4 ms·
I can vouch for this phrase "worry about being stopped if they are driving a nice car in a modest or upscale community, a raggedy car in a mostly white one". I
by tyingq 9y ago
I can vouch for this phrase "worry about being stopped if they are driving a nice car in a modest or upscale community, a raggedy car in a mostly white one".
I live in an upper middle class neighborhood. But I drive a shitty old car, because I grew up poor, and have some fixed ideas about how much you should spend on a car.
I get pulled over at least 4 times a year. No tickets from it, ever. Had to perform and pass several sobreity tests. My wife, who drives a somewhat nicer car...never.
It so happens I'm white, but perhaps identified as "white trash" because of my old crappy cars.
All anecdotal, of course, but the cops do seem to target "car status / area status mismatch".
- nightski 9y agoMaybe. It's clear to you that you have found a correlation. Have you explored many other causes to see what their impact might be? When you are pulled over, what is commonly the reason/excuse the officers give? How do your driving habits compare to your wife? Do you drive at similar times of day? Are you both really cautious drivers? When I was a kid I was always told that it was the people in fancy sports cars that got pulled over all the time, so by driving a modest cheap car you were taking yourself off the radar. But that's the problem with anecdotal experience. It's hard to extrapolate trends without proper science and analysis. EDIT: I didn't mean to target this only at the parent. The article suffers a lot of the same issues. They base a large part of their argument over a single statistic (amount of people being pulled over vs. race) and then fail to dive any deeper into the data.
- tyingq 9y agoSure. I acknowledge it's anecdotal. The sobreity tests, though, when I'm stone cold sober, seemed odd. No reason for pulling me over is ever offered.
- mikeash 9y agoMaybe you should ask. Police aren’t allowed to stop people at random. They have to at least suspect some sort of violation.
- shanev 9y agoSometimes the violation is driving 5 miles above the speed limit on a highway.
- tyingq 9y agoFind some documented case where a US police officer was punished, in any way, for pulling someone over arbitrarily. There are too many loopholes. "Crossed center line", "erradic manuevers", "tint seemed dark", "appeared to see open alcohol container", "did not come to a full and complete stop", and so on. We even have full on Stasi style checkpoints occasionally, where everyone is pulled over.
- whatshisface 9y agoHot rods and beaters both get pulled over, expensive but slow-looking cars like Lexus minivans go under the radar. That's been the anecdote passed down to me, and it includes both of the cases we're discussing.
- Feniks 9y agoAs if criminals are stupid. A drug smuggler is more likely to drive a van than an Audi. Probably hire some white college kid to drive it.
- icantdrive55 9y ago1. It's time it stops. 2. In my county, hell it's Marin County; cops are nothing more than Revenue Collectors. It's all gotten so old. 3. I'm a white dude, but have seen first hand the harassement first hand. 4. I have lost all respect for the boys in blue. It's time clean up the profession, or at least make them keep those cameras on 24/7. 5. Oh yea, and by chance you are caught violating one of the cornucopia of laws out there; we need to tie that fee to rectify the incident to income. It's just not right that a rich boy casually tells the wifey, over dinner, that he owes the government $500 for some dubious rule violation. The poor boy gets a $500 ticket, and it could be the last straw. It's all just wrong. I have seen first hand, what my black friends have had to endure for years, and it's embarrassing! Sorry for going on, but this has been my hot button since I got my license--way too many years ago.
- Gibbon1 9y agoI owned a tan Ford Aerostar for ten years, never got pulled over once.
- symlinkk 9y agoWhat make / model / year of car? Just curious. > cops do seem to target "car status / area status mismatch" Can you blame them?
- iampims 9y agoYes, we can blame them.
- golergka 9y agoWhy? It's reasonable to assume there's a significant correlation between this mismatch and criminal activity.
- tptacek 9y agoNo, it's clearly not. By an overwhelming margin, most people driving "the wrong car" are not criminals; "wrong car" is not a real predictor for criminality.
- golergka 9y agoFirst part of your sentence, about most people, is obviously correct, but has no relation to the second part of your sentence about it not being a predictor for criminality.
- MikkoFinell 9y agoLow socioeconomic status is a predictor for criminality, as well as a predictor for car type owned. Thus car type is correlated with criminality.
- Pulcinella 9y agoHigh socioeconomic status is a predictor for white collar criminality, as well as a predictor for car type owned. Thus car type is correlated with criminality.
- cup-of-tea 9y agoI'm British and this sounds unbelievable. How "shitty" and "old" are we talking, though? I also didn't spend much on my car (2005 model, bought outright after saving for roughly two months) but it doesn't look anywhere near out of place on the road here.
- tyingq 9y ago90's era mid size cars for the most part.
- bri3d 9y agoWe don't have the MOT in the US so much stronger outliers are still found on the road.
- ExcelSaga 9y agoYou have the yearly state inspection though right? At least, last I lived there you did.
- tyingq 9y agoWe do, but outside of California, it's a cakewalk. Mostly checks for functional brake lights, turn signals, wipers, etc. And, again, outside of California, some minimal emissions tests you'll pass unless your car is seriously ailing.
- jack_h 9y agoNot exactly. This is highly dependent upon not only state but county as well. The type of vehicle and its age and even things like a vehicle with collectors plates can factor into emissions and testing requirements. As an example my sister lives in a county in Colorado that doesn't do emissions testing. I bought a car - 2001 Subaru Legacy - from her several years ago and had to pass emissions as I do live in a county that requires it. It failed spectacularly. The car was not 'seriously ailing' either. The forward O2 sensor needed to be replaced and then it passed just fine. Granted from what I hear California has pretty strict emissions requirements, but it's not necessarily a cake walk outside of California either, although sometimes it is. It's highly variable.
- eric_b 9y agoI work from home a lot. I don't like shaving. I enjoy comfortable clothes. I go to the gym on the days I work from home. I also have what has been described to me as the male version of "resting bitch face" - which I take to mean I look angry, even when I'm not. The net net of this is that I'm often running errands in public, during the middle of the day, with a scruffy beard, wearing sweatpants or other grubby clothes, scowling to some degree, and sometimes smelling of sweat and BO (if the store I'm going to is on the way home from the gym) I will get plenty of suspicious looks from store proprietors and other customers. Oftentimes cashiers are surprised when I address them pleasantly. Obviously they are judging me by my appearance. Most likely they've had other interactions with people who looked like me that did not go well. The thing is - I don't blame them. I know I look "suspicious" by the usual definitions. It's not really fair of course, but I believe this "pattern matching" behavior was probably part of our evolution. An ability to perform quick judgments based on past experience was probably useful historically. It still is in many cases not involving discriminatory practices. I guess my point is - cops are humans too. They should be held to higher standards, but if the people who commit crimes are often driving shabby cars, they are going to start putting those things together (fairly or not)
- confounded 9y ago> I guess my point is - cops are humans too. They should be held to higher standards, but if the people who commit crimes are often driving shabby cars, they are going to start putting those things together (fairly or not) Your argument is that there’s nothing that can be done about police racism, because of your theory of evolutionary psychology, based on your reluctance to shower after the gym?
- jackaroe78 9y agoA Grateful Dead sticker will significantly increase your odds of getting popped as well