3 ms·
They claim they reserve the right to view everyone's Skype calls to determine whether any violations occur, which is a huge privacy violation. This bill impact
by userbinator 9y ago
They claim they reserve the right to view everyone's Skype calls to determine whether any violations occur, which is a huge privacy violation.
This bill impacts everyone and will completely change how humans are "allowed" to interact with each other.
If you look at the available technology, it's perfectly possible to set up your own end-to-end encrypted communication channels, peer-to-peer style. SIP and other standardised protocols allow realtime video and audio communication between any two hosts on the Internet without involving a centralised service.
The problem seems to be that the majority of humans are fundamentally afraid of learning about and setting up such systems themselves, so they naturally gravitate toward "easy" centralised proprietary systems like Skype --- and companies are all too eager to advertise the simplicity of their solutions to further drive users toward them.
As someone who's communicated with friends using "a pair of netcats", and later SIP videocalls, I disagree that it's all that hard to set such things up; certainly there's a learning curve, but when the alternative to learning something slightly more difficult yet you fully control is something simple on the surface but controlled by the whims of governments and corporations, the choice is clear to me. "If you want things done right you have to do it yourself."
Yet because the bill is explicitly designed to target sex workers, none of the people who would otherwise be up in arms are saying anything. The hatred of sex workers will destroy us all unless we all stand up and fight.
To reappropriate an old saying, "First they came for the prostitutes, and I did not speak out because I was not a prostitute..."
- anigbrowl 9y agoThe problem seems to be that the majority of humans are fundamentally afraid of learning about and setting up such systems themselves You're right about individuals in general who want to set up secure communications, but I think you're overlooking the contexts in which they want to do so. Most people rationally choose to buy phones rather than building their own too. I can set that sort of stuff up, and I have, but you know what? It's a pain in the ass keeping up with technological obsolescence year after year, and it's not all that easy to just pick up this stuff from scratch. Like people in any other line of work, sex workers would rather focus on being good at their core business of providing fantasy entertainment than invest too much time in developing secondary technical skills. This is especially important given that most of them are self-employed. The other issue to bear in mind here is that they have to connect with customers somehow, and advertising is a real problem. They still need some way to reach potential clients and an easy way for clients to connect with and pay for whatever services it is they desire.
- userbinator 9y agoLike people in any other line of work, sex workers would rather focus on being good at their core business of providing fantasy entertainment than invest too much time in developing secondary technical skills. By that same argument sex workers should also not be too concerned about learning how to drive, cook, or whatever else they need to do in their lives... the extremes of desire to specialise is what leads to centralisation. When I was still in school, we learned about how to write (physical) letters and use addresses, phone numbers, and other such things that would be considered general knowledge today. Perhaps that should now include IPs and hostnames. It's a pain in the ass keeping up with technological obsolescence year after year, and it's not all that easy to just pick up this stuff from scratch. This "technological obolescence" is partly because currently the power to force such change is held by a tiny fraction of the population, and everyone else is clueless so can't do anything but follow along. If the balance of power changes, that will as well.
- romwell 9y ago>The problem seems to be that the majority of humans are fundamentally afraid of learning about and setting up such systems themselves, so they naturally gravitate toward "easy" centralised proprietary systems like Skype I just wanted to correct that when most Skype users gravitated towards it, Skype was mostly a decentralized P2P system. Microsoft silently turned it around.