8 ms·
I still can't wrap my head around everything that was wrongheaded about Windows 8, and I was working there for most of its dev cycle. One wonders what would ha
by asveikau 9y ago
I still can't wrap my head around everything that was wrongheaded about Windows 8, and I was working there for most of its dev cycle.
One wonders what would have happened if they just sort of let Windows be Windows. I.e. if they had continued iterating on core stuff but left UI and general philosophy resembling Win7's trajectory and not tried to force people into WinRT/UWP/store.
Even though Win10 attempted corrective action it always struck me that it was still accepting the fundamental thesis of Win8. They still kept with the Orwellian redefinition of phrases like "Windows app" to mean very recent, immature and unproven technology. They were still talking about ARM devices that don't let you do a straightforward recompile of old code. They were still pushing the Store as the only means to distribute software, where even Apple has not succeeded in changing people's habits on the desktop.
I hope that with a weaker organization, people keeping the lights on for Windows will know to not shake things up too severely and ease up on pushing some of these silly ideas. I somehow doubt it. I've been hoping for that for... 7 years?
- djsumdog 9y agoor if Windows 8 had set one UI default for tablets and the other default for desktops. The OS was faster and had better load times. It was a far cry from the failure of Windows Vista. It was just that start menu that really killed it for most people.
- alkonaut 9y agoThey bet the farm on “store”. Why? Because they must have done the math and realized that the enterprise and “creative pro” desktop with classic expensive desktop apps is a dead end. Was that calculation correct? Who knows. But I have to think they did that analysis very carefully.
- asveikau 9y agoI think it's more likely that there was a team or more likely several teams looking to make a name for itself, and they concluded that forcing everyone in the Windows desktop monopoly to use its stuff was the way to get that work noticed. I am sure that a bunch of the people responsible were praised as top performers and rewarded for their victory. When the original people are cycled out there is already inertia and it doesn't really occur to people that the previous blunder needs to be rolled back.
- extralego 9y agoIt was wrong. None of those apps have been replaced. I use them every day and switched to Windows 3 years ago. I was stubborn and should have done it sooner. Maybe MS saw Apple abandoning the pro hardware market and was trying to play along “because Apple”. A fun result of the whole mess is that after a new Windows 10 install, the first thing I do now is open Store to install Ubuntu WSL.
- simonh 9y agoI think they saw Apple’s success with the iOS App Store, saw Apple trying to do the same on desktop and tried to leap ahead of them by forcing the pace. Of course when app stores on desktop, for both Apple and Microsoft, proved much more problematic to implement, ramming it through like that proved highly damaging.
- asveikau 9y agoIt's funny because even if you put yourself in the mind of 2009, you can imagine a much more modest store feature doing good things for end users. The old Windows desktop might have had a half dozen things prompting you to elevate and update. Flash player, Adobe reader, Java runtime, all these things wanted your undivided attention to update, not to mention were polling the network and using resources to do that. So maybe you could see a single piece of infrastructure allowing those third parties to hook in less intrusively. But that's not what they asked for. They would prefer you trash your app and write for the thing they came up with this year, to be thrown away when they do the rewrite the next year.
- WorldMaker 9y ago> They would prefer you trash your app and write for the thing they came up with this year, to be thrown away when they do the rewrite the next year. That hasn't been true for over a year now. Classic Win32 desktop apps have been in the Store for over a year now (nearly a year and a half). It's my preferred way now to install things like Office and Paint.NET. Even Photoshop is in the Store now. (Even iTunes was promised at one point, and I'm still very hopeful for that, because Apple's Windows Updater is still one of the worst updaters on Windows, where bad updaters was once an art form.)
- Feniks 9y agoThe calculation is correct. Microsoft fears Chrome OS and rightly so. Old Windows as we know it was a mass market dead end. The technophile crowd can always just use win10 Enterprise and tweak it.
- Shorel 9y agoYes, but the solution would be to do something like Steam, and sell normal Windows software in the store. Selling only WinRT software made all their efforts worthless. Forcing developers to provide Win32 and WinRT versions of software alienated software developers. Some of the calculation was correct. WinRT was not.
