4 ms·
There is a very variable gap between novice, amateur and professional in different sports - and I think the closer to "natural human movement" the sport is the
by lifeisstillgood 9y ago
There is a very variable gap between novice, amateur and professional in different sports - and I think the closer to "natural human movement" the sport is the greater the gap.
for example, you could pick any one from the Olympic stadium, give them running shoes and there would be zero chance they would be anything but last over the finishing line.
For something like football (soccer) the gap is almost as large - you could take any enthusiastic amateur and put them in the premiership and the results would be obviously bad. Only as you go up the amateur skill rankins would you start to see a closing of the gap - and football / soccer has spent so long honing that gap that even professional players in the second division would usually be shown to be woefully inadequate (Leicester City being the exception proving the rule)
But NHL hockey has a huge amount of skill / equipment / training needs before even starting a game - and so the gap between amateur and top player is much smaller than we expect.
What I guess I am saying is that 99% of humanity could cross the finish line in an olympic spring (seconds off the time obviously but still finish). but probably 99% of humanity could not even stand up on the ice let alone skate and hit a puck.
As such i conjecture that professional hockey has a lot further it can stretch that gap between top professional and amateur - in other words the team that finds how to develop its skills so that a third string goalie would never stand a chance is a team that will lift a lot of trophies.
- timw0j 9y agoAnother comment I saw elsewhere said that the Elite league he plays in regularly is full of very good amateur/ex-pro players as well. It's not like they picked up a guy off the street and threw the pads on him. He had a ton of experience playing against players just below the caliber of current NHL players. That's not to diminish what he did though. It's amazing that the NHL has something like this place, and the guy seems to have taken it very very well with a lot of humility.
- zf00002 9y agoAt least two levels below. Those good amateurs and ex-pros would be in a minor league team if they were good enough.
- notfromhere 9y agoIt might be difficult to play in a minor league if you have a legitimate career.
- gringoDan 9y agoNot necessarily. If you are college-educated, can make high-five-figures / six-figures as an accountant, and have given up on the NHL dream, why schlep it for less of half that salary in the minors? Not to mention if you have a family and don't want to take long bus trips to away games all winter. For marginal players, being semi-pro is as much of a lifestyle choice & opportunity cost calculation as a statement of ability.
- RobLach 9y agoMinor league hockey players earn on average ~$43,000 / 6 month season. Factor in health risks, job insecurity, and being on the road most of the time it becomes much less appealing.
- mkobit 9y agoI think you are greatly understating the difference between amateurs and top players in the NHL. Watching the players coming from the feeder leagues to the NHL, you can tell that there can be a _huge_ difference in skill. The Blackhawks this season are a good example to look at. If you just compare the goalies this year you will see a large difference. Corey Crawford has been their goaltender for 2 Stanley Cup championships, and was injured in the middle of this year. He has not played since then, and it has forced the team to try and find a replacement. I think looking at the statistics shows the difference even between the most elite goalies and those that are close to that level. W is wins, L is losses, GAA is "goals against average" per game, SV% is save percentage - Corey Crawford: 16 W, 9 L, 2.27 GAA, .929 SV% - Anton Forsberg: 10 W, 16 L, 2.97 GAA, .908 SV% - Jeff Glass: 3 W, 6 L, 3.31 GAA, .898 SV% - J-F Berube: 2 W, 5 L, 3.93 GAA, .891 SV% Statistics taken from ESPN [1] [1]: http://www.espn.com/nhl/team/stats/_/name/chi/chicago-blackhawks http://www.espn.com/nhl/team/stats/_/name/chi/chicago-blackh...
- gringoDan 9y agoWhich of these metrics would be most important in evaluating a goalie? I know nothing about hockey, but my intuition would be that you can throw W/L out the window - if you have an amazing offensive team you could let in 5 goals a game and still win. GAA is a reflection of both the team's defensive ability and the goalie's performance. It seems like SV% is the "purest" metric to compare apples to apples here. Unless I'm only looking at first-order effects here and the team's entire strategy changes based on who is in goal...
- s2g 9y agoSave percentage, but none are that great. Save percentage of .908 is not great for an NHL goalie.
