6 ms·
This article resonated with me. Once, I had a leader that would question parts of my org, or budgeted projects, why they were needed, etc. Her real question w
by tyingq 9y ago
This article resonated with me. Once, I had a leader that would question parts of my org, or budgeted projects, why they were needed, etc. Her real question was "I need to cut X dollars out of the budget". I could have immediately helped that goal if she asked that exact question. Instead, though, she was going about it in an oblique way, trying to figure out where I was being incompetent.
Pretty embarrassed about our current state of leadership skills. In my current organization, we call this syndrome "bring me a rock". Like, I bring a rock, and she says "it's too big, or too brown, or whatever". Instead of outright saying, "I need a medium, smooth, grey, rock". I can deliver if you're explicit.
- lostlogin 9y agoWhat would have happened if you had said, “I think you’re trying to find some money in the budget, would you like some help?”?
- tyingq 9y agoThat's eventually how it worked out, but time and money were wasted in the process. Lots of man hours invested into justifying existing costs/orgs/projects. When I could have offered up lower lying fruit if exact cost was identified as the driver up front. The questions weren't easy to translate into actual intent at first. Leadership styles profoundly affect efficiency.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoIt's also tough to be that honest at some organizations. Like if your manager said, I'm trying to reduce our costs by 10% so that I can get a big incentive bonus personally...
- moate 9y agoDon't really see why motive matters in that case. The idea of misstating the problem doesn't exist (the bonus and the cost reductions are intrinsically tied to one another) and the additional clarity doesn't guarantee the desired behavior. It's possible a subordinate might not help you if they don't feel your personal gain is beneficial to them. If a manager says "I need to reduce costs by 10%", the specific desired business outcome is clear. Reminding your subordinates that your pay and continued employment is tied to you completely the tasks and requests of the people you answer to doesn't seem needed. This isn't about "some organizations", it's just about efficiency.
- throw2016 9y agoOrganizations always want to reduce costs, there is always pressure to be efficient and reduce costs. Usually the current costs are the cost of business, and if there is an externality ie economic downturn, some crisis, big lost deals, then there may be renewed pressure at which point this has already been communicated by the leadership to the org and everyone is on the same page. Trying to reduce costs out of the blue is not usual, it suggests some individual thinks there is some inefficiency after studying the issue, or its a management consultant recently hired to explore that, but usually the people being requested for information would be briefed and know exactly the reason and why.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoI don't know your specific situation however speaking broadly about this kind of line of questioning, a different perspective here is that she may have wanted to be able to evaluate the value of these different programs on her own, rather than be told what needs to happen. In many cases middle managers think they know what needs to be cut or what programs are a waste without all of the facts of the organization. I saw this a lot in government. For example some organization was on the books for the primary reason of being the focal point for a contract vehicle but was in a holding period waiting protest or something and not doing much for a year or two - so it looked ripe to cut - when in fact it was more of a "lady in waiting" for the broader organization.
- tyingq 9y agoYes, but I'd classify that as micro-management. If you don't trust me at that level of detail, then why am I here?
- Bartweiss 9y agoDepending on the company, it can also be a symptom of excess management layers. If your grand-manager tells your manager "ok, today your job is to cut $X from this team's budget", then she'd better do that. She might know full well you have the time and capacity to do it yourself, but if she passed it down the chain someone might notice she wasn't doing anything. Which, obviously, is equally dysfunctional. But it can explain why someone who isn't generally a micro-manager is churning up extra work.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoAgain, in your specific situation it may have been. My point is that, the purpose behind getting into the weeds to such a degree as a manager isn't as obvious as it may seem - especially as a new manager who is trying to understand the organization.
- dvt 9y ago> Pretty embarrassed about our current state of leadership skills. In my current organization, we call this syndrome "bring me a rock". Like, I bring a rock, and she says "it's too big, or too brown, or whatever". Instead of outright saying, "I need a medium, smooth, grey, rock". I can deliver if you're explicit. This sounds like an example of the AZ problem[1]. [1] http://azproblem.info/ http://azproblem.info/
- beaconstudios 9y agohave you made more sites like this beyond the AZ and XY problems? I'd love to be able to cite these when trying to talk about these topics with people.
- dvt 9y agoThe XY problem is kind of famous and I actually didn't make that website (although I find myself citing it all the time). I kind of "invented" the AZ problem because I ran into it multiple times at my previous job and thought about formalizing it in some way. Hope you find the website helpful! :)
- beaconstudios 9y agoInteresting, I'd never heard of it before - but it puts a name on something I think we've all experienced many times. The AZ problem is a useful generalisation too, it digs towards the root cause. Do you know if it belongs to a category of problems, in the same manner that e.g. the "either-or" belongs to the category of logical fallacies and confirmation bias belongs to cognitive biases? I always find those types of categories useful in building mental models.
- dvt 9y ago> Do you know if it belongs to a category of problems You kind of put me on the spot here, I'm not sure. I'd have to think about it for a while, but my gut feeling is that, yeah, it probably falls in the overarching category of "not knowing/realizing that you don't know something" -- so the failure point is epistemic.
- digi_owl 9y ago> Pretty embarrassed about our current state of leadership skills. In my current organization, we call this syndrome "bring me a rock". Like, I bring a rock, and she says "it's too big, or too brown, or whatever". Instead of outright saying, "I need a medium, smooth, grey, rock". I can deliver if you're explicit. Makes me think of stores about Steve Jobs, and how there would be a virtually endless runaround of him claiming not enough this, too much that.
- ryanmarsh 9y agoLeadership quality feels like it has declined as I’ve gotten older. When I began my career Stephen Covey was all the rage. Traditional leadership training was a necessity for middle managers moving up the ranks. Then something changed. Having a softer touch became more important than results. This weird sort of litigation-phobic (pardon my inarticulate explanation) approach to all things took hold. Managers stopped giving clear feedback. They stopped assigning work, merely suggesting it. It’s completely bizarre. Especially when you’ve been in the military and seen real decentralized and self organizing leadership work. These days as a consultant I go in and basically fill a leadership vacuum at each of my clients. I tell them this too. They shrug and keep shuffling and saying things that mean nothing. So weird. I don’t understand the corporate world.
- 3pt14159 9y agoI think it has more to do with the average amount of time spent at an organization. I consult for the Canadian government from time to time and I see plenty of great managers there. The main difference? Most people there for more than 2 or 3 years are there for life. They get to see the results of prolonged good leadership and they get to learn from leaders that they trust. With tech you have random 27 year olds as C-levels at eight or nine digit valued companies (that was me some years back) and there's no way that you have the skill or experience or even respect for the position to do it well.
- tyingq 9y agoDon't know why your comment is being downvoted. False politeness is a real issue in many organizations. You're frustrated with me, but afraid to say why. That situation won't resolve itself.
- arwhatever 9y agoI call that playing the "Wrong, Guess Again!" Game.
- scoggs 9y agoOr the "You need to read my mind to win" Game. I feel like that crops up a lot in romantic relationships a lot too...
- dikkechill 9y agoIf you're interested in how that works, I can recommend psychologist Marshall Rosenberg (a student of Carl Rogers): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkQlAL8mVPs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkQlAL8mVPs Another student of Carl Rogers was Joseph Weizenbaum, the creator of ELIZA.
- ramses0 9y ago"Go Fish"