2 ms·
Because it's not necessarily your process that ran out of RAM. Imagine you have background process A which has allocated 1 GB of RAM just in case and never used
by geofft 9y ago
Because it's not necessarily your process that ran out of RAM. Imagine you have background process A which has allocated 1 GB of RAM just in case and never used it, and then process B tries to allocate maybe 100 MB, and the kernel says "No, I can't do that." Then process B quits. Is this really a better outcome than killing process A?
On my current laptop, pulseaudio has 2.7 GB virtual memory and 17 MB physical memory. If I open a new Firefox tab, I would much prefer for pulseaudio to die than for Firefox to die.
(You might say, "Well, pulseaudio shouldn't allocate 2.7 GB virtual memory," to which I'd say, "Sure, if you'd rather spend the thousands of hours fixing pulseaudio and every other program like it, go for it.")
Also, "panic" isn't a standard C function - are you envisioning a panic that unwinds or one that doesn't? If it unwinds, what happens if you need to allocate memory during the unwind to save state? If it doesn't, why is it a better state of the world for Firefox to crash periodically and require me to recover my work, without even giving it the option to synchronize its state?
- floatboth 9y ago> pulseaudio has 2.7 GB virtual memory heh, anything compiled with GHC allocates a TERABYTE of virtual memory, good luck running that w/o overcommit