6 ms·
This is awesome to hear, and for all of the criticism Cloudflare has gotten in the past, they have spoken loudly against censorship, not just for people they li
by ocdtrekkie 9y ago
This is awesome to hear, and for all of the criticism Cloudflare has gotten in the past, they have spoken loudly against censorship, not just for people they like, but those they dislike as well. I'd much rather point my DNS at them than Google, an ad company where tracking is the whole business model.
- durkie 9y agoReally? Didn't the CEO kick stormfront off Cloudflare because they thought they were assholes?
- gsich 9y agoCorrect
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoSpecifically, the Cloudflare CEO kicked the Daily Stormer off of Cloudflare because the Daily Stormer had been suggesting that Cloudflare secretly supported them/their politics: https://blog.cloudflare.com/why-we-terminated-daily-stormer/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/why-we-terminated-daily-stormer/ Had the Daily Stormer folks kept their mouths shut, they probably would've been fine. And then Cloudflare continues on to describe why they don't think companies should censor content, whereas Google has numerous blogs and entire technologies revolving around how to censor content even more than they do now.
- Gigablah 9y agoAh yes. There’s nothing to censor if you keep your mouth shut ;)
- dictum 9y agoThere's a difference between saying "[highly controversial statement]. We know company X will not censor us." and "[highly controversial statement]. We know company X will not censor us because the people at company X are really on our side!"
- notatoad 9y agoEspecially when "our side" is literally Nazis.
- corobo 9y agoThey really should have booted them for that reasoning rather than by feeling. They even have it in their Terms of Service (and when I looked, did have it at the time of terminating the site) > Section 18 - Because Cloudflare has no control over such sites and resources, you acknowledge and agree that Cloudflare is not responsible for the availability of such external sites or resources, and does not endorse and is not responsible or liable for any content, advertising, products, or other materials on or available from such sites or resources. It's a clear ToS breach, a bit of thought would have avoided the whole thing. You got lawyers on hand? Talk to lawyers!
- kbenson 9y agoThere's a difference between supporting someone's free speech in general and whether you want to continue with them in a business relationship because they are abusing you specifically. I may support my friend's right to free speech in general, but if they are at my house and start bad-mouthing myself and my family, I'll ask them to leave. They can still say what they want (if not libel/slander), but they don't need to do it in my house. They can go say it elsewhere.
- creeble 9y agoThere are still plenty of assholes using CloudFlare.
- cagenut 9y agoto me thats almost the exception that proves the rule. if someone tells me they have a 100% SLA I write them off as a liar, but tell me you have a 99.995% SLA and have only ever had this one exception and here's why, that builds much more trust with me.
- jcahill 9y agoYour reasoning is like saying "the canary only disappeared once, and knowing that it can indeed disappear bolsters my confidence in it now that it has returned." It's plainly wrong. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exception_that_proves_the_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exception_that_proves_the_rule
- kbenson 9y agoNo, it's a matter of reality matching expectations. If you expect that the SLA has very likely been violated at some point, hearing that it has not means you should believe you have just been very likely lied to given your existing knowledge, unless you are considering that statement as a source of truth itself. If you expect that the SLA has very likely been violated at some point, hearing that it has at some point means that the statement confirms to what you already believe to be true given your existing knowledge. That doesn't mean the statement is true, but since it's not obviously conflicting with what you already believe to be true, it at least allows you to believe it is not immediately false. Instead of thinking about it increasing the likelihood of being entirely true, think about it as decreasing the likelihood it's entirely false. Depending on your point of view that may not be much, but it's something.
