4 ms·
This is for soaking up renewable energy that either isn't connected to the grid yet, or is being generated at the wrong time. Since there's no fuel cost for win
by skybrian 9y ago
This is for soaking up renewable energy that either isn't connected to the grid yet, or is being generated at the wrong time. Since there's no fuel cost for wind or solar, you might as well do something with it. Anyone willing to buy electricity at inconvenient places or times will help make renewable energy generation more profitable, so more will be built.
There are lots of potential competitors, though: other kinds of energy storage (such as charging a battery), industrial users that can run in the off hours, or maybe generating Bitcoin. It's probably too soon to say whether this technology will win.
Buying electricity at a low price and selling it at a different time or place at a higher price is basically a form of arbitrage. Hopefully energy storage will become more efficient at getting electricity to customers when they need it, so they can outbid things like Bitcoin mining.
- eloff 9y agoThat makes sense, I was struggling to grasp how it could be economical.
- Gravityloss 9y agoDemand elasticity. We are still really far from reasonable deployment. Talking to a friend who worked for a power utility here, it's a very foreign concept. Some room for disruption there.
- Gravityloss 9y agoFor this you would need to store the CO2. For each ton of coal burned you generate about 3 tons of CO2. At atmospheric pressure thats 1500 cubic meters. A small 200 MW power plant could burn 80 tonnes per hour. Thats 120 000 cubic meters. That is a building 12 m high and 100 m square. I guess everything is possible given the right subsidies...
- ajnin 9y agoYou wouldn't store the CO2 gaseous at atmospheric pressure, you'd use the energy to compress it, presumably liquefying it. Liquid CO2 has a density of around 1100kg/m3, according to a quick Google search, so your example power plant would need only about 200m^3 to store the CO2 produced in one hour, or a cube of about 6m wide. Or 120m wide per year. Still seems like a lot, and I don't know how much energy is needed to compress and cool all that CO2 but it's dubious the surplus renewable energy would suffice to compress all the CO2 produced by fossile-burning power plants.
- Gravityloss 9y agoThat indeed seems like a better idea.
- tfha 9y agoBitcoin mining unfortunately is typically useless for sucking up spare electricity. The hardware is too expensive, unless it's running 85%+ uptime, you will not make back your initial hardware purchase. We can thank Moore's law for that. Bitcoin miners go obsolete every time a new generation of silicon hits maturity. 85% uptime requirement will drop substantially after Moore's law tapers off.
- nordsieck 9y ago> We can thank Moore's law for that. Except that Moore's law has tapered off substantially. The latest 10nm process node is 3 years late[0], and the next one will probably be substantially more difficult than that. [0] https://www.anandtech.com/show/12436/intel-10nm-dualcore-cannon-lake https://www.anandtech.com/show/12436/intel-10nm-dualcore-can...
- neltnerb 9y agoYeah, I had to write a proposal for a carbon capture project. It was really hard to make it make any sense from a systems perspective. I conclude that talking about using it to reduce emissions from fossil plants is idiocy only useful for PR. You are always better off not burning the carbon in the first place and just getting the electricity from another source. The only even remotely compelling case is that it lets the plant respond faster to load by dumping excess electricity into chemicals. And even there, it's not the best solution, it's probably better handled by the way we do it now with load-following plants. I think the researchers know that, they talked about using renewable power for it. But I'm sure their estimates are also based on consuming coal flue gas because they have to goose the numbers to make the CO2 cheap and concentrated enough to make any sense. So my assumption with basically any of these is that they're setting up a paradoxical situation -- assume that we're using fossil power plants for the CO2, but getting the electricity/hydrogen from renewables. That way the chemicals look close to free. But if we're still generating electricity with the fossil plant, it will always be better to just not use the plant from a CO2 and systems efficiency perspective and to instead build more renewable generation to make up the difference.