5 ms·
> regulation hampers growth Is there proof of this? Some countries like Germany and Sweden are both highly regulated and have fastest economic growth in the We
by pavlov 9y ago
> regulation hampers growth
Is there proof of this? Some countries like Germany and Sweden are both highly regulated and have fastest economic growth in the West.
- deltron3030 9y agoWho's growing is the more important question. Regulation benefits the already big.
- fnord123 9y agoSome regulation is bad, but there are plenty of good examples. Regulation on the standards like GSM and use of SIM cards helped new entrants into the European markets. Net Neutrality, standardized electrical systems, etc have benefited everyone large and small. And of course, anti-trust regulations in the EU has not benefited Microsoft or Google.
- davidw 9y ago> standardized electrical systems Except for the damn plugs!
- anigbrowl 9y agoThat's truism that I don't think is accurate. You're assuming all regulation is complex and that this can directly drive administrative costs in linear fashion.
- smt88 9y ago> Regulation benefits the already big "Regulation" isn't guaranteed to do anything. Some regulations benefit already-big, some harm them. Some have no effect at all. Lack of regulation is guaranteed to benefit already-big, though. Unchecked corporations become oligopolies or monopolies. Free markets (meaning free movement, not free of regulation) and consumer protection are impossible without regulations, though.
- deltron3030 9y ago>Lack of regulation is guaranteed to benefit already-big, though. Not neccessarly, it depends on how educated market participants are. Shouldn't a world that becomes more and more informed, connected and educated not become less regulated? >Unchecked corporations become oligopolies or monopolies. But not forever, less regulation also means more opportunity for competitors. And educated customers would be aware of the situation and just ignore the monopolies if they can buy somewhere else.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- abvdasker 9y ago> Regulation benefits the already big That generalization is pretty obviously wrong. The vast body of antitrust regulation is designed precisely to hurt the "already big". Regulations around net neutrality would also fall into the category of helping the little guy far more than a big player. Regulation certainly can hamper smaller businesses, but it really depends on how the regulation is designed.
- Joeri 9y agoBad regulation hampers growth, good regulation induces growth. As I see it, the problem in the U.S. is that the current political system is incapable of producing good regulation, partly because of the deeply flawed voting system and partly because of a collective belief that government cannot be effective (producing that exact outcome).
- saosebastiao 9y agoYes, all regulation hurts economic growth. The mechanism is simple: regulatory compliance is a cost. If it's a fixed cost like most regulation, it becomes a barrier to entry. If it's a variable cost, it reduces labor productivity. HOWEVER, some regulation may improve net economic growth by improving the functioning of markets such that it overcomes the costs that compliance imposes. Therefore the discussion of regulation cannot be divorced from the quantitative and qualitative merits of the specific regulation proposed, and therefore must be considered on a case by case basis. The idea that regulation can be proven good or bad in aggregate is a fools errand.
- alex_young 9y ago>> Is there proof of this? > Yes, all regulation hurts economic growth. What about the proof of that? What basis are you making the assertion on? It seems like some regulation can promote growth. For instance, regulation on product safety increases consumer confidence in the safety of those products and creates a broader market for them.
- Kalium 9y agoUpon careful reading of the comment to which you are responding, I found that it neatly addresses very precisely the keen, sensible, and reasonable point you have raised. Perhaps you have had an experience significantly from mine?
- hluska 9y agoThat comment assumes we can all agree upon a textbook definition of 'economic regulation'. An economic regulation is generally defined as any legislation or administrative act that impacts either pricing a good or entering a market. If you follow that strict, conventional (in economics circles) definition, it's tough to argue with the comment. Outside of textbooks, economic regulation has a much bigger meaning such that a statement like that would be highly confusing and inflammatory. Outside of textbooks, economic regulation can refer to anything from health/safety legislation to antitrust legislation to taxes/tariffs/freer trade. Economic regulation = increased costs only works if you use a conventional definition of regulation...