6 ms·
What the FOSTA/SESTA anti-sex trafficking bill means for sex workers
- yodon 9y agoAs someone not remotely in the target audience for Teen Vogue, I’m amazed at how often high grade articles from that masthead appear in my feeds. Not a title I would have expected to associate with actual journalism
- anigbrowl 9y agoSame. They got new editorship a year or two back that questioned the conventional wisdom that teenage girls are only interested in shallow things and adjusted the content accordingly, which seems to be working quite well for them.
- MarkPNeyer 9y agoActual journalism often means pissing off wealthy or powerful people. This suggests that the more powerful and wealthy a journalistic outlet gets, the less interested it is in actual journalism.
- mreome 9y agoIt's a sad commentary on the state of things when Comedy Central, HBO, and Teen Vogue are host to some of the more well researched and thoughtful news reports.
- orbitingpluto 9y agoNature abhors a vacuum.
- anigbrowl 9y agoTo add some context to this, here's a summary post that's being shared in the sex worker community. Not included yet: Amazon delisting many "adult themed" fiction (ie text, not graphics) e-books and removing them from sales figures, and a mass migration to/adoption of Protonmail and signal. You can keep up with this issue on Twitter by following the #FuckSESTA tag. --- SESTA passed Congress a week ago. It still hasn't been signed into law, yet in the past week all of the following have already happened: * Reddit banned most subreddits dedicated to sales. In addition to preventing sex workers from promoting their content, this also banned subreddits dedicated to guns, drugs, and even homebrewing beer. * Craigslist completely removed their personals section. In addition to preventing sex workers from having a platform to screen potential clients, this means that there is no more meeting people for dating or casual sex via Craigslist. The much-loved "Missed Connections" board was also briefly taken down, before being migrated elsewhere. * Google Drive banned the sharing of porn, shutting down one of the easiest outlets for performers to send direct-sales and to share edits of content with each other. Many performers lost their entire life's work as Google has banned performers from saving their own content once it gets flagged. * Consensual Sex Work advertising sites CityVibe and Nightshift have shut down completely. * Microsoft has banned all "inappropriate" or "offensive" content from its platforms. They claim they reserve the right to view everyone's Skype calls to determine whether any violations occur, which is a huge privacy violation. In addition to preventing cam performers from doing private shows and full service sex workers from screening clients, this also prevents long distance couples from being intimate with each other over camera. These rules also apply to XBox and Office, so one can conceivably be banned for writing erotica on Microsoft Word. SESTA isn't even law yet and it has already destroyed internet freedom. This bill impacts everyone and will completely change how humans are "allowed" to interact with each other. Yet because the bill is explicitly designed to target sex workers, none of the people who would otherwise be up in arms are saying anything. The hatred of sex workers will destroy us all unless we all stand up and fight.
- aphextron 9y agoHere me out on this. Maybe the internet needs this. Maybe we need a clear delineation between the PG, corporate sanctioned mass market internet, and the real web. I couldn't possibly care less what arbitrary decision Reddit makes about it's content policies, because that's not how the internet works. No one will just throw up their hands and say "welp, guess we can't talk about that stuff anymore.". New communities will form. New services will thrive. This is a good thing. Perhaps this leads to users taking back the control that was rightfully theirs in the first place. I honestly feel that the combination of this legislation, combined with the massive backlash against social media 2.0 and the rise of blockchain tech, we are on the eve of a true paradigm shift towards Web 3.0.
- mreome 9y agoI don't know how you get to the "New communities will form. New services will thrive" part of your argument. I agree there is a potentially positive outcome to a rejection of centralized social media, but this legislation will have the opposite effect. It will have a chilling effect that will push against the formation of new communities. When the established, deep-pocketed players start making these kinds of decisions out of fear of prosecution, how is this going to effect the small/new players? New communities won't be able to effectively monitor and filter their content, and won't have the resources to defend themselves in court. At best "that stuff" will move to sketchy and ephemeral locations similar to file sharing "pirate" sties. At worse your web 3.0 will consist of nothing but "PG, corporate sanctioned mass market internet".
