4 ms·
Number of citations is gamed too easily. You would first get self-citations and, after you started ignoring those, citation rings (groups of people colluding to
by Someone 9y ago
Number of citations is gamed too easily. You would first get self-citations and, after you started ignoring those, citation rings (groups of people colluding to citate each other excessively).
So, yes, you would need to assign a reputation to citations. I don’t think that’s a solved problem or even simpler than the problem of assigning reputation to papers.
- rocqua 9y agoThis is the same problem google faced and 'solved' by with the page-rank algorithm. I've seen some attempts at applying this to the reference graph, but it doesn't seem to be taking off.
- cornholio 9y agoIt's not taking off because, out of the box, it can't replace the gatekeepers: there needs to be a certain time period, sometimes decades, from publication until the moment a major work is recognized and cited. Cites form a DAG (old papers never cite newer ones) so do not converge on a recursive application of PageRank, newest works have all identical weights by definition. So in the short run, you still need a prospective measure of scientific value, and acceptance for publication in a selective journal ("impact factor") serves that purpose well.
- rocqua 9y agoAh of-course. I forgot the convergence requirements for pagerank. Indeed, the fact that cites are a DAG really does kind of screw with pagerank. Note that my supposed idea was to use 'pagerank' to replace reference count as the value of a work. Not to replace peer review.