3 ms·
The whole basis for allowing non-competes as a matter of public policy (in states other than California) is to prevent "the first bite of the apple", i.e. to pr
by hga 16y ago
The whole basis for allowing non-competes as a matter of public policy (in states other than California) is to prevent "the first bite of the apple", i.e. to prevent irreparable harm from the first use of an employee's knowledge of trade secrets. For most of us (e.g. hackers/programmers) that's generally not a big deal let alone legitimate, which might explain how Silicon Valley has done so well in an legal regime free of them (or as I argue, it's the most important factor in SV's success; it's certainly the only unique one).
In this case, HP's claim that "he cannot perform his duties for Oracle without necessarily using and disclosing HP's trade secrets and confidential information to others" has a lot of merit. How could he possibly do his job, assuming it includes Sun systems stuff where HP directly competes, while compartmentalizing his very current knowledge of HP's legitimate trade secrets.
E.g. knowledge of HPs major customers and their pain points, knowledge of how HP sees the market and what it is developing in response; heck, knowledge of how HP is planning on converting more Sun customers to HP.
I loathe non-competes in general, but this sure looks like a legitimate exception to me.
- kenjackson 16y agoHow can you have irreperable harm in these sorts of business matters? No one is going to get killed or lose an arm. They can fix the issue with money.
- hga 16y ago"Irreparable damage" as defined in my copy of The Plain-Language Law Dictionary" is "INJURY of such a nature that it is impossible to calculate its extent by an award of money". Here's my impressions as to how that can come about; they're not at all solid, I'm not even an amateur in this area, I've just read a lot of general business stuff: First of all, how can money recover the time and attention lost in litigating the issue? (A general problem, I grant you.) And then there's standard of and time lines for proof. Let's say I sue now, but whatever settlement I get doesn't prevent me from going out of business anyway a few years later. Both get to the next and defining problem: determining the proper amount of money to change hands. We can be sure the two sides will disagree ^_^. How does the damaged party prove that $X amount of damage to its future prospects has been made? They probably can't even be sure themselves. Even if they know it will put them out of business, how do they prove how much business they would have made without the injury???
- kenjackson 16y agoBut this seems like a problem with almost any civil suit. For example, a patent infringement has the exact same problems. Or slander, etc.... They all take time and attention for litigation. They all can have extended time where you don't get paid for years. And all have the same problems of determining damages now, and in the future. It just seems like an odd law that you could sue somebody who not only hasn't done anything yet, but has never had a past history that would lead one to believe that they might break the law. And its absurd for HP to say that its impossible for him to do his job at Oracle. It's very common for executives, with similar levels of knowledge to move from one company to a competitor. In fact, its almost always the case that they do go to a competitor.