5 ms·
I don't know how to say this well, and I often get a lot of flak on HN for trying to say it at all. People don't like having their normal sex life compared to p
by DoreenMichele 9y ago
I don't know how to say this well, and I often get a lot of flak on HN for trying to say it at all. People don't like having their normal sex life compared to prostitution in any way, shape or form. But the fact that I get so much flak suggests it hits a nerve.
There is no clear demarcation between sex work and non commercial sex. Dating frequently involves a man spending money on a woman in hopes of getting laid. Sexual relationships almost never occur in isolation from material aspects of our lives.
As one example, heterosexual sex can lead to babies. So we routinely try to parse "Can this guy support a child if the union results in one?"
That's a moral question where creating a child and being unable to provide for it is irresponsible. So there is no means whatsoever to completely separate money and sexual morality. The relationship between the two is complicated, but it doesn't work to try to pretend you can simply and conveniently separate sex and material stuff.
The fact that there is no clear cut demarcation point between non commercial sex and commercial sex is why Craigslist pulled all its personal sections in reaction to this. So, logically, this potentially endangers all dating sites and hookup apps.
One possible path of progression: With no spaces left devoted to the needs of sex workers, dating sites and hookup apps could become a means of solicitation and then all activities on such sites would become suspect and no one could even ask who is paying for coffee when they meet.
I am not very familiar with this legislation, but "throwing the baby out with the bathwater" doesn't begin to capture the kinds of negative consequences we are already seeing in reaction to this. This is apparently so deeply anti sex that it isn't remotely limited to being anti commercial sex.
I find myself baffled at the capacity of the human race to superficially pretend we are doing something good and moral while just being sexually hung up and apparently wanting to hatefully punish people for having any sexual impetus at all.
This is my second attempt to try to express some of this. I would appreciate it if folks don't scream at me about how sex in their marriage is not an act of prostitution. It's a pointless derail of the conversation that just makes me feel "Me thinks thou doth protest too much." It would be nice if people would stick to the topic of consequences of these laws instead of acting like I have said "You, yes you, are just buying sex from your wife and she clearly does not love you." I said no such thing.
- arthur_pryor 9y agoI have nothing of substance to add to this comment, but I agree with absolutely everything you've said, and I hope you don't get downvoted. I can't really add any nuance, because I don't know where in the weeds we might disagree. I realize that my comment isn't very substantive, and I'm pretty low-karma, but I think you're generally a thoughtful commenter from what I've seen, and I think more people need to read what you've said and mull it over and at least do the thought exercise of seeing how they might agree with you, even if they determine that they ultimately do not agree with you. Please, let's legalize and regulate prostitution.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoThank you. For the record, I an not for legalization and regulation. I think if I want to service a guy for a few bucks, the only thing the government should concern itself with is me reporting that as earned income on my taxes. Here is a recent comment by me trying to clarify my understanding of the difference between legalization and decriminalization, which is something poorly understood and is a topic with lots of contradictory information: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16673076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16673076
- arthur_pryor 9y agooh interesting, esp in light of your other comment's statement that regulated legalization hasn't made things better for sex workers in vegas. i think i need to run some errands and do some work instead of scouting bandcamp and reading HN, but i hope to read your time link and mull that stuff over later this afternoon/evening. thanks for the opinion/info, even if i don't have a reply while anyone's still reading this thread (though i'll try to reply regardless if i think i have something worthwhile to say, if only to get it out for myself). i would say that even if i stay thinking that regulation is the right thing in principle, i'd hope that it'd not be so draconian as to impinge on small independent operators (a la the blind eye turned to homebrewing and your average poker game). without further reading/consideration, i'd still think that a business composed of multiple people involved in prostitution, or a business space specifically devoted to it, might be things subject to regulation? or maybe not even that, i dunno. i'm a big believer in civil liberties and personal freedom, but i'm also not much for libertarianism (because it doesn't seem like it always does a good job of maximizing freedom for most people when you take into account how people behave in groups).