4 ms·
Facebook is in trouble because it sold political influence at a price that previously non-mainstream actors could afford. Data is incidental to that scandal. Eq
by closeparen 9y ago
Facebook is in trouble because it sold political influence at a price that previously non-mainstream actors could afford. Data is incidental to that scandal. Equifax suffered no meaningful consequences for its breach.
I understand that the HN consensus desperately wants your statement to be true, but that doesn’t make it so.
- aylmao 9y ago> Facebook is in trouble because it sold political influence at a price that previously non-mainstream actors could afford. Data is incidental to that scandal. Would you care to elaborate? I'm curious and not entirely sure what you mean by this, sorry. > Equifax suffered no meaningful consequences for its breach. I don't think OP is claiming they did, but rather that it was part of the evolution towards thinking of data as a liability rather than an asset.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kk58 9y agoIm amazed how sheryl sandberg hasnt been called out. Wasn't she supposed to be adult in the room
- perseusprime11 9y agoNo! She is the one who is teaching Mark to play seasoned politics and not come to the townhall.
- eganist 9y ago> Facebook is in trouble because it sold political influence at a price that previously non-mainstream actors could afford. Since there appears to be some confusion (it took me a few passes as well), I interpreted your statement as the following: > Facebook is in trouble because it sold political influence at a discount from what previously only large nation-state actors could afford. The implication, if I'm reading correctly, is that any mom-and-pop millionaire could practically launch the same sort of campaign on the platform. Or perhaps more succinctly and dramatically, Facebook commoditized the weaponization of data. Am I understanding correctly?
- closeparen 9y agoThe traditional DNC/RNC campaign-finance and media-buy systems are not very efficient. They're also based on relationships. Candidates must appeal to broad coalitions of donors so that they can afford the TV airtime necessary to succeed. Ads must not be too damaging to the reputations of the career staffers and media companies putting them on the air. This tends to constrain the ideological space a successful candidate can occupy. We saw a successful candidate from outside that space because the efficiency of Facebook's ad platform, plus a unique and possibly Russian-intelligence-supplied savvy in wielding it, obviated the need for (as much) donor consensus to achieve a winning level of influence. I don't know about "any mom and pop millionaire," but you need less of them in your court than you used to. That scandal that has everyone up in arms is Facebook's complicity in Trump's election, which is a consequence of its enablement of extremists in general, which is a consequence of its ad platform's cost-efficiency, which is a consequence of its troves of user data. But it's not data that started a drumbeat of public intellectuals calling for heavy-handed intervention in the New York Times editorial section (a fingerprint we've seen before). It's influence. The establishment is (correctly) not trying to engage populism in a meme war. It's fighting back the way it knows how.
- nezzle 9y agoPolitics are like medieval royalty. A complex inter-generational web of influence, alliances, and quid pro quo. Support of these influencers was required to earn votes, and policy had to repay these influencers - rather than voters. Through the application of advanced techniques and data, Facebook enabled the circumvention of that at a shockingly lower cost than in the past.
- denom 9y agoThat’s right. The numbers I’ve seen have been 10 million for the Mercer’s initial investment. This is a pathetic amount of money to bankroll an operation with such large scale effects. Assuming the Mercer’s eventual expenditure reached 10 times that, $100 million is like building a library in a middling size city. It’s an incredible return on a pittance of an investment.
- downandout 9y agoThis is a pathetic amount of money to bankroll an operation with such large scale effects What effects though? The idea that CA’s strategies were effective has been disproven [1]. [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/cambridge-analytica-facebook-scandal-trump-cruz-operatives-2018-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/cambridge-analytica-facebook-...
- shostack 9y agoI think the full amount of money and dark money involved in this will turn out to be staggering. Parscale bragged of spending $90m alone on FB ads. And that is just one highly visible piece of the puzzle.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- downandout 9y agoFacebook is in trouble because it sold political influence at a price that previously non-mainstream actors could afford I’m curious exactly what you mean by this. If you’re saying that their paid ads system works well, that isn’t specific to political influence. Further, the recent scandal was over data abuse by third parties, and the reported effects of that have been proven to be dramatically overblown [1], so I assume that isn’t what you’re referring to. Finally, the notion that enough votes to change the election results were suppressed/changed by some Russian fake news articles mostly written in broken English is laughable. So what exactly are you referring to here? [1] http://www.businessinsider.com/cambridge-analytica-facebook-scandal-trump-cruz-operatives-2018-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/cambridge-analytica-facebook-...
- closeparen 9y ago>Further, the recent scandal was over data abuse by third parties The most recent wave of Facebook's ongoing scandal revealed that data abuse by third parties was one implementation detail of Facebook's complicity in Trump's election. Facebook's troubles (calls for breakup, regulation, etc) started over its crime of making political influence too readily available to extremist ideologies.
- downandout 9y agoAgain, you aren’t explaining your basis for the idea that Facebook actually has political influence to make available to anyone. The idea that CA’s strategies worked to any degree has been disproven. Also, not to get political, but would you be this upset over it if the other side had won and it turned out that they had employed a similar strategy (even if it had been proven ineffective, as CA’s strategy has)?
- closeparen 9y agoDid I indicate I was on board? Absolutely not. I think it's a disgrace that polite society is gearing up to wreck free speech on the internet just because we didn't like the result this time. But of the people calling to punitively regulate the tech industry now, only the tiny minority who've drunk the HN kool-aid are approaching it from a data-privacy perspective. The actual movement here is about Facebook's assistance to Trump and other extremist politicians, effective or not.