3 ms·
Re-read it. I did not say that AI expertise by itself was enough. And I did not say that nothing should happen. I said that people whose expertise is in bein
by btilly 9y ago
Re-read it. I did not say that AI expertise by itself was enough. And I did not say that nothing should happen.
I said that people whose expertise is in being experts on what others should do are going to not do a good job.
Let's take a concrete recent example.
http://time.com/5209144/google-search-engine-algorithm-bias-racism/ http://time.com/5209144/google-search-engine-algorithm-bias-... decries how Google search results are racist and are biased against black girls. It is written by someone whose background is clearly not machine learning, but who qualifies as an expert in the ethics of machine learning. She has a PhD, tenure at a well-regarded university, and a book on the subject.
While her article complains about the results of machine learning algorithms, and how horrible they are, she said nothing that showed an understanding of how they actually work. Why they produce the results that they do. Her diagnosis is that Google is a racist and sexist company. Her proposed solution is that Silicon Valley companies should be forced to hire blacks, and particularly black women, for the express purpose of keeping companies accountable for their racist environments.
The truth is that Google's internal environment is neither racist nor sexist - quite the opposite in fact. The actual problem is in the data available to Google of what people click on. How you can modify the algorithm to be slanted towards socially acceptable results is a tricky problem that requires a CS background. How you can modify the incentives so that companies are motivated to produce good results is an even more tricky problem.
Yet if she got to create the regulations, what would happen? We would literally get a requirement to hire politically correct thought police!
How well do you think that would work?
- gridaphobe 9y agoCan you point to where the author recommended that Google and co. be forced to hire black women (or any identity group for that matter)? What she did say is that it's not surprising that Google search produces biased results, given that minorities are underrepresented and topics like ethics are barely discussed in engineering schools. It sounds to me like she is attempting to raise awareness of a systemic issue in the tech industry, which requires no qualifications other than knowledge of the issue.
- spc476 9y ago> This is no surprise when black women are not employed in any significant numbers at Google. Not only are African Americans underemployed at Google, Facebook, Snapchat and other popular technology companies as computer programmers, but also jobs that could employ the expertise of people who understand the ramifications of racist and sexist stereotyping and misrepresentation and that require undergraduate and advanced degrees in ethnic, Black/African American, women and gender, American Indian, or Asian American studies do not exist. > We need people designing technologies for society to have training and an education on the histories of marginalized people, at a minimum, and we need them working alongside people with rigorous training and preparation from the social sciences and humanities. To design technology for people, without a detailed and rigorous study of people and communities, makes for the many kinds of egregious tech designs we see that come at the expense of people of color and women. So perhaps not a direct call to hire minorities, but a direct call to hire people versed in identity politics and various non-white studies.
- btilly 9y agoRight. - The company is bad because it doesn't hire enough black women. - The company needs to hire people versed in identity politics to critique what they are doing. - Programmers should be required to take the kind of course that she teaches. - Programmers should be only allowed to work alongside the people versed in identity politics who can tell them what they are doing wrong. In short, this is a power grab. "They done wrong, so people like me need to be given authority to make sure that they don't continue doing it." That may seem like an extreme example, but it is along a natural progression for people whose profession is figuring out what should be complained about. Everyone wants to believe that what they do is important. That they should be given more power and authority. What that means in practice varies by profession. But that is always the tendency.
- musage 9y ago> While her article complains about the results of machine learning algorithms, and how horrible they are, she said nothing that showed an understanding of how they actually work. This is from the article: > In this case, the clicks of users, coupled with the commercial processes that allow paid advertising to be prioritized in search results, mean that representations of women are ranked on a search engine page in ways that underscore women’s historical and contemporary lack of status in society — a direct mapping of old media traditions into new media architecture. or as you put it: > The actual problem is in the data available to Google of what people click on. As for the "Her diagnosis is that Google is a racist and sexist company" and "literally get a requirement to hire politically correct thought police", I'm curious how you arrive from that article at these conclusions.