4 ms·
Sometimes I wish HN had a filter I could use because the constant flow of these articles and some of the opinions that follow really enrage me. Keep voting me d
by ck2 16y ago
Sometimes I wish HN had a filter I could use because the constant flow of these articles and some of the opinions that follow really enrage me. Keep voting me down though and just keep wondering why the number of women in tech are so low with these kinds of chauvinistic attitudes.
It's illegal to yell fire in a crowded movie theater. That's not stepping on free speech, it's an adjustment by society to keep things sane and fair. Same thing for asking business to stop helping the selling of women.
And it's not "many people disagree with banning prostitution" - it's most MEN want to reserve the right to trade money for instant sex, regardless of the cost to society because they don't know how to regulate their cravings.
- _delirium 16y agoIs it really a mainly male POV? Most of the activist organizations I know of specifically for legalizing prostitution/sex-work are women-led, essentially the sex-workers' part of the union movement, and often explicitly feminist (from the radical branch of sex-positive feminism). That does seem to be a bigger trend in Europe than in the US, though. Some details: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_workers%27_rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_workers%27_rights
- ck2 16y agoThe women that support making it legal are doing it as what they see as the better option because they know it won't go away and they desperately want to see bad things stop happening to women. It's hard to deal with when you see it in real-life. They figure it's always going to be there and if so, it's better that it's out in the open so women can at least get legal support instead of the cops laughing them off when they get hurt. I say that's not the answer, it's a poor choice of lesser evils. Just imagine what if it would be like if everyone could get hard drugs and it was out in the open. Imagine CL full of ads for hard drugs being condoned. In a better society when you've made bad choices you should be able to get help for yourself regardless if it's prostitution or hard drugs. And yes I think those two are about the same level in bad choices for all involved, buyers and sellers. It means you've crossed certain lines where instant gratification is overriding long term thinking and it damages you and society. If you want prostitution LEGAL well then campaign for that but don't do an end run around the illegality by saying there should be open ads for illegal activity. That's a double standard.
- darrikmazey 16y agoI don't think the dispute is whether there should be open ads for illegal activity. The proper course is to settle that between law enforcement and the offending party, not law enforcement and the medium, especially when doing the latter means stepping on the free speech of some people posting legal ads. Some people choose to drive while intoxicated, but nobody's demanding we take down the roads, or calling local governments accomplices to illegal activity (nor car or alcohol manufacturers). There are plenty of sites on the Internet where one can engage in illegal activities. The question is why this one? And why this activity?
- derefr 16y ago> Imagine CL full of ads for hard drugs being condoned. You've never read an ad looking for a "generous" friend to "hit the slopes" with?
- jamesbritt 16y ago"Just imagine what if it would be like if everyone could get hard drugs and it was out in the open." Lower prices, better quality control, less drug-trafficking violence. Maybe even less social stigma surrounding drug use, so more people who needed help could get better help. Or did you think the 18th Amendment was a good idea?
- hnhg 16y agoI know a few guys who worked as escorts for female clients. The clients were usually aged late 30s onwards, some lonely, some just looking for sex. Mostly they were affluent, busy professionals. Women seem to like paying for instant sex too if the social conditions are right.
- biturd 16y agoAnd from two interviews I read, men are treated terribly in general by women compared to how women are treated who work in those professions.
- jamesbritt 16y ago" Women seem to like paying for instant sex too if the social conditions are right." Indeed, it's said that you don't pay the [man|woman] for the sex; you pay them to leave.
- guelo 16y agoYour comment enrages me but I don't want to censor it. BTW, just because you're a woman doesn't give you authority to speak for all 150 million of them. Or to make up statistics about MEN.
- sev 16y ago> It's illegal to yell fire in a crowded movie theater [1]"Shouting fire in a crowded theater" is a popular metaphor and frequent misquoting of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.'s opinion. The misquote fails to mention falsely shouting fire to highlight that speech which is merely dangerous and false which can be distinguished from truthful but also dangerous. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_thea...
- jongraehl 16y agoWhy do you read the comments on such articles if you know they enrage you?