4 ms·
> If you are the luckiest out of every five entrants, you may win the profession's ultimate prize: A comfortable middle-class job, for the rest of your life, wi
by tagrun 9y ago
> If you are the luckiest out of every five entrants, you may win the profession's ultimate prize: A comfortable middle-class job, for the rest of your life, with summers off.
That's pretty good actually. Your chances are far less than 10% in physics and that's for postdocs not students, and that's assuming you're from a top university with a good publication history in the top of the top journal(s).
Edit: For all the replies that focus on "summers off", I'm not saying you have summers off, that's a part of something I quoted. I'm well aware you don't get summers off from experience. Heck you can't take off time even after a baby unless you want to jeopardize your chances in tenure. If you read the portion that I wrote, you can see that my reply is about the job security (=tenure).
- tnecniv 9y agoAlso your summers aren't off, necessarily. If you're at a research institute, it's not like the group of PhD students and postdocs you manage vanishes.
- danieltillett 9y agoAs a former professor, I can tell you summers are the busiest work times as that is when you are trying to catch up on all the research activities you put off during the semester. It is actually nearly impossible to find time to actually take a vacation. I had more than 6 months banked when I quit. Edit. To add to your edit, tenure is far less secure that it appears from outside. It allows you to get away with being a moderate pain, but if you get too bad what they do is make your position redundant in the next departmental reshuffle. Since these occur about every 2 to 3 years tenure is more illusory than real. You not only have to worry about your position being made redundant, but your whole department. It is easier for admin to get rid of a few troublemakers by killing the whole department than just going after the troublemakers directly. A fair amount of my admin/politics time was spent defending the entire department rather than worrying about my own position directly.
- fwgwgwgch 9y agoInteresting do tell more please. How much of a professors life is showing that they are doing vs actually doing. What aspects are better and what worse? And which are popularly misunderstood (like summer vacation) ?
- danieltillett 9y agoProfessors have three full time jobs; administrator, researcher (well supervision of people actually doing the research, but this is very time consuming if done right), and teaching. Each job is more than 35 hours a week (the time I was nominally paid for). I was deliberately terrible at the administration side and outright refused to do anything unless it meant more money for my department (the one good thing about tenure is you can be a pain in the backside and not get fired), but even spending less than 10 hours a week on admin, my work week was rarely less than 80 to 90 hours. One of the major reasons why I quit academia and went back to my startup was to have more time to spend with my family.
- rocqua 9y ago> I quit academia and went back to my startup was to have more time to spend with my family. That alone seems like a rather damning indictment of academia.
- danieltillett 9y agoYep. I only work around 60 hours a week now.
- fwgwgwgch 9y agoCan you explain why you made a point to say "supervise students"? From your statement it looks like there is no expectation to do original/independent research. Is that the standard practise too?
- danieltillett 9y agoI didn't say supervise students so it was not a point I made?? I of course did supervise students. This does vary by field, but done right each student needs about 5 hours a week one-on-one direct enagagement (more at the beginning of their degree and less at the end). Less time than this and the student will struggle. You can of course do what some of the big empire builders do and just let the student sink or swim on their own, but this is not good for the student. Good supervision is very time consuming, but probably the most rewarding aspect of being an academic.
- tagrun 9y agoAs a current one, I can also tell you the same thing. Where did you get the idea that I am talking about summers being off?
- danieltillett 9y agoI know you were quoting the OP, I was just adding to your post that professors don't get the summer off based on my personal experience.