6 ms·
I feel that could be said of higher edu in general. That is, it's being promoted and recommended to too many who just aren't the right fit. God forbid a parent
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
I feel that could be said of higher edu in general. That is, it's being promoted and recommended to too many who just aren't the right fit. God forbid a parent with a degree have a kid without a degree. As if 25+ yrs ago is the same as now.
It's not much different than the housing crisis / crash. The unaware are fueling the fire, only to find out they're stuck with a bill beyond their means.
It's only a matter of time before higher edu implodes. It's not sustainable. It's not practical.
- nicoburns 9y agoTotally agree. And I would like to add that I don't even think a degree is the best way to learn even for many who excel at them.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoWorse. A degree is no proxy for drive, ambition, creative thinking, problem solving, etc. Too many have come to believe a degree is the magic. In some cases it is. In plenty of others it's a curse. The time and money could have been better spent elsewhere.
- noobly 9y agoIt's certainly no proxy, but it is a standard metric to measure said qualities against. I hope we see a rise in autodidact accreditation and acceptance of non traditional paths, along with more decentralized and public research taking place.
- nikofeyn 9y agoi agree with you. and most of the teaching in universities is absolutely pathetic. students primarily learn hopelessly alone through poor but overpriced books. the curriculum and professors are uninspiring, save for a few. it’s amazing what a good professor can do, but those are unfortunately rare. as someone who keeps thinking if i should go back to finish my ph.d., i can’t help but think of how dogmatic most graduate programs are in addition to being logistical nightmares. there’s basically no time or space for one to explore one’s own thoughts and program unless it specifically matches up with what someone else (namely an advisor) wants to do. there’s so much hand holding through required coursework (and homework) that one can’t hardly think deeply about anything actually original. the book disciplined minds touches upon this. that those born in institutions will carry that institutional conservatism with them. i have felt this. i went to talk about some of my ideas to a well known and respected researcher. before i could even finish my sentence that began with “i’m interested in...” he cut me off shaking his head and, literally, said “i don’t believe in it...”. goddamnit.
- imakecomments 9y ago>. there’s so much hand holding through required coursework (and homework) that one can’t hardly think deeply about anything actually original. Take an actual graduate course in pure mathematics, very little hand holding. >there’s basically no time or space for one to explore one’s own thoughts and program unless it specifically matches up with what someone else (namely an advisor) wants to do. Not necessarily true. Find an adviser that will support YOUR interest (they exist). Sounds like you have some biases against PhD programs without actual experience of being in a good one.
- nikofeyn 9y agosounds like you like making assumptions. > Take an actual graduate course in pure mathematics, very little hand holding. i have taken many. and you missed my point. i didn’t mean having one’s hand held through the actual material. that isn’t true at all of course, in part due to poor teaching and in part due to the difficulty of the material. i meant that one is forced to take x amount of courses. i believe, past a certain level, that this becomes extremely limiting. you spend all this time and time effort doing coursework and going to class rather than researching. learning within a context is much better than learning without context, aka most courses. and many schools hardly take any coursework transfers. there aren’t many good reason for this. and of course i have a bias because that’s what personal experience yields. but there’s no reason for you to insult me. i would wager my bias is shared by many who have been through ph.d. programs. and of course it’s not necessarily true. there are excellent advisors. but they are rare.
- unignorant 9y agojust as a point of optimistic contrast, i've taken only three required courses over my PhD. some of my peers (who came in with better undergrad prereqs) have taken less, and in a few cases, none
- usgroup 9y agoYou know I’d actually pay the crazy fees if only I could find a place that’d reteach me advanced maths “in context”. I find often that adding context means subtracting the “advanced” part :)
- z3t4 9y agoTo solve future problems and avoid war we need more educated people, not less.
- ekianjo 9y agoHaving a paper is not the only means to get educated these days. Oh and your assumption that education somewhat prevents wars is completely false. Societies like pre ww2 Germany and Japan were full of well educated folks.
- z3t4 9y agoA quick search gave plenty of articles saying higher education prevents war. For example "Among independents, education is highly related to support for the war. Those with only a high school education give clear majority support, but support declines as educational level increases." http://news.gallup.com/poll/7768/war-support-education-gap.aspx http://news.gallup.com/poll/7768/war-support-education-gap.a... "The results provide evidence for both the grievance and stability arguments, providing strong support for the pacifying effects of education on civil war" http://www.uky.edu/~clthyn2/thyne-ISQ-06.pdf http://www.uky.edu/~clthyn2/thyne-ISQ-06.pdf
- ekianjo 9y agoVery poor data to support your point. > There is a modest decline in war support as educational levels increase from high school or less, to some college, to college graduate (with no postgraduate education). However, the largest gap occurs at the highest level, between those with a postgraduate education and those without. Only among the postgraduate group is the majority opposed to war, 56% to 40%, while the other three categories all show majority support. Postgraduates almost don't count since there are so few of them in a civil society. So virtually no difference between high school level and college graduates, which does not support your point.
- icelancer 9y agoDo citizens vote for war? All of our leaders are very well educated, by American standards, yet war and police action persists.
- usgroup 9y agoEducation is unnecessarily expensive, but if it were otherwise, I’d say send everyone, pass or fail, for the benefit of what they glean trying. However, I’d also say , see the participation as benefit in itself and credit those that do.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y ago"If you think education is expensive, try ignorance". Not saying that people without higher degrees are ignorant, of course there are many ways to learn. But I think many people wouldn't find the motivation to learn without the social pressure to get a degree. So that pressure effectively achieves a society with less ignorance. In the US you should fix the problem of the crazy tuition fees that send people into bankrupcy, though. In countries like Germany, tuition is free, i.e., the whole society pays for your degree. I find this reasonable: as a member of society, it benefits me that e.g. we have competent doctors for when I get sick, and that they are the best possible (i.e., selected by knowledge and skill, and not by being rich enough to pay for a degree).
- notafxn 9y ago>I find this reasonable: as a member of society, it benefits me that e.g. we have competent doctors for when I get sick Problem with this is, in the list of degrees, useless degrees far outnumber useful degrees.
- chiefalchemist 9y ago> "But I think many people wouldn't find the motivation to learn without the social pressure to get a degree." On one hand, I agree. On the other, you hit the nail on the head. This is a socialization issue. As much of the USA gives a nod to individualism, the fact is we are taught to not take that too far. The status quo feeds the higher edu beast. But there are too many blindly chasing the promise, and only piling up tons of debt. The wrath of Higher Edu Industrial Complex continues. No questions asked. Yes. We can fix the tuition issue. But that also means saying "Sorry Charlie, you don't qualify." This latter bit, no one wants to discuss. In addition, the truth is, cost is a function of demand. Edu prices - like housing prices - were driven up by demand; demand that was increase with cheap loans and easy availability. Edu's charge more? Because. They. Can. But everyone gets to go. Some use the opportunity wisely. Some do not. But if the pay model changes so must the who gets to go where model. All that said, edu is not a gateway to success. And the edu model is broken. It's going to implode. When AI replaces the vast majority of jobs (including white collar) then there will be an excess of edu'ed people with too much free time on their hands (and too much debt with no viable way to pay). Perhaps higher edu isn't the only thing headed for a reckoning?
- meri_dian 9y ago"it's not sustainable" Unfortunately it is, in a grim sort of way, with grads' wages being siphoned off for decades to pay for debt and interest. Over a 15 year time scale even the largest educational debt loads are reducible, but they may be very uncomfortable to reduce for someone making, say, $60,000 a year.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]