4 ms·
> Science and the Humanities worked fine before peer review Before peer review they were not dealing with the volume of scientific content that is submitted no
by jclos 9y ago
> Science and the Humanities worked fine before peer review
Before peer review they were not dealing with the volume of scientific content that is submitted nowadays. One could debate whether citations are the only metric necessary, but there needs to be a filter before that even happens, or else we will be flooded with an avalanche of garbage research. It would be trivial for someone with deep enough pockets to order a network of junk papers citing each other and debunking climate change or evolution and make a real mess. As painful as reviewing is, it's a necessary evil for now.