3 ms·
This is such a false premise. What you don’t realize about those jobs is they go out of their way to diminish what people earn. “Burger flippers” are not hired
by ianai 9y ago
This is such a false premise. What you don’t realize about those jobs is they go out of their way to diminish what people earn. “Burger flippers” are not hired full time. They give them full time -1 hour just to avoid providing benefits. They’ll even break up a workers schedule and require them work two different locations in the same day. They are not paid for travel time and the hours don’t add up to full time.
Then there are sewage workers. I recall on “Dirty Jobs” the divers that have to work on submerged pipes make large amounts of money (six figures iirc).
I advocate for UBI because we really do have enough to feed and house everyone. The UBI isn’t a quota system - merely a per deim to purchase the bare minimum. That won’t place artificial prices on commodities nor force labor. People will still purchase goods and services on a relative, trade-off basis. The current system forces labor.
As for whether people will then decide to not work for burger joints: if a business needs to resort to the business practices I mentioned earlier in order to operate then maybe that business isn’t needed by society. Further, people with a UBI will see the minimal hours scheduled as a bonus - they’re just adding another income stream to their UBI at that point. And yes, the line for cutting off either should not exist or be high enough to be negligible at the trade off point.
- emodendroket 9y agoThe most advanced society in the world still needs grave diggers and morticians. You can change the structure of jobs and compensation but you probably can't have a system where people only do work they love.
- coldtea 9y ago>The most advanced society in the world still needs grave diggers and morticians. You can change the structure of jobs and compensation but you probably can't have a system where people only do work they love. There are lots of people that take pride in being grave diggers and morticians. It's also a cool job for anyone with gothic tendencies... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9v3VZ-kQn4s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9v3VZ-kQn4s
- emodendroket 9y agoTaking pride in the work isn't the same thing as loving it so much you'd be doing it for free.
- coldtea 9y agoI don't think many people love their work so much they'd be doing it for free. At best, they'd doing SIMILAR work for free -- but not the work itself, with the commercial and organizational constraints it has. E.g. even if some people love programming and would still program for free, they wouldn't really want to program the features some bozo PMs have decided, and in the timeline they provided, and with meetings and other baggage that comes with it being a job. So, one might love the field/domain, but loving "the job" itself is far less common (if it exists).
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, yes, I agree. That's kind of what I was getting at.
- slothtrop 9y ago>I advocate for UBI because we really do have enough to feed and house everyone. Sure, though I contend we ought to see much further than this. We need infrastructure in place, when the time comes, to allow citizens to collaborate efficiently on large projects as without income and access to capital, loafing around only gets you so far. Lower-income/no-income citizens in the West rely on welfare, low-income housing as it is but that doesn't dispel the "impoverished" status despite being fed and housed; it mostly stretches beyond homelessness. And by extension ubi won't turn everyone into middle-class citizens. It doesn't address the issues of drug and crime microcultures in the ghetto either.