3 ms·
How about "guilty beyond all reasonable doubt" as a burden of proof for our systems of judgment. As much as that sucks sometimes. If the government can't prov
by busterarm 9y ago
How about "guilty beyond all reasonable doubt" as a burden of proof for our systems of judgment. As much as that sucks sometimes.
If the government can't prove its case, it probably shouldn't be getting to a jury either.
- ethbro 9y agoIt's pretty easy to cover your tracks if you're not an idiot and know what you're doing, and I assume a lot of the people that make big insider trading plays are neither. So hamstringing the SEC with an arbitrarily high standard just facilitates continued insider trading. Agreed on the full burden of proof for penalties. But having your gains clawed back is a different fish entirely.
- curun1r 9y agoIf the SEC pursues a civil case where the penalty is only fines and not prison, the standard need only be a "preponderance of evidence." It's much easier to prove that some of these executives probably knew about the news when they sold their shares.
- busterarm 9y agoYeah our civil court system fucking sucks. Edit: I used to work in the legal industry nearly exclusively in civil court.
- mulmen 9y agoCan you elaborate? In what specific ways does it suck? Do you have any suggestions for improvement?
- ISL 9y agoWith a lower standard for guilt, a greater number of innocent people will be fined by our government, for which we are ultimately responsible.
- jonathanyc 9y agoA greater number than are currently charged, sure, but a far smaller number in absolute terms causing a far larger amount of damage than the ordinary Americans for whom a criminal charge—which is made essentially entirely at the discretion of the DA—will remain on their records permanently, affecting their ability to travel and obtain jobs.
- p49k 9y agoTo zero out someone’s gains in this situation, as suggested by the parent poster in cases where no proof exists, would simply be a regulation to hold one financially responsible for his/her company’s actions. Guilt or innocence doesn’t have to come into play in that scenario.
- mulmen 9y agoOstensibly the market already takes care of that in the form of stock price.
- p49k 9y agoThis entire thread is focused on the one situation where the stock price doesn't take care of it: When an employee sells their stock before a major price drop in a way that it's unclear if the employee knew about the reason behind the drop or not.
- mulmen 9y agoThe article sates that he sold stock in anticipation of the price dropping and by doing so saved himself $117,000.00. The SEC believes this to be an illegal trade so now he is facing charges. If he had traded legally the market would have punished him for the company's failings. In this situation everything seems to have worked correctly. If you think the stock price should be lower take it up with your elected representatives and see what happens when regulations are put in place.
- noobermin 9y agoHow does charging someone require "guilty beyond all reasonable doubt"? Sounds like a conflation between charging with a crime and convicting someone. Aware he said "convict" but he probably meant "charge".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- busterarm 9y agoImposition of any penalty is a conviction unless there is a voluntary plea. Charge is absolutely not what he meant, especially since that was a base he already explicitly covered.