4 ms·
> The reason why everyone trusts the LIGO result is that we have an extremely high degree of confidence in general relativity. No, that's not true. The reaso
by lisper 9y ago
> The reason why everyone trusts the LIGO result is that we have an extremely high degree of confidence in general relativity.
No, that's not true. The reason everyone "trusts" the LIGO results is because we believe the people running the experiment are trustworthy. The results have nothing to do with GR except insofar as they were designed to test a heretofore untested prediction of GR (which prediction they have confirmed).
And the reason we want to test a prediction of GR is that we want to try to falsify it, because that is the way progress is made in science.
I think you may have meant to say something about how we cannot know for certain that GR is true, that that's right, we can't. But it's not like Einstein just pulled GR out of a hat. It's the only known solution to the problem that fits all of the known data. That doesn't prove it's true, but it is the best explanation we have so we might as well carry on as if it's true until someone proves otherwise or comes up with a better idea.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoI don't think that LIGO was designed (only) to test GR. It was also set up to be an astronomical observatory. (I don't know which goal was considered more important...)
- lisper 9y agoWhy do you think those are different goals?
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoBecause in the astronomy part, we're assuming the GR is correct, and using it to watch astronomical events in a way we couldn't before. For example, the detected neutron star merger tested that gravitational waves travel at the speed of light, since we were able to also detect the fast gamma ray burst from it. That's testing GR. But it also showed that such fast gamma ray bursts come from the merger of two neutron stars. That's not testing GR.
- perlgeek 9y agoMy impression was that they made advanced predictions what a gravitational wave observation would look like from a binary black hole merger, and then they measured pretty much exactly that. This is why we believe the machine worked. The other reason we believe them is that they (together with VIRGO) found a neutron star merger, and that was confirmed by many other observations in many different spectra.