6 ms·
I don't know about Facebook in particular, but what you're missing is that the reason employees can debate internally about policy is that they trust it won't l
by skybrian 9y ago
I don't know about Facebook in particular, but what you're missing is that the reason employees can debate internally about policy is that they trust it won't leak externally. The risk of leaks eventually results in companies clamping down on security, so most employees aren't told anything that's not already public, unless they need it for their job. (Much like Apple has been all along, where employees only know what they need to know.)
So I would ask you where you'd rather work? At an employer that trusts you not to leak stuff, or somewhere that doesn't trust you? If it's the latter, you might as well be a contractor.
You'll find this is true in most organizations, not just companies. They want to know if they can trust you with their secrets. It does require some faith that internal debate will help the organization make good decisions most of the time, which admittedly can be a stretch sometimes.
- marricks 9y agoHow about a company where decisions are shared internally and employees feel empowered enough to speak up, *externally if needed, against what they see as an injustice when internally nothing is done? That shouldn't be too much to ask for. Perhaps some tech unions are needed to enforce this, as shareholders and owners would probably rather have just the dichotomy you presented. This just reveals how big the power imbalance is between employees and executives that we’d have to make such decisions.
- skybrian 9y agoWhen you say speak up, do you mean internally or externally?
- marricks 9y agoI thought it’d be clear but I added clarification. Speaking up internally when you’re not on the board often doesn’t get much done. At least if it’s a moral objection.
- skybrian 9y agoIf you want to get something done, you need to think about who gets to make the decisions and how to influence them. Depending what it is, speaking up externally might not get you more pull with internal decision-makers? Particularly if they feel betrayed. Or, maybe a big external stink could cause action? Depends what it is. It's quite possible that neither would work, and then you've burned your bridges for nothing.
- dpwm 9y agoI think you're missing the greater context here. Bosworth's memo is classic end justifies the means. This is almost an admission that they knew things they were doing would be deeply unpopular. The post in full doesn't read at all like it was to stimulate discussion. It reads more like it was to silence dissent. If you really wanted to stimulate discussion and gather employee views on this stuff, you'd send a survey round. But the relationship is still asymmetrical between boss and employee. All you're doing when posting something like this semi-publicly is creating an environment where more quiet conscientious views get shouted down by the loudest voices.
- ribosometronome 9y ago>It reads more like it was to silence dissent. Which makes his response read all that more hollow. Calling it a straw man? The post seems to have been an all out justification for immoral behavior by an executive. I can't imagine a Jr. Engineer or someone fresh out of college with their MA in Stats feeling super comfortable hopping in and going, "Hey this sound unethical and if people saw you saying it they would think we're hella fucked up." I'm relatively low-ranking at another big SV company and the thought of needing to stand up to a high ranking employee like that is more than a little intimidating.
- dpwm 9y ago> the thought of needing to stand up to a high ranking employee like that is more than a little intimidating. And not just that, but to be expected to "contribute to a discussion" in such a way that all your coworkers can see. I think as somebody who takes objection to that memo I'd probably be more inclined look for alternative work.
- jyrkesh 9y agoSame. I'm not even THAT low-ranking, and it's still a big deal when I push back against a VP or director on something that's in my area. For some topic where I didn't even feel like an expert, against such language, and with morals concerned? I think I'd just silently start looking for a new job.
- specialist 9y agoI prefer the distrustful organization. I would never be tempted to suspend disbelief that this one time my opinion, effort, goodwill actually mattered. I've fallen for the "trust us" scam too many times. Embarrassing. Ever more, the only thing I trust is mutual distrust.
- barrkel 9y agoThat's a false dichotomy. It's better to work somewhere where transparency isn't a problem.
- jacquesm 9y agoExactly.
- princekolt 9y agoEmployees would probably feel more comfortable about debating opinions regardless of company trust if their opinions didn't involve Orwellian kinds of user manipulation and "questionable practices".
- jacquesm 9y ago> At an employer that trusts you not to leak stuff, or somewhere that doesn't trust you? That's a false dichotomy. I'd like to work for an employer that would not mind me discussing my work related stuff outside without immediately classifying that as a leak, and I'd like my employer to trust my judgment in knowing what is and what is not appropriate in such discussions.
