7 ms·
This is the Cloudflare resolver, right? What's the "privacy-first" part about? It's just another third party DNS host. They haven't changed the protocol to b
by ajross 9y ago
This is the Cloudflare resolver, right? What's the "privacy-first" part about? It's just another third party DNS host. They haven't changed the protocol to be uninspectable and AFAIK haven't made any guarantees about logging or whatnot that would enhance privacy vs. using whatever you are now. This just means you're trusting Cloudflare instead of Comcast or Google or whoever.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- shimms 9y agoYes they have: "Privacy First: Guaranteed. We will never sell your data or use it to target ads. Period. We will never log your IP address (the way other companies identify you). And we’re not just saying that. We’ve retained KPMG to audit our systems annually to ensure that we're doing what we say. Frankly, we don’t want to know what you do on the Internet—it’s none of our business—and we’ve taken the technical steps to ensure we can’t."
- dictum 9y ago> Frankly, we don’t want to know what you do on the Internet—it’s none of our business In the DNS resolver space, what is their business?
- hrunt 9y agoThey want fast resolution of names that point to websites hosted by Cloudflare. Cloudflare makes their money selling their network to businesses that use it, and anything that makes that service better for the end-user increases customer stickiness.
- distantsounds 9y agoMaking the internet fast and reliable, and arguably DNS resolution plays into that.
- tbyehl 9y agoCould be a precursor to launching an OpenDNS competitor.
- wtmt 9y agoIs OpenDNS even as relevant as it was earlier, before Google DNS appeared (and then OpenDNS was bought by Cisco)?
- tialaramex 9y agoMaybe not _as_ relevant, but still a considerable number of clients are configured to trust OpenDNS, and their far more ambiguous stance on what exactly this is for is appealing to some people. For example, OpenDNS says yes, absolutely it is their business what you're looking up, and maybe you are a Concerned Parent™ who wants to ensure their children don't access RedTube, so that feels like a good idea.
- tbyehl 9y agoI was thinking more along the lines of their SME offering. DNS filtering is an important layer in network security and CloudFlare’s position of being in the middle of a large portion of Internet traffic, alongside now trying to attract a chunk of general DNS queries, potentially gives them a great deal of insight into who the bad actors are.
- jhanschoo 9y agoTraffic from heavily censored regimes to its big customers, which often end up being censored due to user contributions, I suppose.
- ajross 9y agoSerious question: where is that quote from? The link above is just to the resolver address.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vimda 9y agoDid you read the page? They're supporting DNS over TLS and DNS over HTTPS - both changes to the protocol to make in uninspectable. They've also said they're not logging IP info and they're getting independent auditors in to confirm what they're saying. Sounds trustworthy to me
- dingaling 9y agoBoth encrypted extensions are of course inspectable at the end-point, which is the privacy model being discussed. What is intriguing to me is why Cloudflare are offering this. Perhaps it is to provide data on traffic that is 'invisible' to them, as in it doesn't currently touch their networks. Possibly as a sales-lead generator. Or is the plan to become dominant and then use DNS blackholing to shutdown malware that is a threat to their systems?
- vimda 9y agoIm probably being naive, but maybe altruism? At least if you buy into their making the internet better rhetoric
- wtmt 9y agoCloudflare is already a significant enough player in handling Internet traffic. Maybe the company does want to do good for the sake of doing good, but I’m wary of companies taking over in this manner and making the Internet more like a monolith than a distributed system.
- zackbloom 9y agoThe goal is to make the sites that use Cloudflare ridiculously fast by putting the authoritative and recursive DNS on the same machine (for clients who use 1.1.1.1).
- kzrdude 9y agoIt seems like bait-and-switch though? They tell about DNS over https and dns without logging, and then direct to an installation instruction where you can learn to start to use, "DNS without logging", but nothing that's encrypted? What am I missing?
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y agoOn the contrary, they've taken 2 big steps that are better than ISPs (not sure about Google): * no logging * DNS over HTTPS
- therealmarv 9y agoGoogle is one of the first ones using DNS over HTTPS. BTW if you want to use DNS over HTTPS on Linux/Mac I strongly recommend dnscrypt proxy V2 (golang rewrite) https://github.com/jedisct1/dnscrypt-proxy https://github.com/jedisct1/dnscrypt-proxy and put e.g. cloudflare in their config toml file to make use of it.
- cptskippy 9y agoThe whole point of encrypting DNS traffic is to hide it from the likes of Google.