- kd5bjo 9y agoAll of the stats are heavily affected by what the rest of the team is doing. If the team knows it's playing in front of a weak goalie, they'll play more defensively so that more shots are blocked in the field and only lower-percentage shots ever make it to the goal in the first place, raising the SV%.
- rsync 9y ago"There is a very variable gap between novice, amateur and professional in different sports - and I think the closer to "natural human movement" the sport is the greater the gap." I find your comment interesting but I am not so sure it is correct ... I have heard it convincingly argued that hitting a major league pitcher is as difficult a task to complete as anything else in sports - and it appears to be true. The gap between someone who can do that and everyone else is huge and also appears to be innate - either you can do that or you can't. And yet, it's a completely arbitrary action that has no real relation to natural movements. Also, as long as I'm picking apart your argument - skiing has all kinds of specialized, unnatural equipment (like a hockey goalie) and it is not a natural movement ... and yet if you picked a random spectator from the crowd to make it down the super G, they might fare even worse than your spectator for the footrace.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoI think those are similar arguments - there are some sports (NHL, skiing) that are just difficult - the bar is high immediately just to be able to take part. These sports seem to have a smaller gap between the lowest performer and the top players - either because anyone able to compete at all is already quite good, or as i suspect, that the top players are not as good at say hockey, as the top sprinters are at running - partly because you are selecting from a smaller population, partly because (and this is my point) there is still a long way for humans to go to manage the skills - Usain Bolt is considered to be near the limits of human performance (what is physically possible with levers the length of a human thigh etc) - but that is not the case with ice skates etc how shall i put this ? Moneyball teaches us that baseball is unlikely to be the only sport that would see huge gains by rejecting industry machismo. Could NHL see gains from basic changes? yes. Do i know what those are ? No.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoLet's redo this. I can happily imagine that every child in the USA gets to find out if they are any good at hitting a baseball (#). So we can be fairly sure that the population of possible baseball picks is as wide as it can be - and is a proper bell curve. But the population of those who have had chance to skate on ice and hit a puck is, even in canada, is not as wide as possible- so it won't be a bell curve - maybe double hump? this gives us in my head a situation where even the top players in NHL are not the best possible from the whole country - but the baseball players are closer to that ideal because they draw from a more complete bell curve. as such i speculate that NHL top players are not as good as possible because - the top players are not the best possible from population compared to say sprinting - the set of all players is more closely grouped (thinner curve) so any player is closer in ability to top players than say sprinting - most sports probably still have plenty of "moneyball" left on the table All of which is a long winded way of saying, if there is a sport where a non-professional can come in and perform distinguishedly, then there should be plenty of scope for investment and improvement and so consequent profit (wins at any rate) (#) every male child at least, but let's not go down that road now.
- kakwa_ 9y agoIn soccer, the gap is not always that high. In France, for example, there are a few examples of lower levels teams reaching the semi-finals or even the final of the national cup. I remember for example Calais in 1999 or 2000 (amateurs forth division), they reached the final, losing quite honorably to Nantes (a top flight team) and beating one or two second division teams, and two first division teams including Bordeaux (first division champion the previous year, and still in the top 5 in 2000). And it's not an isolated case, there are other examples. I would agree that a cup leaves more room for surprises as everything is decided on one match. And generally over the course of a complete season, things tend to equalize, teams with better players get better results overall. But, first, soccer is a team sport, meaning that it's not because you have 11 great players that you get a great team (Porto win in the 2004 Champions League comes to mind, it was a really elegant team, able to unbalance the other teams with a well oiled system and very precise ball circulation and placement). Secondly, the formation schools of professional clubs create a lot of very decent players, but not all these players make it to top flight teams. A lot of them end-up in second to forth level divisions. So a lot of these players were educated to be professionals players with all that entails in term of life hygen, tactical understanding, knowledge of training exercises, etc. Thirdly, there is "amateur" and "amateur", in the forth level (which is amateur in France), the training is quite extensive, the players trains everyday after work (and very commonly, they take part time jobs to do it). It's not as extensive as professional clubs trainings, but it's a world away from amateurs training once a week at most, and taking a beer after there sunday game. So amateurs, specially ones that train a lot and with potentially a professional background can do well, or even very well over the course of one match.