3 ms·
That's always sad to see people focused on Energy when talking about electricty : the grid needs Power not Energy. And since you can't realistically store elect
by littlestymaar 9y ago
That's always sad to see people focused on Energy when talking about electricty : the grid needs Power not Energy. And since you can't realistically store electricity, these two are really different beasts. Renewable is OK at producing Energy, which we don't really care about after a certain point, but it's terrible at producing a reliable amount of Power which is what we need.
More on that here : https://bourrasque.info/articles/20180116-moulins-%C3%A0-vent https://bourrasque.info/articles/20180116-moulins-%C3%A0-ven... (in French though)
- ukulele 9y agoThis is essentially incorrect. Renewables have predictable generation when deployed on a large scale, and gas peaker plants can respond to changes as needed. With the simplistic model of the article (nuclear + wind), it is easy to reach the wrong conclusion.
- layoric 9y agoReally? In Australia we still see large wind and solar ramp events that are hard to forecast and predict even with some of the most modern weather forecasting approaches, these are solvable problems but I think calling renewables predictable is a bit hand-wavy IMO.
- ukulele 9y agoIt's not about forecasting the weather: good gas peakers can respond in under 10 minutes. I meant predictable in the sense of day/night/season.
- layoric 9y agoGas is a good backup due to it’s response rate yes but regarding renewable power generation, they are all about weather. http://www.hellogrid.com.au/energy-exchange/1117/ http://www.hellogrid.com.au/energy-exchange/1117/ As solar utility scale sites become more common (and they are), a cloud growth can wipe 100s of MW off the grid very quickly and the problem is it is very hard to tell how much will get wiped off and when (measured in minutes). Gas will be in the mix for longer than other fossil fuels due to its reaction time but as storage becomes cheaper and gas more expensive, it will be used less and less IMO.
- littlestymaar 9y agoStorage isn't physically doable in practice though, and it's not just a matter of cost at our current consumption level. We just don't have the natural ressources to build enough storage. To illustrate, storage is already really cheap in practice thanks to Pumped-storage, we just have really sort supply of locations for such plants.
- littlestymaar 9y agoGas can be used as a complement to renewable, but at this point you mostly have renewable helping gas power plants saving money instead of the 100% renewable often advertised. Which is what I meant when I said : > Renewable is OK at producing Energy, which we don't really care about after a certain point.
- layoric 9y agoRight, intermittency is the biggest challenge renewables have but this is not an unsolvable problem. Forecasting and storage along with some automation will accelerate the transition to largely renewable powered electricity grid. The price of generation is too cheap to ignore. These solutions are still in their infancy but I think (I’m bias as I work in this space building said solutions) will become the standard operation in less than a decade. That isn’t to say most developed countries won’t still be using fossil fuels (especially nuclear due to cost to build and gas due to its speed to ramp up and down), but purely for economical reasons, the transition will happen and these intermittency issues will be resolved in the next 10ish years IMO.
- littlestymaar 9y agoHave you read the storage figures in the article ? Storage won't do it, not with are current consumption, which will likely increase when electric cars become mainstream (which is a terrible idea btw). Also, storage is never counted as part of renewable costs in articles promoting renewable.
- layoric 9y agoI’m not seeing any specific over night storage numbers in the article no, but you’re right this is a huge problem that Li-ion won’t solve alone. Hydro will be a large part of this where geographically practical and then there are also a number of other options like molten salt that may also play a role. Our habits around electricity use will also have to change as well but with vehicle to grid solutions starting to come online from car manufacturers like Nissan, I think electric cars will be part of the solution though one that will take 20-30 years to become a major player. Cost of storage isn’t talked about for renewables usually because it isn’t needed to provide ~50%+ of usage, it’s the last 30% that will require storage of some kind for 100%. This will be doable for places near hydro but harder for places without. At 100,000GWh till end of March FY means ~140GWh over the 12 hours at night assuming usage is flat over the day (which it isn’t). I think you’re right that a usage behaviour change would be make the storage problem more practical to address.. EDIT: Incorrect figures from article regarding usage over 12 hour period.