- jayess 9y agoBring back newsgroups!
- anigbrowl 9y agoI kind of agree with you and don't think you should be downvoted. It's true that environmental pressures will probably accelerate the development of more federated and free (not as in beer) services. I've longed for a rebirth of NNTP, for example. However the downside of this faith technology and markets is that many people who don't have the capital/know-how to stay ahead of that are going to get crushed under the legal steamroller in the meantime, and police and prosecutors have a habit fo going after easy targets and relying on popular prejudice to get away with it. Nobody in the sex work community is in favor of human trafficking, and it's a real thing that should definitely be curtailed. But curtailing organized crime takes a lot of diligent effort, so what often happens is that legislators broaden the definition of crime and then law enforcement sweeps up marginalized people to make quotas that support budget requests. My SW friends tell this has been a perennial problem and also have harsh words for the 'nonprofit industrial complex' which vacuums up a lot of grant money but requires a steady supply of victims to assist in order to maintain their cash flow. Naturally that sector lobbies government, and so do sex workers, but since sex workers often find themselves in a legal grey area to start with any sort of political organizing on their part actually exposes them to greater liability.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI don't know how to say this well, and I often get a lot of flak on HN for trying to say it at all. People don't like having their normal sex life compared to prostitution in any way, shape or form. But the fact that I get so much flak suggests it hits a nerve. There is no clear demarcation between sex work and non commercial sex. Dating frequently involves a man spending money on a woman in hopes of getting laid. Sexual relationships almost never occur in isolation from material aspects of our lives. As one example, heterosexual sex can lead to babies. So we routinely try to parse "Can this guy support a child if the union results in one?" That's a moral question where creating a child and being unable to provide for it is irresponsible. So there is no means whatsoever to completely separate money and sexual morality. The relationship between the two is complicated, but it doesn't work to try to pretend you can simply and conveniently separate sex and material stuff. The fact that there is no clear cut demarcation point between non commercial sex and commercial sex is why Craigslist pulled all its personal sections in reaction to this. So, logically, this potentially endangers all dating sites and hookup apps. One possible path of progression: With no spaces left devoted to the needs of sex workers, dating sites and hookup apps could become a means of solicitation and then all activities on such sites would become suspect and no one could even ask who is paying for coffee when they meet. I am not very familiar with this legislation, but "throwing the baby out with the bathwater" doesn't begin to capture the kinds of negative consequences we are already seeing in reaction to this. This is apparently so deeply anti sex that it isn't remotely limited to being anti commercial sex. I find myself baffled at the capacity of the human race to superficially pretend we are doing something good and moral while just being sexually hung up and apparently wanting to hatefully punish people for having any sexual impetus at all. This is my second attempt to try to express some of this. I would appreciate it if folks don't scream at me about how sex in their marriage is not an act of prostitution. It's a pointless derail of the conversation that just makes me feel "Me thinks thou doth protest too much." It would be nice if people would stick to the topic of consequences of these laws instead of acting like I have said "You, yes you, are just buying sex from your wife and she clearly does not love you." I said no such thing.
- arthur_pryor 9y agoI have nothing of substance to add to this comment, but I agree with absolutely everything you've said, and I hope you don't get downvoted. I can't really add any nuance, because I don't know where in the weeds we might disagree. I realize that my comment isn't very substantive, and I'm pretty low-karma, but I think you're generally a thoughtful commenter from what I've seen, and I think more people need to read what you've said and mull it over and at least do the thought exercise of seeing how they might agree with you, even if they determine that they ultimately do not agree with you. Please, let's legalize and regulate prostitution.
- mattsfrey 9y agoRegardless of your political persuasion / values, it seems the common theme in the last year and moving forward is an insidious removal of civil liberties. This is how it begins, with the fringe. It only balloons out further from there.
- snarfy 9y agoAs long as you film it you are OK.