3 ms·
The Chamber of Commerce could easily sue on the grounds that these regulations are overbroad and even the incumbent governor is on the record as saying so, but
by anigbrowl 9y ago
The Chamber of Commerce could easily sue on the grounds that these regulations are overbroad and even the incumbent governor is on the record as saying so, but the cost of compliance (displaying a sign) is low and it's handy to have something to kvetch about.
Also, note that it was a nonprofit, the American Cancer Society, that sued to enforce this, not the state of California.
- Skunkleton 9y agoYes, but the state of California is the one enforcing it.
- tedunangst 9y agoWas it the ACS or the Council for Education and Research on Toxics?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> The Chamber of Commerce could easily sue on the grounds that these regulations are overbroad There are no regulations at issue, there is an initiative statute; and, while, yes it is easy to sue and claim a statute is overbroad, it is much harder to win such a suit: “overbroad” isn't just “covers more conduct than good policy judgement would permit”, but “exceeds any constitutionally permitted purpose to impose a chilling effect or outright prohibition on constitutionally protected conduct.” In fact, as that claim would be a defense in any lawsuit under the act, if it was such an easy win, it would have been made in one of the cases—like the present one—under the act.
- anigbrowl 9y agoHmm, you make a good point. I assumed they wouldn't have standing to bring it up if they weren't litigating against the state itself, and that they were limited to arguing on the facts about the acrylamide.