12 ms·
> Acrylamide is created when starchy foods are roasted Does this mean that potatoes should come with a warning? And bread?
by maccard 9y ago
> Acrylamide is created when starchy foods are roasted
Does this mean that potatoes should come with a warning? And bread?
- awinder 9y agoSpecifically thought to be caused by the Maillard reaction, which includes grilled / seared foods
- harshreality 9y agoSteaming or even pressure-cooking potatoes (or any other food) at <121C/250F doesn't produce substantial amounts of acrylamide. It's only higher-temp cooking (frying, baking) that's bad. If you like bread, sucks to be you. Bread is a filler for when better foods are scarce or too expensive. The kinds of bread that are affordable on a tight budget are awful; good bread (still not that good for you, but at least whole grain, low sugar, maybe some added seeds and nuts) is expensive. The added cost for "good" bread comes from the expensive healthy additions, so the healthier the bread is, the more it approximates the cost of the seeds/nuts/fruits/etc with only a token amount of bread dough to hold everything together, and you're not saving any money compared to eating those nutritional foods raw or lightly cooked. Baking also reduces the amounts of most nutrients, so even the good additions to good bread aren't as healthy as eating them separately. ETA: I'm not talking about how bread tastes. I don't dispute that bread tastes good. That's why people eat it. Like most carbs, if all you have is bread you will keep eating it until you get sick or you force yourself to quit still feeling hungry... that's the curse of carbs. Tasting good and being temporarily addictive is not the same as being good for you. Adding bread to other stuff as part of a sandwich does not make the bread magically better for you.
- cup-of-tea 9y ago> If you like bread, sucks to be you. Bread is a filler for when better foods are scarce or too expensive; I would say it's not part of a good diet. If you think that then it sucks to be you. Good bread is a joy.
- mi100hael 9y ago> Bread is a filler for when better foods are scarce or too expensive Or, you know, the key ingredient in a class of highly popular and convenient foods called sandwiches.
- lostlogin 9y ago> If you like bread, sucks to be you. Bread is a filler for when better foods are scarce or too expensive; I would say it's not part of a good diet. Eat better bread. Seriously. There is a reason it used to eaten a lot more than it is now, and that’s because by and large it’s badly made now. Well made bread with proper incredients is fantastic. Methods such as the Chorleywood process have removed most of the good and all the taste. Bread requires flour, water and salt. Be sceptical is there is much more than that. Crust is better with a little added sugar or honey and a little fat helps texture and flavour. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chorleywood_bread_process https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chorleywood_bread_process
- kabdib 9y agoIt's incredibly easy to make bread. It's not even labor-intensive or expensive: You can often find used bread machines at a second-hand shop for about ten dollars, and the ingredients for a loaf of bread are a fraction the cost of a commercial loaf. I make good bread a couple times a week, for maybe fifty cents a loaf.
- harshreality 9y agoGood bread for $0.50/loaf? By what metric is it good? It tastes good? I never disputed that cheap bread can taste good. It has a token amount of good additives? Sure, you can do that, and it makes the bread sound healthy, without actually being healthy. Let's assume the loaf is 1 pound (likely slightly more). You claim $0.50 ingredients in that 1 lb. Cheap flour is what, I see $0.02/oz at walmart (25lb bulk), so that's $0.32 per loaf, max. You've added 18 cents of other ingredients. (Edit: factoring in water, more like $0.15-0.20 of flour, so 30-35 cents for healthy additives). You can't buy much with 35 cents. The bread is still a bunch of empty carbs combined with some healthy food (baked, so a bunch of the nutrients are reduced. You can make more expensive bread that's 1 or 5 dollars too, it doesn't change the fact that bread is mostly empty carbs, plus whatever you added that you could have eaten separately and gotten more nutrients from.
- maxerickson 9y agoLike 1/3 or more of the weight of the final product will be water. There's also really nothing wrong with calories. Most people need something like 2000 a day, leaves plenty of room for eating things just for taste.
- redial 9y agoYou seem to think the only "good" bits of bread are seeds and nuts some people add. That is not bread. Bread is water, flour and yeast, and salt optionally. Great bread doesn't have to be expensive and it doesn't need anything extra. And "healthy additives" doesn't make bad bread good.
- unethical_ban 9y agoLiterally every person below you mistook your post to be about the flavor or quality of bread, instead of being about the health of the consumer.
- redial 9y ago> If you like bread, sucks to be you. Bread is a filler for when better foods are scarce or too expensive. No misinterpretation needed. Bread is not a filler. Some people (most?) eat it because they enjoy it. They actively seek it even when "better" options are available.
- unethical_ban 9y agoHis/her communication isn't the most clear, but the point being made is that bread is not healthy, and that it essential to current human population size, but the species would be better off not consuming it ideally. That it should be seen as a treat, as something to eat despite its effect on the body, not because of it. tl;dr Paleo diet.
- ralph0 9y agoAnecdote Alert! A very knowledgeable Chinese doctor (acupuncturist, trained on the mainland)warned me of this decades ago. She said that for my body type, coffee was extremely bad. She explained (in her broken English)that the coffee contained "fire" due to the way the beans were processed and that this could make me more susceptible to cancer. Grilled food was also a no-no (for me). Baked & fried foods? For most people, fuggedaboudit! I can't help but notice the latest research is beginning to show exactly what she told me all those years ago.
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoMy very knowledgeable statistics professor (my professor beats your doctor) told me that extraordinary claims ("fire" content from grilling causing cancer) require extraordinary evidence (say, some science behind)
- kabes 9y agoYep, recently there was a small uproar here in Belgium when the EU wanted restrictions on the baking of fries because of this exact reason. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jun/20/chips-are-down-for-belgian-frites-as-eu-acts-on-chemical https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jun/20/chips-are-down...