- jcahill 9y agoAbsolutely not. >No, it's a matter of reality matching expectations. What an agent tells me is what they choose to tell me. You're describing some sort of luck-based updating via that third party's choice. I don't live in a tinseltown universe full of model trains and animatronic NPCs. None of us do. All reasoning about real-world agents is subject to incomplete information and uncertainty. That much is trivial. More, it's mutually understood to be the case. Also mutually understood: basic world knowledge stemming from the same. These are principles simple enough to be patronizing in written description, yet persistently ignored or misused at implementation-level. Like: 1. Actors are variably susceptible to errors in reasoning under uncertainty 2. Actors are variably skilled at exploiting 1 to modulate 3rd party behavior 3. Actors are variably motivated to make use of 1-2 It follows from the above that allowing an actor to subtly shift your expectations as if you ever held a platonic model of their behavior is simply a cognitive error. There's no way around it. Take the "99.995% SLA" example. In the absence of that figure, would you have assumed a God-Mode level of performance? Clearly not. You can cross all the factors like whether you care about the figure, whether it's above or below average, whether disclosure is standard in this context, … to just enumerate all the cases and see clearly that there's no time when this information is surprising. I mean, just look at a top google hit for SLA⁽¹⁾. You really think a CIO reader is in any way surprised to hear that some metric they negotiated into a contract indeed holds? Or that it doesn't? Continuing: A figure like 99.995% is well within reasonable bounds for any number of business processes, so it's not necessarily false precision here. What it almost definitely is, however, is precision in pursuit of persuasion. There are plenty of industries for which exacting figures at the high end of some performance criterion — manufacturing quality, service availability, measurement accuracy, etc — are essential to informed consumer behavior. Those industries almost universally have norms or regulations setting out certain expectations about what will be found on a specsheet, how units will be tested, how this information will be reported. If not, the spiel is just spiel. Facts and figures as token gestures of fallibility, however, are confidence tricks. I already know you're fallible. You cannot sway this comprehension by reframing around some very likely sort of figure: charm pricing⁽²⁾ and related uses of odd figures are marketing weaselry targeting plebs. To point these things in the direction of clientele is to tell them how much you think of their ability to resist bullshit-fatigue. My feels about whether I'd wanna have a beer with <The Guy>, modulated by his current demeanor toward me or whatever audience he imagines me to be a member of, do not determine his fitness for any high-stakes job. The same is true here. Cloudflare is in the MITM business. Absolutely trusted at no point in time, independent of whatever cost/benefit has gone into the decision to use a MITM. This isn't even defeated by being too big a client to lose: if you were big enough to be a lifeline for cloudflare, you'd have no need for cloudflare. ____________________ ¹ https://www.cio.com/article/2438284/outsourcing/outsourcing-sla-definitions-and-solutions.html https://www.cio.com/article/2438284/outsourcing/outsourcing-... ² http://enwp.org/Psychological_pricing http://enwp.org/Psychological_pricing
- notafxn 9y agoThey will kick you off if you're a white supremacist, but not if you're a carder or a phisher.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- discussedbefore 9y agoCloudflare has dropped the Daily Stormer https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15029852 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15029852 (August 2017) > I wonder if this signals a more general change in attitude CloudFlare CEO says his Daily Stormer takedown was “arbitrary” and “dangerous” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15034304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15034304 > If this is true [Daily Stormer made the claim that CloudFlare were secretly supporters], then I agree with the takedown [...] But in this interview, the CEO says something totally different The Terrifying Power of Internet Censors https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15238415 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15238415 (September 2017) > If you think that [...] government has a tendency to suppress dissent, then censoring [...] is just opening the door and setting a precedent ‘Daily Stormer’ Termination Haunts Cloudflare in Online Piracy Case https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15377292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15377292 > Cloudflare set up a limit to what they allow or not so now they will have to fight where that limit is
- emilfihlman 9y agoThey do censorship if they like to do it.
- throwaway4719 9y agoLike when the CEO randomly feels like it because he woke up being annoyed. But otherwise, totally not.
- gsich 9y agoDo Cloudflare websites work from TOR then?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIt appears they put a lot of work into how to handle Tor without being extremely frustrating: https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-trouble-with-tor/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/the-trouble-with-tor/
- gpm 9y agoUp to the website operator. Cloudflare actually went out of their way to make it easy to whitelist Tor IPs that would generally get automatictly blacklisted for abuse.
- f2n 9y agoThey also went out of their way to automatically treat them as more questionable by default. Unless the website operator explicitly whitelists tor, tor users are given a worse experience. EDIT: Maybe not anymore? See replies
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoThis probably isn't really correct. Their blog says that 94% of the traffic they were getting over Tor was malicious, and since they probably automatically put IPs where a lot of malicious traffic comes from on the CAPTCHA list, my guess is all the Tor nodes got flagged automagically. What they went out of their way to do, was explicitly make it less painful for legitimate users to use Tor, despite the amount of malicious content they get from Tor. I'd argue for most companies, if 94% of the traffic from somewhere is malicious, the answer is "block it and be done with it", but clearly, Cloudflare actually values Tor and what it stands for enough to come up with a workaround.
- xxdesmus 9y ago"They also went out of their way to automatically treat them as more questionable by default." nope, you're spreading un-sourced/unconfirmed FUD. Provide a source, or this is just FUD. Tor IPs are treated like any other IP by default, not "more questionable by default".