- jsgo 9y agoWhile I agree to a point, I do think the "wild west" nature of a lot of Win32 apps kind of prevented it as they couldn't manage the security. If there were some way to wrap the Win32 apps in their own individual sandboxes without hampering function, then I could see it working. But with everything else they have to get going, I guess it is too tough a nut to crack right now (if could be cracked).
- Shorel 9y agoThe obvious counterpoint to that is Steam again. They don't have to sell all existing legacy Win32 apps in the store, but they should at least allow some Win32 apps. About malicious software, I think it would be very dangerous legally for the malicious developer to expose his personal and financial information to MS and expect nothing happens when caught.
- jsgo 9y agotrue, but I think (not certain) Microsoft's aim is security via sandboxing, so without thorough testing of the various Win32 apps, I don't see how it gets done. And I could just imagine the blog post from a Win32 developer when their Windows Store release breaks because it doesn't have the same access privileges as the proper version. Then users request added security but with no net impact on user experience/expectations and all that. And all it would take is the developer to claim that their machine had a virus unbeknownst to them that somehow made its way into their binary. Dunno, Steam is in a position where they don't really have to care about the Windows brand but Microsoft does, so they have a bit more freedom than Microsoft in that.
- cptskippy 9y ago> One wonders what would have happened if they just sort of let Windows be Windows. I.e. if they had continued iterating on core stuff but left UI and general philosophy resembling Win7's trajectory and not tried to force people into WinRT/UWP/store. With Windows 8 they tried to do too much too quickly and not well, however their motivations and intention were spot on in my opinion. Security has always been a pain point for Windows and it's only been getting worse, the Store introduced a sandbox like that found on iOS and Android. ARM, iOS, and Android showed that modern hardware and software can produce power efficiencies that put x86 and Windows to shame. UWP introduced hardware independence and a modern development framework that would put Windows Apps on a level playing field with iOS and Android. The problem was that Microsoft thought that merely by virtue of their existence, developers would adopt UWP/Store despite the path forward being a huge pain in the ass. We see how that played out. With Windows 10 we've seen a course correction and a change in strategy. You can have traditional Applications sandboxed in the Store, and you can have UWP Apps outside the Store. Microsoft bought Xamarin and is folding it into UWP, the intent is to not just have hardware independence with UWP but also OS independence.
- saiya-jin 9y agothat's... not what most users want. even as a dev myself, I understand most people want just freedom and no hassle, OS to be there in the background, not creating narrow allowed alley for its own users. will keep my Win7 for as long as hardware and software keeps running. don-t expect much more from OS honestly
- Endy 9y agoI second this.
- cptskippy 9y ago> that's... not what most users want. even as a dev myself, I understand most people want just freedom and no hassle, OS to be there in the background, not creating narrow allowed alley for its own users. Android and iOS have demonstrably shown that most users don't value freedom as long as the OS works for their needs. Most users are security nightmares as IT Admins and relatives supporting family members can attest to. The Store is Microsoft's attempt to introduce that stability and safety to the wider Windows audience. That's not to say that there isn't a significant subset of power users who want the ability to do what they will with their machine however they are the exception. Microsoft is struggling with how to cater to both markets simultaneously.
- Micoloth 9y ago>immature and unproven technology Wasn't old windows desktop technology the one proven to be bad? I mean I can say this because I like windows, but people have made fun of windows bugs and viruses for three decades now.. Granted, Windows Store still sucks ass years later its introduction, but building a new ecosystem with unified and modern tooling was probably a necessary step for them to make
- dblohm7 9y ago>Wasn't old windows desktop technology the one proven to be bad? I mean I can say this because I like windows, but people have made fun of windows bugs and viruses for three decades now. A lot of that stuff could have been (and is now being) fixed incrementally. Lots of that tech is available to Windows desktop applications without needing to switch to UWP. Some of it is UWP only (except for a backstage pass for Edge, which tells you everything you need to know) only to push developers to the Store.
- simonh 9y agoThere as nothing wrong with their desktop core technology. Visita at least allowed them to solve the security issues, and with seven they had a really great, solid desktop OS. The problem was actively undermining all that with Metro and RT. What’s popular and effective about 10 is all the crud they stripped off it, much more than anything they added, just as with 7.