- underwater 9y agoDiscussing stuff outside work is different from leaking internal communications verbatim. I left Facebook for a place where the stakes are a lot lower, but information leaks like a sieve. It’s really disheartening to know that a lot of new coworkers would prefer to leak their “spin” to the press and actively try to damage the company when they don’t get their way.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt all depends on what the public interest angle is. In the case of Facebook the hypocrisy on display borders on the unbelievable. Facebook arguably infringes in the worst way possible on the privacy of a very large chunk of humanity but is highly offended when its own 'private' communications are exposed. If it's good for the goose it is good for the gander and companies with this much influence on the world should welcome transparency, not oppose it. And if they do not welcome transparency then we'll have to help them along a bit every now and then.
- underwater 9y agoFacebook doesn’t maliciously expose private user data in order to inflict harm on people.
- jacquesm 9y agoNo, they do it to make money. But that's all the same to me.
- danso 9y agoUnfettered leak-free debate, or, heavy secrecy? Seems like an easy choice, especially on paper, just like unlimited vacation vs. 3 weeks paid — the devil is in the implementation and unforeseen consequences. I think the reality with FB is that the current idealized system is not necessarily the best, and likewise, the occurrence of leaks is not necessarily a sign of impending doom. Sometimes leaks are a necessary symptom for when an organization has gone off the rails and has failed to self-correct. I don’t think any organization enjoys or wants leaks — just as no human enjoys sneezing or diarrhea — but sometimes the temporary discomfort is necessary for long-term health.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- slavik81 9y agoI've never worked for a company that gave employees a forum to talk openly. Company policy was always set by upper management behind closed doors and broadcasted down to everyone else. Discussions and disagreements were handled privately. I like the idea of employees having open discussions about company policy and direction, but I would never would have believed such a thing could exist at enormous companies like Facebook and Google. Though, given headlines recently, I'm not sure it will survive much longer.
- Spooky23 9y agoThis sort of post isn’t a debate. It’s a pep rally. Personally, I’d rather be in the dark about policy than be schnookered into thinking that I have some meaningful input.
- rdiddly 9y agoSo you could say, they value their privacy and don't want their comments shared with people they didn't authorize? It's ironic to see employees complaining about what is essentially a lack of privacy, when the company they work for goes out of its way to convince everybody that privacy is a thing of the past, and in so many words, so does the very Bosworth post they would protect and keep private. Eat your own dog food. And then one of them says that whoever leaked the post (the whistleblower, is how I would refer to them) lacks integrity. Integrity? You work for Facebook. Has it never occurred to you that maybe you're the baddies?
- greenyoda 9y agoThe word "integrity" may have a different meaning inside a tightly-knit corporate culture[1] than on the outside, just like "honor" means something different inside the Mafia, where it means "you can steal and murder, but above all, keep your mouth shut". A corporate code of silence that insists on the absolute privacy of internal communications is similar to the Mafia's code of silence, in which it's considered bad form (punishable by death) to blab to the authorities: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omert%C3%A0 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omert%C3%A0 "Omertà is a code of honor that places importance on silence, non-cooperation with authorities, and non-interference in the illegal actions of others." It will be interesting to see what kind of documents this and other whistleblowers will decide to leak in the future. Facebook needs its own Snowden to expose its inner workings. [1] I suspect that the corporate obsession with secrecy we're seeing here is not unique to Facebook. What's unique is the irony of a privacy-destroying company insisting on its own right to privacy.
- baud147258 9y ago> At an employer that trusts you not to leak stuff, or somewhere that doesn't trust you? If it's the latter, you might as well be a contractor. I'm a contractor, in the same team of FTE devs for a year, it's going really well, but I was a little hurt when I realised they were reading CVs to fill a vacancy in the team without putting me in the loop. Edit: I understand why they are doing it, I mean I'm from a big consulting company (Alten), but still it stung a little, especially since I'm on pretty good term with the rest of the team.
- solatic 9y ago> So I would ask you where you'd rather work? At an employer that trusts you not to leak stuff, or somewhere that doesn't trust you? If it's the latter, you might as well be a contractor. Employers which still use trust at scale are ignoring their risk analysts. The risk of a secret leaking is proportional to the number of people who know the secret. You can reduce the risk with Stasi-style surveillance, or legal enforcement (e.g. legally classified state secrets), but few people wish to work under those conditions. It's a false dichotomy because people would rather work for an employer that trusts them with the secrets they need to get their job done, and doesn't trust them with the secrets they don't need, a.k.a. the principle of least access. Openness in organizations is important insofar as people can attain access to information they need when they need it, but not unlimited access to everything, which ultimately reduces organizational trust when leaks inevitably occur.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hw 9y agoOh the irony. People trusted Facebook to keep their data secure and it 'leaked' to C.A. It seems apt that internal debates and posts would leak to the outside world.