3 ms·
> Not even having a "probation" time after people have been released from prison; they did their time, they are free again I think you're mistaken about what p
by chrisseaton 9y ago
> Not even having a "probation" time after people have been released from prison; they did their time, they are free again
I think you're mistaken about what probation is.
Probation is part of your time. You're sentenced for a given period of time, and at some point you may be released to serve the rest of that time in the community, on probation.
Their sentence isn't over, and they aren't 'free' while they are on probation. It's part of the original sentence still.
Probation allows people to serve part of their sentences back in the community when they are safe to do so. If you're arguing against having probation you're arguing for longer time spent in prison.
- cornholio 9y ago> Probation is part of your time. Yes, but it's a part that is substantially different from imprisonment: you are given a chance to prove yourself (Latin probo, probatio, French prover) to society. It should be as close to the life of a virtuos citizen as possible - and exerting a right to vote, far from being a personal gain, is exactly the type of pro-social behavior we should encourage. I can understand why she should be reprimanded for violating her probation, but it's revolting that voting during probation could be considered a violation. Something is seriously wrong in a society that does that.
- maxerickson 9y agoIf you're arguing against having probation you're arguing for longer time spent in prison. Not necessarily. edit: It's entirely possible to oppose halfway programs and also advocate for shorter sentencing...
- Retric 9y agoMany people feel that probation is inherently unethical. X years of probation seems less harsh than X years in prison but often amount to the same thing. Without the option of probation prison time is not going to increase 1:1 and depending on the ratio total time in prison may actually decrease.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 9y agoWho are these people? How many of them are ex-convicts?
- mushbino 9y agoWhen you're on reporting probation you essentially lose all of your rights. The rules are incredibly strict and your probation officer can come find you any time of day. If they call you and you don't answer the phone that can be considered a violation of your probation. Straight to jail. They can come in your house and search 24/7. They can send you to jail indefinitely for any reason or no reason at all. Body cavity search any time they want. Speeding ticket? Straight to jail. Late to work? Straight to jail. Outside of your house after 10pm? Straight to jail. Didn't go to enough AA meetings this week? Straight to jail. Not able to pay court fines? Jail. Left city limits without permission? Guess what. Attempt to vote? Five fucking years!
- mushbino 9y agoI think you're mistaken about how probation is used in practice. Many small offenses will get you put on probation for ten years. Parole and work release are more often used as alternatives to incarceration. The main issue here is whether or not people on probation should be allowed to vote. I don't see why they shouldn't and I can't see any justification for putting them in jail if they do. It's absolutely absurd.
- tialaramex 9y agoThe US frames prison as primarily revenge, it's about taking things away from "bad" people. Take away their nice things, destroy their family, make sure they'll never get a decent job and so on. The EU (and most modern actual thinking on the issue) says prison primarily lets us force convicts to reform, we can impose structure in their lives, show them how to be good - and in the worst case we keep them there if they refuse to reform. The British government fought and lost a legal battle to retain the status where prisoners can't legally vote (and many people who are in jail but aren't convicted of any crime don't end up being able to vote even though it's legal). The EU said that's not OK. You can target criminals who e.g. are in prison for vote tampering, but you can't take away people's vote just because they're in prison since they're still citizens.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]