2 ms·
Let's redo this. I can happily imagine that every child in the USA gets to find out if they are any good at hitting a baseball (#). So we can be fairly sure t
by lifeisstillgood 9y ago
Let's redo this. I can happily imagine that every child in the USA gets to find out if they are any good at hitting a baseball (#). So we can be fairly sure that the population of possible baseball picks is as wide as it can be - and is a proper bell curve.
But the population of those who have had chance to skate on ice and hit a puck is, even in canada, is not as wide as possible- so it won't be a bell curve - maybe double hump?
this gives us in my head a situation where even the top players in NHL are not the best possible from the whole country - but the baseball players are closer to that ideal because they draw from a more complete bell curve.
as such i speculate that NHL top players are not as good as possible because
- the top players are not the best possible from population compared to say sprinting
- the set of all players is more closely grouped (thinner curve) so any player is closer in ability to top players than say sprinting
- most sports probably still have plenty of "moneyball" left on the table
All of which is a long winded way of saying, if there is a sport where a non-professional can come in and perform distinguishedly, then there should be plenty of scope for investment and improvement and so consequent profit (wins at any rate)
(#) every male child at least, but let's not go down that road now.
- rsync 9y ago"I can happily imagine that every child in the USA gets to find out if they are any good at hitting a baseball (#). So we can be fairly sure that the population of possible baseball picks is as wide as it can be - and is a proper bell curve." That's a very good point - thanks. I suppose the same point could be made, even more emphatically, for skiing. "most sports probably still have plenty of "moneyball" left on the table" Actually, I reject the Moneyball principle and its prescriptions, but that's another story ...
- kgilpin 9y agoHockey is more popular in Canada than baseball is in the USA!