- criddell 9y ago> with seven they had a really great, solid desktop OS. The problem was actively undermining all that with Metro and RT. I sometimes wonder if maybe they should have done a hard fork between 7 and 8 and continue to develop 7 for commercial users and 8 would be the consumer version. In the commercial branch, they could undo some of the moves they made years ago (like putting GDI in the kernel rather than user space) to eventually get a more stable, secure OS.
- wilun 9y agoI think they recently put backs tons of kernel space code back in userspace (in recent versions of 10), probably because the quantity of discovered security vulns started to become really ridiculous.
- remir 9y agoThey took risks with Windows 8 and I give them credit for that, but yeah, I'm glad they changed course because it wasn't working.
- orev 9y agoI feel like they started gathering metrics and then had no idea how to interpret them, and the result was Windows 8. "The Start menu only gets clicked on a few times per day. That must mean no one uses it, so let's remove it". Are you kidding me? It's like they really have no clue there. Some of these things are just so blindingly obvious you are left with no words...
- makecheck 9y agoYep. If this was a car, they’d have said: “clearly the brake pedal is needed but let’s get rid of the door handle, people only touch that occasionally”.
- simonh 9y agoIt would have helped if they hadn’t done everything they could possibly imagine to fragment windows as much as possible. Six SKUs of Windows desktop, then on top of those two entire desktop UI environments in desktop and Metro, then Windows on ARM, then shifting from one new development stack to another, then another. Then mandating store apps. This was foot shooting on full automatic, clip after clip. I switched to a Mac desktops in 2007 before Vista so I watched all of this with stunned bemusement and to be honest have little idea how it affected users and Devs reliant on the platform, except from reading the occasional article by Paul Thurrott.
- avtar 9y ago> Six SKUs of Windows desktop Here's hoping they'll rethink that at some point and follow Apple's approach of having just one desktop OS instead of nickel-and-diming the masses for features such as BitLocker.
- freehunter 9y agoOn the other hand, compare Windows desktop marketshare with that of macOS. When you're tiny, limited choices makes sense. When you're huge, product differentiation makes sense. When you're a premium product, you can charge whatever you want. Windows appeals to people who spend $0 on an OS and also people who can spend $300 on an OS. If they cut that down to one product, they'd be losing money.
- simonh 9y agoThis is true, but fragmenting your platform is an existential threat. Nickel and diming customers just isn’t worth it. The problem is Microsoft thought they were so powerful and had such strong lock in that it didn’t matter. They were wrong, hence the radically simplified SKUs for 10. But they just can’t bear to actually get it all right, so still try and stiff people to switch off ‘S’ mode.
- conradfr 9y agoThere is two constant declarations for each new Windows : - There will be less SKUs - Updates won't require to restart the OS Well ...
- giancarlostoro 9y agoOne thing I love about Windows 10 which may sound silly. The Netflix app. I can download anything downloadable on Netflix. I can't do this basic thing on my Macbook Air sadly cause they have no desktop app. Small thing that makes me enjoy Windows 10.
- freehunter 9y agoI honestly don't know the answer to this, but is that a Microsoft/Apple problem, or is it a Netflix problem? Apple has an app store for macOS, and there are tons of unofficial Netflix apps in there. Netflix has an app for iOS. So why hasn't Netflix made an app for macOS?
- macintux 9y agoI don’t know either, but I wouldn’t be surprised to discover Netflix thinks people with Apple laptops are likely to have an iPad or iPhone as well. With the possible exception of my non-Retina iPad mini I’d rather watch Netflix on any of my mobile devices. It never even occurred to me to look for it on my laptop, because the form factor is so ridiculous for movie watching.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoVery possible. I've watched movies off my desktop for years, and my network isn't always reliable so being able to predownload shows on my Windows desktop is perfect. It returns me to my experience pre-Netflix / Hulu. I wish the streaming services were not getting so fragmented they're not helping with their greed, they're only drawing people toward piracy further all over again. I'm speaking of course of CW. I'm not paying to stream only one network just to watch Arrow and Co. dang it!
- jpalomaki 9y agoIt felt like somebody on very high level decided to have unified experience for both tablets and desktops. Then those people who told this is impossible to do (well) in given timeframe were ignored. Windows 8 was what they managed to scrape together before running out of time. Delay was not an option as the tablet hardware launch was depending on the OS.