- eis 9y agoOn the other hand they've also censored some of their users without being legally obliged to do so on a couple occasions. They don't have a clean track record. I'd rather point my DNS settings at my own server than anyone elses.
- scrollaway 9y agoI would much rather have a company with a long but nearly clean track record, than a short and spotless one. The difference is that when a company with a spotless record decides it's time to change their ways, it can be a pretty radical change (look at Reddit). But with cloudflare I know we're a long way from that. It's kind of absurd how everyone expects spotless companies. I'd like to live in that world as well but the reality of this one is that such companies do not exist. Cloudflare gets criticism on both too much censorship and not enough. I don't envy them...
- eis 9y agoMy last point was that DNS is supposed to be decentralized. With a properly decentralized system, censorship becomes very difficult. We shouldn't rely on someone like Cloudflare or Google to provide us with DNS services.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIt's a decentralized service, but at the end of the day, your PC's going to check one address. If it's not Cloudflare/Google/Quad9/etc., you're just going to be checking against your ISP. It's pretty beneficial, especially in certain countries, to have alternatives to the ISP's DNS.
- scrollaway 9y agoSo what's your thinking here? Cloudflare shouldn't offer to be one of the many pillars of that properly decentralized system? I don't believe we are going to suddenly flock to cloudflare to provide all dns ever. Between ISPs hardcoding or force-defaulting their own (awful) dns servers, and the amount of geeks and IT techs who have memorized 8.8.8.8, we're safe for a long time. And if I'm wrong on that, that wouldn't speak highly of the "decentralized" nature of DNS, would it?
- cm2187 9y agoHow much tracking can you do on a v4 DNS? There can be thousands of people behind the same IPv4 at a given time, or it could change in a matter of minutes. A state could probably be able to exploit that (as in there is a political opponent living at this address) but if the aim is just to track an individual’s browsing habit I would think it is impractical. IPv6, other debate.
- tambre 9y agoWell, they do seem to plan to offer IPv6 DNS. And you'll probably want to be using that anyway, although they don't seem to recommend using that, as they mention it only briefly.
- ballenf 9y agoMy home IPv4 address from a major cable internet company hasn't changed in over a year and I don't have a static IP. Even when they do change, knowing ping times plus IP address owner plus superficial usage patterns would easily be enough to narrow down to a single household. Many households will have a unique DNS footprint based on the exact makeup of internet connected devices in the household that are constantly phoning home.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoPeople do often forget this about DHCP addresses: Most DHCP servers will renew your same IP for as long as practical, and this often spans years. At work, my NIC held its same lease for about two years, I was a little sad recently when I discovered it had finally changed. How I monitor my house also lets me know when my public address changes, and its extremely rare.
- huslage 9y agoI have an IPv6 address that has never changed. My IPv4 address changes fairly often. The DHCP servers most definitely log the end-point MAC which can be tied directly by the ISP to my modem and router behind it. It's fairly easy to trace this stuff, if somewhat impractical.
- ebikelaw 9y agoThe privacy statements on this service are vague. Google makes specific and strong guarantees about what it does with DNS service logs. Google does not keep DNS logs with client IPs longer than 48 hours. I also note that Cloudflare doesn't make a performance comparison with Google DNS.
- detaro 9y ago"We will never log your IP address" doesn't sound that vague.
- ebikelaw 9y agoBut it is. They don't say what they do log. For example if I zero out the highest octet of your IP address and I log the ASN, I have effectively identified you without "logging your IP address".
- hoschicz 9y agoI know nothing about how auditing companies like the stated KPMG work. If Cloudflare did this, would they pass the audit?
- kyrra 9y agoGoogle is very transparent about what they log with their public DNS servers[0]. [0] https://developers.google.com/speed/public-dns/privacy https://developers.google.com/speed/public-dns/privacy
- majewsky 9y agoAnd how do we know this information is accurate?
- corobo 9y agoLawyers exist and any case against Google would be a huge payday in settlement alone
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoTo sue someone for doing something illegal, you first need some evidence that they're doing it. Google heavily employs confidentiality for that reason. Case in point: Antitrust investigations across the globe were launched into the Android MADA... but that didn't happen until years later, when the confidential agreements were revealed in the Oracle v. Google case. As long as nobody knew what was happening, it went unpoliced. One of the ongoing HR-related lawsuits explicitly claims Google prohibits employees from revealing illegal conduct that the company engages in.
- corobo 9y agoFair point, I was unaware of the HR-related lawsuit