4 ms·
If it'd been a Waymo or Tesla car I'd have been more likely to give some benefit of the doubt. Driving is hard and most of these systems already make fewer mist
by _bxg1 9y ago
If it'd been a Waymo or Tesla car I'd have been more likely to give some benefit of the doubt. Driving is hard and most of these systems already make fewer mistakes than human drivers.
But Uber never has been and never will be trustworthy. It's a toxic organization that will continue moving fast and breaking things - sometimes intentionally - until it's stopped by either the market or the government.
- akira2501 9y ago> Driving is hard and most of these systems already make fewer mistakes than human drivers. When driven in a small number of states that have beneficial weather conditions. I don't think we've done _nearly_ enough testing to come to this conclusion yet.
- herbstein 9y agoEven so, the places that Tesla and Waymo primarily drive - while "easy" for an autonomous car - should then also be easier for human drivers. His point is that they're in fewer mistakes and human drivers. In the end that is all we need from these cars. As long as they make fewer mistakes than us they are a success.
- jackvalentine 9y ago> Even so, the places that Tesla and Waymo primarily drive - while "easy" for an autonomous car - should then also be easier for human drivers. His point is that they're in fewer mistakes and human drivers. Genuinely curious if you've come across accident statistics that break down human miles in to similar categories as the kind of miles autonomous cars drive.
- cctt23 9y agoThe numbers so far, including human intervention rates do not support the claim that autonomy beats humans. With a limited dataset, the suggestion is very much in the other direction. These vehicles may someday be better than us, but “someday” isn’t today. In particular I think Uber had a human intervention on avg every 13mi. Edit: I’d love to hear a counterpoint, although of course I accept that’s not required. Like the discussion about fusion, people seem to argue from a point in the future when all of the problems and limitations of today are gone. Let’s try arguing from what’s possible now instead.
- paul7986 9y agoNot today, but don't worry after these robot cars kill 1000s to more innocent people they will be safer. All those killed will just help us learn to improve and make progress.
- Consultant32452 9y agoIf you haven't heard of it, you may be interested in the trolley dilemma. https://theconversation.com/the-trolley-dilemma-would-you-kill-one-person-to-save-five-57111 https://theconversation.com/the-trolley-dilemma-would-you-ki...
- perl4ever 9y agoThe trolley dilemma is something that people are not very receptive to in real life, because the very fact that someone presents such a dilemma leads to suspicion about the accuracy of the number of lives saved vs. destroyed. The type of mentality that would sacrifice one life to save five is instinctively assumed by a lot of people to be the sort of mentality that would deceive themselves and/or others about the correct statistics and the uncertainty thereof. Assuming the ratio of 1:5 to be accurate and worthwhile is largely missing the real issue, in my opinion.
- theyinwhy 9y agoInteresing to see how little customers can do to stop them. As they are always in the red they never attracted enough customers for their business case. Nevertheless they always are able to get fresh money. The customer is irrelevant and left out of the equation. It is the shareholders that bet on the future no matter how dire the present is. That really speaks volumes about how capitalism works and is depressing as there is nothing you can do to boykott this company.
- perl4ever 9y agoCapitalism has resulted in us drowning in capital. This seems to me to be a statement about its success, not its failure(s). Would the alternative (scarce, expensive capital) be better?
- theyinwhy 9y agoI am pretty sure you are not talking about the majority here when referring to "us".
- mnm1 9y agoWhy should we need to boycott a company like this? The government should prevent them from operating, otherwise it has failed at its job. In this case, this has led to a death, which is still probably not enough for the government to intervene permanently. Seems too me like the failure here is completely with the government failing to do its job of regulating and protecting people. Given enough cash, I'm not surprised and am prepared to see many more people die at the hands of companies like uber without any serious consequences whatsoever for the company.