3 ms·
I'm sympathetic to your problems and I see nothing inherently wrong with deleting a post that doesn't belong there and sending a standard message related to it.
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
I'm sympathetic to your problems and I see nothing inherently wrong with deleting a post that doesn't belong there and sending a standard message related to it. But the GP is saying he is tempted to troll the subreddit in question because of feeling burned.
This was something I thought a lot about as a moderator. If I don't have time to deal with these small issues, when I am going to find time to deal with the towering inferno that is growing because of me putting out the fire with gasoline?
Sometimes, it isn't what you do per se, it's how you do it.
When I was homeless, I had a question deleted from Metafilter and not hugely long after, someone else asked the exact same question with identical wording but a different explanation for asking and it was allowed to stand. That looks to me like the reason mine got deleted was not because the question was not allowed, but because the mods were classist assholes and actively looking to shit on me. We can't have the homeless woman having any positive experiences here. It might encourage her to stick around and, heaven forbid, even help improve her life and solve her problems, a platform we are actively hostile towards.
I really was okay with my questions sometimes being deleted, but a lot of the details of how this specific incident was handled suggested to me that it was not actually a case of "This question is in violation of the guidelines." And that is often the case. Sexism, racism, classism, homophobia, etc are often reinforced with such tactics because it maintains plausible deniability.
This is intended as food for thought. I am well aware moderating is challenging and that being too nice can serve as an attractive nuisance, causing people to dump on you and expect you to kiss their boo-boo in response to their icky behavior. There are no perfect solutions. I get that. I'm not trying to attack you.
- eecc 9y agoWell, I was just tempted what I did was to unsubscribe, once. Then I had another question, but was given the same treatment so now I’m gone for good... I don’t care if there’s interesting stuff or if I can contribute some, it’s just a hostile circle or i-dotters and t-crossers, life is too short
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThat's the right decision on your part and it speaks well of you. Nonetheless, that doesn't change the fact that your negative reaction has consequences and those consequences may be harmful to the forum. They have not only lost a potential member who was interested in the subject, you are here complaining about the forum in question, just as I am here testifying to my dreadful experiences with Metafilter. It's really challenging to pin down cause and effect for social phenomenon. It usually isn't as clear cut as "Flicking cigarettes out your car window while driving can start a forest fire." But I wonder a lot about the cause and effect of social events and how to mentally model them. Much of Georgia is split nearly 50-50 between blacks and whites. Other races represent a tiny fraction of the population. Years ago, I saw a TV show that traced the origins of gang violence in Atlanta to a small number of Hispanic children being treated badly at school by both whites and blacks, which meant almost everyone treated them badly for being the wrong race. On the show, they interviewed some of the original members of the first gang. One of them said he joined because he was tired of being scared. After he joined, he no longer needed to be scared because now people were scared of him. Online forums are real social environments. What we say and do on the internet can lead to serious real world consequences. People have married others they met via an online forum. People have been fired from their job for comments made online. My recollection is the gang violence in Atlanta could be traced to just nine Hispanic kids who simply were treated in a very unwelcoming way and who just could not make positive social connections no matter what they did. You don't need to mistreat all that many people to lead to a metaphorical conflagration. Our actions have consequences. For good or for ill, those consequences often come back to us.