8 ms·
Internet access is quietly changing Seattle’s tent cities
- wallace_f 9y ago>The library has set aside 50 hotspots just for Seattle’s homeless camps, funded in part by $305,000 from Google This must be a mistake, somehow. That comes out to $6,100 per hot spot, which was still apparently not enough, alone, to fund them.
- swampthinker 9y agoProbably isn't just for the hardware.
- cyberpunk0 9y agoThem Verizon data charges!
- lsc 9y agofor how long? yeah, that'd probably cover setup... but remember that the wifi hotspots need internet access themselves, and usually you can't just hook them up to your comcast home connection. On top of that, you've got ongoing maintenance, abuse, etc... dealing with that bullshit costs money, and even more if you allow anonymous connections.
- wallace_f 9y agoThis here is probably one of the problems with helping the poor. When people are spending other people's money to help other people, they don't spend it very well. As for the cost... For the record, I've lived over a year around the poverty line... In Australia--An even more expensive country. I also did a loop around the country, saw and went everywhere I wanted to go, spent most of my time at the beach or mountains, and surfing... and oh yea, had internet the entire time. Even amortizing that cost over ten years, this is still double what I spent on wifi.
- robotrout 9y agoYou got down-voted because you dared to say that tax money gets wasted by bureaucrats. HN people worship government wealth redistribution programs and will never admit that they are often corrupt and wasteful.
- wallace_f 9y agoI see. I know my comments are often intended to strike debate, rather than state something I already know all will agree with. But maybe I should have been more clear that I am against waste and for better effective improvements in human welfare and dignity. I'm not againdt redistribution, just the way it is done.
- cma 9y agoWhen you look at it from a marginal utility standpoint, it would have to be thousands of times more wasteful for it to be as wasteful as not redistributing it from the top.
- the_cat_kittles 9y agohi, its me a guy who thinks that public programs are often wasteful and corrupt who also thinks that in many cases they are still probably a better idea than privitization
- p49k 9y agoHe got downvoted because he has no understanding of how expensive it is to build a network of public wi-fi hotspots, and compared it to sticking his router beside his window and sharing his home broadband connection. Literally everything about public wifi, from the wiring and build costs, to the hardware and antennas, to the bandwidth itself is significantly more expensive. $6,100 per point sounds completely reasonable.
- pnutjam 9y agoThe simple fact is you could do it cheaper, but you either pay for expertise or hardware. If you don't have a skilled network guy volunteering time, it's going to cost, even if you do, it's going to cost only a bit less.
- BariumBlue 9y agoYou misread the article >But money proposed for Wi-Fi was spent on more pressing needs... >In 2016, Seattle Public Library stepped in. ... funded in part by $305,000 from Google. So the govt proposal for WiFi was underfunded, then the Public Library stepped in with different funds partially from Google.
- dennisdamenace 9y agoThere was a post on HN some time ago by a homeless woman. One thing she said would a lot is wireless access. She said a great deal of time and energy would be spent moving from the camp to internet availability. Source http://whathelpsthehomeless.blogspot.com/2017/09/a-virtual-life.html?m=1 http://whathelpsthehomeless.blogspot.com/2017/09/a-virtual-l...
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThe article doesn't say as much as I wish it did about actual impact on the day to day lives of homeless people. For me, internet access while homeless was a means to keep myself occupied so I wouldn't go crazy, a means to have social contact and meaningful discussion even though I wasn't very presentable, a means to do research to problem solve, access to online banking and other financial stuff, access to reward programs that helped keep me fed and so much more. Having a virtual life made a huge difference in my quality of life while homeless and eventually helped me get back into housing, in part by leading to earned income, in part by allowing me to find a place I could afford. This was vastly different from the homeless people I saw sitting at the park all day doing nothing while their social skills, self esteem and self image deteriorated and their only means to make money seemed to be recycling and pan handling. With internet access, a cell phone and mailing address, being homeless is much less of a hardship than if you have none of those. You aren't simply cut off from society, news, information and the power to make plans and build a future. I don't know how to express how incredibly empowering the internet can be for a homeless person. I always thought of it as if it were a kind of magic. It helped me feel like a whole person. It kept hope alive by keeping options open in a way that simply wasn't previously possible. Today, a homeless person can go online and look for information and communities for van dwellers, digital nomads, remote work and other things of that ilk that open up the opportunity to see yourself as simply living an alternative lifestyle rather than being straight up a social outcast. That makes taking adequate care of yourself so much more feasible and makes a path back to a more conventional life vastly more navigable, even if you don't qualify for any programs, many of which are aimed at specific populations, like addicts or single parents.
