4 ms·
What's shocking about it? For just the Echo, Amazon claims to have sold 20 million devices so they are probably in at least 10 million homes. How many of the pe
by criddell 9y ago
What's shocking about it? For just the Echo, Amazon claims to have sold 20 million devices so they are probably in at least 10 million homes. How many of the people that buy an Echo have been harmed so far?
I have an Echo and use it daily for music, weather, timers, home automation (ie controlling lights and fans), etc...
I also drive a car almost every day and that has a relatively high probability of killing me. Compared to that, having an Echo in my house seems somewhat harmless.
- StanislavPetrov 9y ago>How many of the people that buy an Echo have been harmed so far? That entirely depends on your definition of "harm". Those of us who see intrinsic value in privacy would be grievously harmed.
- criddell 9y agoI think the definition of harm has to include some negative consequence. Otherwise you could just say "those of us that are offended by the color blue are grievously harmed every time the Echo is activated". Even if we accept that sharing anything private is harm, I'm guessing most purchasers of the Echo understand that the device uses the internet to answer queries. How are those foolish people being harmed?
- ConceptJunkie 9y agoI don't think there's any way to tell if there has been concrete harm, which is the biggest problem. You can't trust the platform.
- gambiting 9y agoWhen the German government started gathering data about religion of its citizens, way before WW2, how many people were harmed by filling out that one field on the form? Zero. No one was harmed by the collection of that data. Except that then WW2 arrived and this data was used to exterminate entire communities. In my own country(Poland) the secret police used to gather all data on people and do nothing with it - until you gave them a reason to, then they had entire archives of recorded conversations, intercepted letters, logs of visits and journeys, ready to be browsed in search for anything that could be used against you.