4 ms·
I failed to get through the entire article. It repeats memes I have seen before that I see as an incomplete grasp of the situation at best. I have been a moder
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
I failed to get through the entire article. It repeats memes I have seen before that I see as an incomplete grasp of the situation at best.
I have been a moderator. I also was a full time parent for a long time. These two things have a lot in common.
It isn't true that your choices are either censorship or just letting some fool ruin everything. You can engage fools, welcome them, be kind, educate them and help them start fitting into the culture.
It helps to assume they are intelligent, but don't know everything. This is a rubric I learned by raising kids. Children aren't stupid, but they have a great deal to learn. A lot of the eye roll worthy stuff they do is just naivete, not intentionally bad behavior.
You can just explain stuff to people without being ugly, angry or condescending. You can just assume they haven't yet learned all the rules, they were distracted, their dog just died.
It helps to give people the benefit of the doubt the first several times and give them time to learn the ropes. People need to be clued that, hey, that doesn't work around here. If you don't tell them this isn't something we welcome here, don't be shocked when they keep doing it, oblivious to the fact that other people aren't cool with it. But you can tell them without being ugly about it.
A healthy community needs some tolerance for friction, mistakes and dust ups. No one should be expected to be perfect and occasionally defending yourself should be acceptable.
At the same time, it needs mechanisms to lubricate the social friction. An expectation of baseline respect is the best lubricant.
Respect is distinct from polite catch phrases and learning all the rules. Some of the most awful people are good at using polite catch phrases and memorizing the rules so they can politely shit all over everyone else. This is toxic behavior.
Yes, it's work to keep a community healthy. But, no, evaporative cooling is not inevitable.
- bad_user 9y agoThe parenting analogy is good, except ... we tolerate our children because they are our own. I'm a parent myself and I have infinite patience with my son. But few people have the energy and patience to tolerate and educate other people's children and those that do usually work in education. I can't stand other people's children running amok in restaurants for example. And I won't try to educate them, after all, I'm there to eat and maybe have a nice conversation with people I care about. I also won't try to educate their parents either. If they left their kids to run amok in that restaurant, then they are probably beyond educating. What I will do instead is to complain to the waiter. And then leave without leaving a tip if s/he does nothing about it. Because unless you have a big sign on your door that suggests "screaming children are welcome", then having other people's children screaming in my ear and running between the tables while I'm eating is not OK and I couldn't give a damn about the context that made that happen. Not my problem. And so it is with online communities in general ;-) If you're the educator type, good for you, I'm very grateful that such people exist. Other people are not and think they have better things to do.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoOn HN, the mods do a lot of the educating. You can do your part by just following the guidelines, which already admonish us to not engage in personal attacks and to just not reply to ugly comments instead of putting out the fire with gasoline. Following the guidelines yourself so as to leave room for other people to do some educating is sufficient. It isn't necessary for every single member to proactively educate newcomers. (In fact, that can go bad places. It can lead to newcomers being obnoxiously swamped with nitpicky "advice" every time they open their mouth, which is the opposite of welcoming and kind.) I will note that I didn't tolerate my kids. I adored them. I thought they were cute and funny and interesting and cuddly. But, boy, did they have a lot to learn about how life worked. I was happy to talk at them about life, the universe and everything while they soaked it up like little sponges.
- bad_user 9y agoHN is the perfect example of a community that is being defended. My account is almost ten years old and I've seen countless of comments and articles being censored and accounts being banned or soft-banned. And before that the community itself is pretty ruthless in downvoting any dissenting opinion. It actually gets pretty bad sometimes, because it encourages the hive mind effect, but if the alternative is the aggressiveness of Reddit, then I'm fine with how things are, because I still keep coming to HN, having given up on Reddit. > I will note that I didn't tolerate my kids. I adored them. It's pretty bad if you don't tolerate your own children. Yes, I know what you mean, any sane parent should adore their children, but note that I was talking of behavior when they do mistakes, not feelings. Invoking feelings in this conversation is eliciting an emotional response that detracts from the purpose of the conversation. The point was that really few people tolerate other people's children. That people don't say anything has to do with politeness, fear of repercussions or simply because they've got children of their own doing the same things. But even so, the sociological effect is pretty clear, it's for example the number one reason for why people that don't have small children stop hanging out with those that do.
- CraigJPerry 9y ago
- eecc 9y agoExactly. Speaking of “censorship” I posted twice for advice on r/diy and twice I was unceremoniously deleted by a moderator with some copypasta message. Sure, before posting I should have bothered reading the group EULA and realize there’s another “what’s this” sub (god knows what rules they have over there) but boy ain’t I genuinely bitter about the treatment. It alone makes me want to troll them just out of spite... couldn’t they just have been more polite and gasp ask me to move the post to this-and-that sub?! Politeness, assuming goodwill in the counterpart... generally being civil, oh i miss that!
- ubernostrum 9y agoI mod a medium-size (250k subscribers) subreddit. And... no, we do not have time to give personalized individual hand-holding attention to every single person who can't be bothered to read a simple set of rules linked from our sidebar. We use AutoModerator for a lot, and will be using it even more in the future. It's a very impersonal tool, but in any but the smallest subreddits it's simply not possible to scale up personalized moderation like what you're asking for. At some point you have to show some initiative and read subreddit rules or linked wiki pages/guides/FAQs for yourself rather than relying on the goodwill of volunteer moderators to do it for you.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoDoes the, or can the, automated moderation tools privately message the user and let them know why their post was moderated? Even if it just said the post was removed because it didn't meet the rules, here's a link please read??
- ubernostrum 9y agoIt can, and I've set it up to do that with some of the obvious stuff. Also working on reorganizing things to make it easier for AutoModerator to detect those things. But even then it's an impersonal deletion with a "copypasta message", which is what the parent comment was complaining is unacceptable.
- 9y ago