- blitmap 9y agoThis is a very illuminating post that I will remember when speaking about net neutrality, modern rights I think we should have (internet access), and how someone may find their way out of homelessness (if they desire). Thank you for this.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoPop into r/homeless some time. For the price of a reddit handle and the time it took to post a question, I have seen several people avoid or delay eviction, find solutions that kept them off the street after they announced "I shall be homeless in X period of time" or announce they finally got themselves off the street through their own efforts. I occasionally think it has to be one of the cheapest and most effective homeless services on the planet. And it's just a free discussion forum. I see these results in spite of it attracting trolls, judgey middle class assholes who are there to lecture homeless people, and people who clearly have serious issues and can't manage to behave in a pro-social fashion. Amidst all the muck, lives are quietly being kept from suddenly unraveling and other lives are being slowly knit back together. That's the power of the internet. It fosters lightweight solutions that couldn't happen any other way, including crowd sourcing wisdom and practical advice. I love it.
- robotrout 9y agoI would love to see some sort of city-wide wifi, that would allow people to buy small amounts of data with bitcoin. You would connect to the access point, send bitcoin/altcoin to the address generated, and get access to the internet until you had transferred the amount of data you had purchased. Non-homeless people would use such a service as well, but it would be especially valuable to homeless, who could be given bitcoin/altcoin or perhaps obtain it from crypto ATMs. Not having a physical address is a huge impediment to functioning in our society. Without a physical address, you can't have a credit card or a bank account. Without a credit card, you can't have a cell phone for internet access, or a gym membership to take a shower. But shower facilities or gyms that allowed you to buy one month at a time with crypto, coupled with internet access that could be purchased with crypto, would allow people to function pretty normally in this society without a physical address. Neither of these would need to be specifically for homeless, nor would they need to be tax payer funded.
- DoreenMichele 9y agowould not need to be an impediment to making a living It is still an impediment, but it is not a showstopper. If you start making enough money, you stop identifying as homeless. You either get back into housing or you start identifying as a digital nomad, which is simply a lifestyle choice. Even digital nomads talk about how that lifestyle can make it difficult to sit down and concentrate on your work. Being technically able to work from anywhere doesn't change the fact that lack of a dedicated work space (and routine, etc) tends to hamper productivity. Some digital nomads settle in someplace for a few weeks or months at a time in order to carve out blocks of productive time. Unlike well heeled digital nomads who can spend fair sums at cafes, homeless people tend to not be welcome to hang out on their laptop or tablet for hours at a time. They aren't presentable enough and they aren't spending enough money. They tend to get thrown out and told to not come back if they try to hang too long at a commercial establishment.
- newnewpdro 9y agoPre-pay smartphones don't require a credit card, and have all the trappings of a normal smartphone's contract service. Urban areas should just give wifi internet access away though, it's not terribly costly. Even the tiny town of Pescadero, CA has free high-speed wifi internet provided by San Mateo county.
- question_that 9y agoHow large is a single camp that they'd need 11 APs? Couldn't you just have a few on poles? Why do 50 hotspots cost 300k? Are they rugged units bundled with GPS units and solar panels?
- crowbahr 9y agoSeattle is #3 in homelessness in the USA and has more homeless per capita than one of the other two (LA I think?). The tent cities get large and only get broken up when deaths of women and children start occurring. See The Jungle: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jungle_(Seattle) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jungle_(Seattle)
- devmunchies 9y agoIt’s hardly quiet if it’s in the Seattle times and on the front page of HN.
- ObeyTheGuts 9y agoim internet connected homeless rightnow, youtube.com/angriestcat
- Feniks 9y agoTent city? Lol. Reminds me of the 90s when refugees from the Balkan wars were housed in party tents because there was a shortage of housing. It was a national scandal that shamed the nation in the international newscasts.
- ocschwar 9y agoThe comments on the article are a fucking cancer. THere are so many people out there who have nothing better to do with their time than to actively call for making life worse for people worse off than themselves.