3 ms·
I think the most solid argument in favor of the quantum multiverse is along the lines of "The universe is virtually certain to fall into a lower-energy quantum
by jerf 9y ago
I think the most solid argument in favor of the quantum multiverse is along the lines of "The universe is virtually certain to fall into a lower-energy quantum vacuum state. That we have not observed it to be the case means either that we have been astonishingly lucky, or that there is a selection process going on. There is such a selection process; we can only witness futures in which the entire past lightcone of the universe has not collapsed; despite the near-certainty that such has occurred there are still far more possible universes than that." In short, the quantum multiverse argument can be run backwards in time, too; a given quantum system will observe a superposition of all possible past states of the universe as it evolves forward in time, and we can only see the ones in which we still survive.
Now, I still don't believe in the quantum multiverse. We have not proved to my satisfaction that lower-energy quantum vacuum states are inevitable, on the grounds that we don't know enough yet to know why it hasn't happened. (i.e., there may be other effects keeping it from happening, or perhaps there are reasons why it actually can't happen such as the lower state being non-viable for some other reason, etc.) But in my opinion, this is still the most solid argument in its favor; if it can be established that our current universe with near-certainty should evolve into something that we can't live in or observe with a bubble expanding at the speed of light, it's going to take something equally potent to counteract that.
Or, in other words, under this theory, for every split second of your entire life, vastly, vastly more of your worldlines are getting lightspeed-annihilated than not. %99.999... "keep writing 9s as long as you like" of them. But the destruction is so total and instantaneous that you can never observe this fact, so you go on happily living in the 0.00...01% of the remainder, happy as a clam. Again, this isn't my own personal belief, but it's a theory.
- T-A 9y ago> The universe is virtually certain to fall into a lower-energy quantum vacuum state. That we have not observed it to be the case means either that we have been astonishingly lucky, or that there is a selection process going on. If that is the most solid argument in favor of the quantum multiverse, this paper is a disaster. See Eq. 6.28: the probability that we should have seen a bubble by now is < 10^-516.
- jerf 9y agoWhen I quoted that argument, I was not saying it was 100% accurate; after all, I don't believe it myself. If further work comes along to prove that the collapse into the lower state is not highly probable, then the argument collapses. Again, not accepting the multiverse anyhow, that the best argument in its favor collapses would not particularly bother me. Of course, it would not constitute evidence against, merely a lack of evidence for. Now, some people with a insufficiently deep understanding of probabilities and such will say those two things are completely different, but they aren't; lack of evidence for is indeed a form of evidence against, especially if one is actively searching for the evidence. It just isn't very strong, and it certainly isn't a proof.