- rb808 9y agoRemember at that time Windows 8 was the MS solution for tablets and MS was getting killed in the tablet space as iOS took off. Windows 8 wasn't officially out until a year after the first iPad. They had to get it out asap.
- criddell 9y agoWindows 8 may have been a response to iOS popularity, but don't forget that Microsoft had been pushing tablets for a long time by then. They had a huge head start over Apple. If you want to include Windows for Pen Computing, then it was an 18 year lead that they lost overnight.
- robotresearcher 9y agoApple released their own hardware pen-based handheld computer in 1993. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Newton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Newton Windows for Pen Computing was released in 1992.
- criddell 9y agoGood point. I guess I would respond with the difference being that Microsoft developed the technology continually during that time whereas something like the Newton was a relatively short-lived product. For the record, I had a MP120 and absolutely loved that machine.
- jhbadger 9y agoYes, but Newton's OS had nothing to do with MacOS, being a completely independent system with its own API and even programming language (Newtonscript). Windows for Pen Computing was Windows.
- makecheck 9y agoTo be fair though, it’s not that a desktop app store couldn’t work, it’s that Apple’s implementation and set of restrictions are infuriating.
- ryandrake 9y agoAs a developer, the Windows target is baffling. I briefly considered porting a few apps I wrote over to Windows just to re-learn the platform again. Might be fun! Back in the day, the choice was easy: MFC/Win32 Now, I have no idea where to even start! C#? C++? .NET? Win32? MFC? WPF? XAML? WinForms? UWP? What a rat’s next! How did MS let the development ecosystem get so muddied? I know I can go online and research all of these, learn the trade offs, and hope I bet on the right horse, but then again I could also choose to simply leave this crazy platform alone and work on more features on the platforms that are more comfortable.
- dblohm7 9y agoThis reminds me of "How Microsoft Lost the API War": https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/06/13/how-microsoft-lost-the-api-war/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/06/13/how-microsoft-lost...
- amatheus 9y agoI'm not developing anything desktop right now but when I think about it the conclusion I come to is to give up on MS technologies and go with QT. Much more stable and you get Linux for (almost) free.
- ryandrake 9y agoYea, this is where I ended up. If I’m going to port something to oddball non-Unix-based or otherwise less-important platforms, like Windows, Qt makes the most sense.
- 21 9y agoYou start at Electron. Having used most of the GUI frameworks listed above, making a GUI app in HTML/JavaScript is faaaar easier.
- WorldMaker 9y agoHere's how simple I think it is: Out (but not gone/forgotten): Win32 (hand-coded C, C++ MFC, C++ ATL and related alphabet soup [aka back in the day the choice wasn't easy, either], VB6, .NET WinForms, etc), WPF/Silverlight (a .NET only XAML platform) In: UWP (C++ with XAML, C#/.NET with XAML, JS with HTML/CSS) Just three UI platforms to consider (Win32, WPF, UWP), two of which are mostly deprecated and not recommended if you are building a fresh application or porting one to a new UI. The remaining platform (UWP) gives you language choice (C++, C# or other .NET languages, JS), but not UI design framework/markup language choice (XAML, unless JS and then HTML). If you are doing a fresh port of a C++ application from another platform, the choice seems pretty simple to target the UWP and use XAML to define your UI.
- corey_moncure 9y ago>One wonders what would have happened if they just sort of let Windows be Windows. Presumably, given that the opposite has happened, in that case, "targets" would not have been met by "Q4" and important team members would have to be "let go". As you point out, this is not new. I would pin the start of this trajectory on the introduction of Windows Activation with XP. It's all variations on the theme of restricting the user's freedom. It hasn't been your software since 2001. It's theirs.
- cm2187 9y agoWhat strikes me is that their latest bet seems to be universal web apps. I have nothing against UWA in themselves but I very much doubt that the mass of Java/VB/C#/C++ developers that write the bulk of Windows apps will suddenly move to JavaScript. And if you ported your app to the web why bother with UWA.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- s73v3r_ 9y agoAgreed. If I wanted to be a web/javascript developer, I would already be doing JavaScript. But I don't want to.