3 ms·
Cooking and "total utilization" are two different goals. It may be laudable (and very politically correct) to teach kids to "totally utilize" every last bit of
by bambax 16y ago
Cooking and "total utilization" are two different goals. It may be laudable (and very politically correct) to teach kids to "totally utilize" every last bit of food from yesterday's lunch, but it's not fine cooking.
I love leftovers. I love rillettes, and saucisson. I made saucisson once, when I was maybe ten. I watched the pig being killed, and hanged by the feet for the blood to go, and then I helped cut it, and put the meat in the machine and the intestine at the other end. I liked that. No problem. (The problem is you have to wait six months to eat what you just helped make).
But there is a reason why good restaurants serve food from the "noble" parts of animals, and chicken nuggets are found at McDonalds: noble parts taste better. They require less processing -- or no processing: "just the product".
The goal of Jamie Olivier is not to convince kids not to eat nuggets; it's to show how things are made.
- tptacek 16y agoThis is absolutely not true. In fact, unless you eat a lot of Mexican and know the good places, you have to go to a fine dining restaurant to find the offal bits. And, of course, in most kitchens, a fully cleaned chicken carcass in no way qualifies as "offal". Incidentally, and I'm sorry that this isn't going to help your argument (OK, no I'm not): the #1 ingredient in McDonalds Chicken McNuggets? "White boneless chicken". And no other ingredient on the list is an animal protein, either. The real world is pretty much the exact opposite of the argument you just made. In the real word, the "noble" meat is the cheap, unhealthy stuff, because it's the product of a hellaciously compromised system that is optimized to produce "noble" white meat chicken (from chickens that can't even walk properly because of the way they've been manipulated into bulking up) in huge volume; that meat is medicated from egg to slaughterhouse in antibiotics, raised on bone meal and fecal matter, and then finished off with a sweetened, dextrose-enhanced batter in a deep fryer. If Jamie Oliver wants to convince kids not to eat chicken nuggets, bully for him. He should use the same argument he used with adults just a few years ago, when he filmed dinner tables full of people in evening dress buddying up with cute, fluffy baby chicks, and then killed all the male chicks in front of them. The kids would definitely remember that, and wouldn't be premising their diets on broken and unhealthy beliefs about meat quality.
- bambax 16y agoMaybe I should mention that I'm French and live just outside Paris. I buy my food at the "farmers'" market -- which is just the market: there is no other kind. (There are supermarkets though, of course; but even inside supermarkets you find real butcher's shops where you can buy whole animals. Well, not whole cows -- but you can find whole rabbits or chickens (or any kind of fish/seafood) in any supermarket here). I would oppose "trash" to "noble" and not "offal"; a liver or a heart is "offal", but a chicken carcass (the subject of Oliver's piece) is not, because it can't be cooked and eaten as such. Also, I think you fundamentally agree with Jamie Olivier: you're denouncing junk food just as he is. Your point is that meat is over-processed during its (short) life; his point is that we're fed carcass reprocessed to look like whole food. Aren't you both making the same point?