- akquise 9y agoFor me personally it is much more important to hide my DNS traffic from my ISP instead of Google, etc., even though I don't live in the US. I pay them to access the internet, every further information they gather about my internet activity does not mean any benefit for me.
- opencl 9y agoHiding DNS traffic from your ISP is pointless when you have to give them the IP that gets resolved anyway for them to route your traffic.
- markonen 9y agoNot really. Typically the query includes much more information (the site you want to visit) than the response (an IP potentially shared by thousands or millions of sites).
- otoburb 9y agoCloudflare is making a public pronouncement that they're not going to sell your DNS data nor track your IP address, with the implication that they will also not use the usage data to upsell you services. That's about the only additional "privacy" edge they offer. In the same breath, they insinuate that Google both sells and uses DNS usage from their 8.8.8.8 and 8.8.4.4 resolvers.
- heisenbit 9y agoThey are NOT saying Google is lying and collecting the data. They are saying the business model of Google inherently provides such incentive. Cloudflare is somewhat right: Means, Motive and Opportunity - but for a conviction you have to prove someone acted on the Opportunity. The Motive of Google is tampered with severe risk for loosing trust. Cloudflare can make an argument they are fundamentally better positioned and that is all they do. As with all US based operations the NSA may cook up some convincing counterarguments and we may never know.
- Twisol 9y agoIt's clear what you meant, but for whatever it's worth, I think the word you wanted was "tempered", not "tampered".
- wtmt 9y agoFor what it’s worth, you missed to point out “loosing” vs. “losing” in that comment (where it talks about “loosing trust”). :)
- Twisol 9y agoThat looked more like a garden-variety typo than a bona fide eggcorn, so I gave it a pass ;) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eggcorn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eggcorn
- bogomipz 9y ago>"They are NOT saying Google is lying and collecting the data." The OP did not say that cloudflare is "saying" that. The OP very clearly said they are "insinuating" it. And yes under the heading "DNS's Privacy Problem" the post mentions: "With all the concern over the data that companies like Facebook and Google are collecting on you,..." I think that juxtaposition of this statement under a bolded heading of "DNS's Privacy Problem" is very much insinuating that.
- tialaramex 9y ago"We will never log your IP address (the way other companies identify you). And we’re not just saying that. We’ve retained KPMG to audit our systems annually to ensure that we're doing what we say." Now, audits are generally not worth very much (even, perhaps even especially, from a Big Four group like KPMG), but for this type of thing (verifying that a company isn't doing something they promised they would not do) they're about the best we have.
- runningmike 9y agoWhere is the technical audit report published? Open access url please.
- bostik 9y agoHaving dealt with KPMG recently (which I do at least once a year...), I would not expect to see the report. KPMG's risk department - the lawyers' lawyers - appears to be violently allergic to their customers disclosing any report to outside parties. Based on my experience you can get a copy, but first you and the primary customer need to submit some paperwork. And among the conditions you need to agree with is that you don't redistribute the report or its contents. Disclosure: I deal with security audits and technical aspects of compliance.
- jlgaddis 9y ago> KPMG's risk department - the lawyers' lawyers - appears to be violently allergic to their customers disclosing any report to outside parties. Isn't that the entire point of such an audit? To be able to present it to outside third-parties? For examples, Mozilla (CA/B) requires audits for root CAs. The CA must provide a link to the audit on the auditor's public web site -- forwarding a copy or hosting it on their own isn't sufficient.
- tialaramex 9y agoYou'd think, but it's surprisingly difficult to get the real full audit report. Mozilla's root policy _does_ require that they be shown the report, and has a bunch of extra requirements in there to ensure they're more detail, rather than some summary or overview document the auditors were persuaded to produce for this purpose. But the CA/B rules would allow just an audit letter which basically almost always says "Yes, we did an audit, and everything is fine" unless the auditors weren't comfortable writing "everything is fine". And almost always they feel that a footnote on a sub-paragraph buried in a detailed report is enough to leave "everything is fine" as the headline in the letter... If you've ever been audited for some other reason, you'll know they find lots of things, and then you fix them, and that's "fine". But well, is it fine? Or, should we acknowledge that they found lots of things and what those things were, even if you subsequently fixed them? The CA/B says you have several months to hand over your letter after the audit period. Guess what those months are spent doing...
- cornholio 9y agoI think the whole point for such free services is to log that data and extract statistical meaning out of it - in this case, they pledge to use an anonymized format. On the other hand CloudFlare's mission (ensure secure, solid end to end connectivity) is much better aligned with the user's needs than Google's mission (sell more ads).