3 ms·
I think there is a common economic structure in organization that creates a-hole cultures. Actors, PhD students, etc. enter into superstar economy where many
by nabla9 9y ago
I think there is a common economic structure in organization that creates a-hole cultures.
Actors, PhD students, etc. enter into superstar economy where many people compete for very small number of positions with prestige, money, power, fame (or whatever the measure of success is in the field).
Each position with value has large number of potential candidates who are all good enough. It's difficult or impossible to rank the top applicants with high accuracy and objectivity. Those who are selected are receiving something of great value from their mentors for subjective or arbitrary reasons.
Normally you would use auction or some other mechanism to sell the position, but actors or PhD student's don't have that kind of money and selling a position may be seen as ethically questionable because you are supposed to select the best.
The abusive culture is the result of this extra value that is given out for subjective reasons. Movie actors can be expected sell sex to cover the gap between their innate value and the position they are getting, PhD students can be used as a slave labor for years.
To correct the situation incentives should be aligned. If PhD student works on something for 5+ years, it should cost something for the boss. Dropping out from PhD program should cost something for those who are in the position to select who gets in.
- speedplane 9y agoInteresting that you focus only on actors and PhD students. What you describe is true of just about any field. The superstars are, by definition, rare. Sometimes they get their due to incredible skills, sometimes by luck, most often by both. It's also often the case that superstars not necessarily the best. This is true for superstar programmers, lawyers, basketball players, managers, machinists, and just about everyone. It's difficult to rank anyone for almost anything, the best aren't always chosen, and people often win for talents unrelated to their core competency. To sum it up... life isn't fair.
- nabla9 9y agoYou are either overgeneralizing or focusing in the wrong aspects of superstars. Functioning job market is antidote for subjectivity. Basketball players and many other sports have selection process and auctions and player markets. Multiple teams can evaluate the candidates and there is binding contracts where money is exchanged. (sports is US collages may be a form of abusing cheap labor though)
- speedplane 9y agoEvery selection process or auction contains subjectivity. Ball players are not just judged on their stats, but on their pedigree, coaches, and endorsements, the compilation of which are subjective. Fine art, which is often sold at open auctions, is completely subjective. Brands, connections, styles, and attitude are all attributes that are bought and sold, and are almost entirely subjective. Attempting to remove subjectivity from the job application or valuation process is a worthy goal, but has not historically been terribly successful.
- nabla9 9y agoThe mechanism I described does not arise from the subjectivity alone.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThe difference is that in some fields there is a huge gap between the superstars and everyone else. Someone who almost became a star actor probably has a second job as a waiter. Someone who almost became a tenured professor is probably making peanuts as an adjunct. Someone who almost because a superstar programmer is probably still making six figures.