4 ms·
> Free trade is a wonderful thing that makes everyone better off in the long run. If one of the participants has an absolutely massive population, a unified mo
by mistermann 9y ago
> Free trade is a wonderful thing that makes everyone better off in the long run.
If one of the participants has an absolutely massive population, a unified mono-culture known for being incredibly hard workers, doesn't lack any particular disadvantages, and is run my (what seems to be) and incredibly smart communist dictatorship, how do you guarantee that in one thread of possible outcomes that this dictatorship isn't able and willing to spread its wings to largely bring the entire planet under it's dictatorship. I'd hope you don't deny that the US as de facto world leader exercises a little global influence, if all the pieces fall into place and China with it's massive advantages over the US, how do you guarantee this outcome will not (and can not) come to pass?
A typical response to this question is that a free democracy always beats a dictatorship (this belief is so pervasive and unbending in the West, it's almost like a religion), but this is in no way whatsoever(!!!!!!!!!) guaranteed to always be true, in fact even with our incredibly small historic sample sizes, things were looking pretty iffy with Germany back in WW2, and they are tiny compared to China.
And I suppose I should make it explicit: no, I am not guaranteeing this outcome, I am warning of it as a possibility - but those who say it can not and will not happen are making a guarantee.
- valuearb 9y agoThey have one aircraft carrier, we have twenty. Their carrier is 60,000 tons, we have eleven 100,000 ton carriers. We have enough nukes to kill every chinese "communist party" member a dozen times over. It's GDP is about half the US. And their "communist" system is being run entirely off the back of a mostly free market economy. Free markets always beat communism and socialism. And if you believe that none of this matters, that China is a real threat, the last thing you want is to impose tariffs on them that hurt us more than they hurt China.
- mistermann 9y agoYour ability to post an answer that skipped every single point I made is admirable. You may find this article interesting: https://reason.com/archives/2017/10/26/the-fragile-generation https://reason.com/archives/2017/10/26/the-fragile-generatio...