's design and the intellect of its users. So yes, you're an elitist.
>Give me my plain old links in their plain old default blue underline and my mod-hacked-together css+bots.
... and here you are arguing in favor of minimalism, which is a form of design.
Your entire comment is just a rant about how other people's design preferences are less valid than your own.
- Mediterraneo10 9y ago"It's also particularly odd to invoke Japan as an example of a culture that doesn't care at all about design or aesthetics." The belief that Japanese people all deeply care about such artistic things is largely a Western romanticization of Japanese culture, the sort that Roy Andrew Miller criticized in Japan's Modern Myth over three decades ago already. Yes, Japan is home to some interesting traditions, but that doesn't mean that broad society cares. And as Japanese websites show, Japanese mass society is quite comfortable with cluttered websites that one would be hard-pressed to call "elegant".
- krapp 9y agoTrue, but I didn't claim that "Japanese people all deeply care about such artistic things", only that they had a history with a design aesthetic that differed in principle from Western design, but wasn't an example of the absence of design. One could just as correctly assert that most Westerners don't care deeply about design, either. >And as Japanese websites show, Japanese mass society is quite comfortable with cluttered websites that one would be hard-pressed to call "elegant". Do they look cluttered to Japanese people, though? Or do they only look cluttered to Westerners because Japanese text looks like noise rather than language? Admittedly, it doesn't look elegant, but that doesn't mean it isn't an example of design.
- sizzle 9y agoYou're confusing user interface design and graphic design, which are two different disciplines with different goals, neither of which is to be merely distracting. "Dumbing it down" = designing for user's mental models = ux design
- krapp 9y ago>"Dumbing it down" = designing for user's mental models = ux design Riiight... when Reddit designs their UI around the mental model of mainstream users, they're dumbing it down, but when Hacker News designs their UI around pg's mental model of "good hackers", they're being elegant and minimalist.