3 ms·
This is not a technological solution. It's an attempt to create a legal convention of applying a particular form of centralized blacklisting. The power of this
by CryptoPunk 9y ago
This is not a technological solution. It's an attempt to create a legal convention of applying a particular form of centralized blacklisting.
The power of this method is directly proportional to how widely it's adopted.
And the reference to a precedent gives a false sense of legal legitimacy to this form of blacklisting. The decision referenced dealt with creditor claims to a shared asset.
The relevant legal precedent is from 1749. That's when a court sided with the Royal Bank of Scotland in its legal challenge to a request for a blacklist for notes used in crime. The RBS argument was that making money responsible for the acts of its previous holders would "render the Notes absolutely useless":
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2260952 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2260952
For hundreds of years, that has been the legal treatment of cash, which has facilitated commerce, by making cash fungible.
Jurisdictions around the world have been steadily degrading the principle of fungibility over the last 40 years to institute a mass surveillance system to stop the drug trade, money laundering and income tax evasion (it's worth noting the income tax didn't exist in 1749).
The result is concentrated power structures accumulating ever greater bureaucratic control over the traditional financial system.
- cinquemb 9y agoWell it seems like even the actors who influence the G20 finance minister talking heads[0] cant even agree on what to do, except for asserting that somehow they will need to be in charge. I think that concentrated power structures (that exist today or evolve in time) that can exploit this environment will win in the long run, but it won't necessarily be in any particular nation states interest. [0] https://www.euromoney.com/article/b17jt5vnb3fn3m/g20-ministers-wrestle-with-cryptocurrency-oversight https://www.euromoney.com/article/b17jt5vnb3fn3m/g20-ministe...
- CryptoPunk 9y agoAny centralization of a sector of an economy needs to be politically coordinated so the fact that the G20 heads don't agree on a plan is promising. I think it's possible some of finance ministers of the G20 members like the disruptive potential of cryptocurrency.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoLegally speaking, bitcoin is a commodity, not a currency.
- cinquemb 9y agoIn which jurisdiction? The US? Japan? Singapore?