3 ms·
NUMTOTs idealizes city populations and social climates at the nadir of urban decay, and wishes that they could have all the infrastructure-investment trappings
by closeparen 9y ago
NUMTOTs idealizes city populations and social climates at the nadir of urban decay, and wishes that they could have all the infrastructure-investment trappings of contemporary global powerhouses without any of those pesky middle-class people ruining the culture and taking up space.
It's the revolutionary-socialist working class squabbling with the salaried middle class while millionaire homeowners cheer them on and pocket the home-equity gains of a "we should only build what we can publicly finance" development policy.
It holds that cities are great, but all actual examples of people internalizing this information and migrating towards urban lifestyles are crimes against humanity. It believes that people should not live in suburbs, but that development should be subject to as much local control as possible (maintaining a situation where most housing is in suburbs). These contradictions are held to be contradictions of capitalism itself, with a socialist revolution and a completely unspecified "make housing a human right" scheme as the only remedy.
It's fascinating, enthralling, maddening. I was really into it for a while and burned out.
- zjaffee 9y agoExcept for the fact that the true middle class has already been displaced from city centers already, the current debate is between those who are/were working class and those who are upper middle class/upper class (but aren't necessarily the 1%). Where historically, this population had used their same political power that they are using now to gentrify neighborhoods to systematically deny access to the suburbs to people of color and lower income people forcing them in cities. To fight against community displacement because it's a current trend for rich people to want to live in city centers isn't a war on the middle class necessarily when it comes to the long term, because said trend could easily reverse again.
- Itaxpica 9y agoIt mostly just sounds like bog-standard leftbook with an urbanist skin.
- closeparen 9y agoYeah, with the caveat that moderators explictly say "this is not leftbook" and there's a fair amount of debate from the YIMBY side.
- zjaffee 9y agoSaying this isn't leftbook means that you won't be banned from the group for having opinions that aren't highly liberal.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoAre we talking about the same group? The NUMTOT I'm in is basically pure YIMBY.