3 ms·
Heritability and genetics operate on probability and statistics in very similar ways that we measure information in regard to race and gender. As such, there is
by belorn 9y ago
Heritability and genetics operate on probability and statistics in very similar ways that we measure information in regard to race and gender. As such, there is not very much difference between a policy based on genetics, race, or gender. Such policy is trying to catch a problem through the probability that a category of people will share a common trait.
In my opinion I agree that genetics is rarely a good idea to base a policy, but would your perspective agree to the same statement in regard to race and gender idenity?
I prefer a scientific approach. Take gender identity, genetics, race idenity, sexual preference, religions affiliation, nationality, or any other social identity and measure the "heritability" factor that a certain "trait" (ie data pattern) will happen. Treat it all as prediction models and create polices if and only if underlying detectable distinctions are meaningful and a general policy has been tested and found ineffective.
- ggm 9y agoWell.. I posted a very reactive answer. We've had some issues in Australia with self identified indigenous and Tasmania, where the genocide removed all but perhaps three families so the DNA evidence of first ownership might actually be strong. This is a sore topic. I'm more concerned about unregulated use of DNA by health and other insurance companies, or the hiring policies of Google and like who chase the top 5% and could argue in some dystopian HR for non intrusive DNA tests to confirm high mathematicial ability or something. I really don't like identity politics much either but policies to confront gender and race bias takes you there. I don't think I have the answer. I worry the debate is capable of being derailed rapidly but perhaps that's what I'm doing too?