3 ms·
Just like Airbnb is a hotel business, Uber is a taxi business (meaning a ride-for-hire business and nothing else) having a car rental business is having a car r
by alkonaut 9y ago
Just like Airbnb is a hotel business, Uber is a taxi business (meaning a ride-for-hire business and nothing else) having a car rental business is having a car rental business regardless of whether the cars are “shared” or whether there is an app involved.
And just like Uber has to follow any regulations surrounding rides for hire (regarding taxes, insurance, accessibility, right to deny service, ...), so must this company with regulations surrounding car rental.
I don’t see how making sure startups don’t get away with some loophole is a “legislative war”. It’s no different from cities where Hotels say AirBnb should pay hotel taxes and have hotel level fire security.
If the regulations surrounding the established market is too rigid then address that. But don’t “revolutionize” markets by using some loophole and an app.
- nate_meurer 9y agoYour examples aren't helping to prove your point though. It makes zero sense to require single-family houses or duplexes to have hotel level security. Requiring a homeowner to retrofit sprinklers and fire doors, or provide 24-hour video surveillance or an onsite security guard? A hotel is fundamentally different sort of facility than my house. Insisting they be regulated the same is pure rent-seeking on the part of the hotel industry.
- alkonaut 9y agoIf you rent it out you are a hotel. Or, possibly, a landlord (which comes with different but quite burdensome regulations in most countries). What a lot of these startups do is expose areas of markets that may be too rigidly regulated. Perhaps the reasonable level of regulation for Airbnb renting is just working smoke detectors, a basic escape plan map and good insurance? Perhaps most of the remaining hotel regulations could be lifted? It’s very likely that the advent of “not quite hotels” and “not quite taxi” calls for new regulation. But what the established players “war” against is newcomers completely dodging regulation on account of being “not a hotel”, “not a landlord” or “not a taxi”.
- nate_meurer 9y ago> "If you rent it out you are a hotel" This kind of semantic conflation isn't helpful. A house, rented or not, has almost nothing in common with a typical hotel with dozens of rooms and unrelated guests, complicated egress paths, commercial kitchens, industrial services and controls, etc. It absolutely makes sense to require hotels to have automatic fire suppression systems, heavy fire doors in every room, video surveillance, or 24-hour guards. And then there's ADA, a whole other conversation. Hotels aren't pushing for hotel regs to be applied to houses out of some even-handed desire to prevent loopholes. The AH&LA is a cartel trying to have their competition outlawed.
- maxsilver 9y ago> Hotels aren't pushing for hotel regs to be applied to houses out of some even-handed desire to prevent loopholes. The AH&LA is a cartel trying to have their competition outlawed. Sure, but the opposite is equally true. AirBNB, Uber, and others aren't blatantly lying about their core business out of some even-handed desire to prevent loopholes. They're doing it exclusively to illegally escape regulation -- regulations their competitors are all bound to by law. They're trying to replace a cartel with their cartel. The question to the public at large is: would you rather have an existing cartel that is subject to regulation, or a new cartel that also believes it is above the law.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoYou make it sound like the regulations somehow bind and constrain the existing cartels. Another point of view is that the regulations are the mechanism by which the cartels keep competitors out. I'd rather have "above the law" cartels than "makes the law" cartels.
- alkonaut 9y agoWhen I say “hotel” I didn’t mean some particular category of operation - I meant “commercially by-the-night rented rooms”. Such as a 2-room inn above an English pub, or any 1-room B&B on the French countryside. Obviously the regulations that should apply for a person renting out a single apartment on AirBnB shouldn’t be more burdensome than the very simplest Inn/B&B.