3 ms·
YIMBYs do acknowledge the central role of zoning in shaping the sprawled-out, car-dominated shape of modern American life. We disagree that it ought to be prese
by closeparen 9y ago
YIMBYs do acknowledge the central role of zoning in shaping the sprawled-out, car-dominated shape of modern American life. We disagree that it ought to be preserved.
I’ve come to understand that economic-justice arguments on both sides are really ex post facto rationalizations for beliefs like “we should live in houses and drive” vs. “we should live in condos and take transit.” The houses-and-cars people have a point: an abundance of condos in the sky does nothing to help (and probably hurts) affordability for the type of housing they consider fit for human consumption.
Unfortunately we talk about boxes in the sky as “luxury” with the subtext that having your own plot of land, some of which you don’t even build on isn’t.
- pcwalton 9y ago> I’ve come to understand that economic-justice arguments on both sides are really ex post facto rationalizations for beliefs like “we should live in houses and drive” vs. “we should live in condos and take transit.” Yeah, unfortunately I think this is basically true. You can almost perfectly predict whether someone supports SB 827 based on whether they prefer single family homes or urban density.
- davidw 9y agoThe crazy thing is that you can prefer to live in a SFH yourself and still be in favor of letting the market add density. If you already have a SFH, no one will make you move.
- pcwalton 9y agoWell, unless you're renting the home and your landlord evicts you to make room for a condo building. This would be an uncommon situation, but evicting low-income tenants of low-density apartments to make room for higher-end high-density condos is a related, and legitimate, concern. The bill should probably continue to be amended to make sure this doesn't happen. Note that this concern is basically irrelevant to all the Bay Area suburbs like Palo Alto that have virtually no low-income tenants to begin with, as well as San Francisco, which is essentially completely gentrified at this point.
- kspaans 9y agoOr if your land gets up-zoned and suddenly is worth 3x as much, and your property taxes go up accordingly (if you don't live in CA at least).
- zjaffee 9y agoThe number of times I've seen YIMBYs say things like "Abolish All Zoning" is rather high. Zoning is a far more complicated thing than just restricting density, it prevents industrial manufacturing from happening right next to an elementary school, and it allows cities to make sure that sidewalk space in front of buildings are publicly accessible.
- closeparen 9y agoYIMBYs come out to support apartment buildings, not factories. The big YIMBY upzoning bill increases permitted housing density while not interfering with sidewalks. This sort of reply is pedantic. “Zoning” to YIMBYs means single-family and low-rise caps on residential density, and sometimes the separation of shops/offices from residential neighborhoods.